Best Crib Mattress Reviews 2017

(Updated )
Choosing a crib mattress seems like an easy task, but it’s one that warrants cautious consideration. It is imperative to note that your baby will spend nearly 18 hours in their crib, so comfort and safety are of great concern in this case. Here are some of the best crib mattresses that guarantee safety and comfort for your baby.
Overview
PROS
CONS
SPECS
Material
Safety
Size
Cover
Extras
Our Top Choice
Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic Crib Mattress
Naturepedic creates organic mattresses for all age ranges, aiming to provide comfort, quality and safety. Their crib mattress is certified and designed by experts.
Lightweight. Greenguard and GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) certified. 100% Organic. Makes sheet changing easier.
Not firm enough for heavy babies.
100% organic cotton
GREENGUARD certification
6 x 27.8 x 52 inches/ 10 lbs
Waterproof
2-stage dual firmness
Best Value
Simmons Kids Ultra Deluxe 2-in-1 Crib Mattress
Simmons specializes in all kids furniture, blending beauty and safety to please everyone. When a brand slaps a lifetime warranty on a product you can bet it’s a good’un, such as their natural crib mattress.
It has a dual-purpose design for newborns and toddlers. It boasts a natural fire protection wrap. It is eco-friendly.
Heavy and rather cumbersome to remove from the crib to change sheets.
Natural Cotton
Greenguard Gold & CertiPUR-US
27.5 x 6 x 52 inches / 19.4 lbs
Water and stain resistant
Limited lifetime warranty
Colgate Eco Classica III Crib Mattress
Colgate pledges to provide quality products to parents to ensure their peace of mind. Their integrity most certainly stays intact with the Classica mattress, created with organic, superior materials.
No bad odor. Lightweight. Organic sheet cover. Eco-friendly. Dual sided and dual firmness. Fits a standard crib perfectly.
Only the cover is organic.
Memory Foam
GREENGUARD Gold certified 
51.7 x 27.5 x 6 inches/ 9.4 lbs
Certified Organic Cotton Cover
Dual Firmness
Sealy Soybean Waterproof Crib Mattress
With a brand that’s won an award for their products for babies, you can expect great things from Sealy. Their Waterproof Crib Mattress is a great example of quality and comfort combined.
Extra Lightweight. Waterproof and Stainless cover. GREENGUARD® Children & Schools Certified. High density reducing sagging and increasing durability.
Only the covers are organic.
Lightweight foam
GREENGUARD certified 
51.6 x 27.2 x 5 inches/ 8.3 lbs
Pearl embossed waterproof
Voted America's Best Baby Brand
Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress
Milliard provides mattress solutions to those on a budget but want good quality. This baby mattress is anti-microbial, for a healthier sleep, and is a unique blend of foam, for a comfortable sleep.
Reasonably priced. Washable and waterproof polyester cover. High density. Naturally hypoallergenic, antimicrobial and resilient to allergens, mold, bacteria, and dust mites.
It has a very strong unpleasant odor when still new, but it will go away quickly.
Unique blend of foam 
CertiPUR-US® certified
52 x 27.5 x 5.5 inches/ 8.7 lbs
Polyester, waterproof
Hypoallergenic Cover

Related Reviews
Best Baby Crib
Best Bassinet
Best Infant Car Seat
Best Toddler Bed

How Do I Choose the Best Crib Mattress?

Searching for a crib mattress is so important because, well, you’re baby is the most important thing in the world and you want them to be happy, healthy and, most of all, safe! The perfect crib mattress can provide all them things. Searching for a crib mattress can be daunting though because there are so many factors to consider; how thick should the mattress be? What material should it be made of? Is it certified? Will it be comfortable for my baby? And so many other questions race through your mind. To simplify it, we have broken down the considerations into price, features, construction & design and performance & ease of use to hopefully take some of the weight off your shoulders (and your babies too!).

If you are looking to purchase an infant’s crib mattress, it is paramount that you have a great baby crib to go with your mattress. We have a separate review where we present 5 excellent baby cribs that are available on the market today. We recommend that you look for a convertible crib, one that will be able to change in form and function. When choosing a crib mattress, it is also important that you pick one of the right size and which is firm enough, so that crib sheets fit snuggly and stay in place as your baby sleeps through the night.
Price
The price of crib mattresses depends heavily on their quality; therefore, the better the quality, the higher the price. When you buy a quality mattress, you get comfort, safety, and longevity in exchange for your money which is definitely a good deal. Yes, you will pay a little more for a premium mattress, but you won’t need to visit the store any time soon looking for another one.

Other factors that may influence the price include the manufacturer’s reputation and the size and density of the crib mattress. With this in mind, the market price for crib mattresses is somewhere between $18 and $500. Obviously, you can find plenty of cheap crib mattresses, but remember that the safety and health of your angel is at stake. It is better to stay away for poorly built, ridiculously cheap crib mattresses because they might be potentially dangerous, and pick one which offers decent features and doesn’t break the bank. Yes, there are such mattresses available for purchase and we have selected 5 of them to feature on this review.
Features
Crib mattresses vary depending on their make; foam, nature (organic or inorganic), and hypoallergenic capacity.
Some come with accessories and added features such as waterproof covers, mattress zipper bags, and dual-functional flip sides. Please note that low quality foam and innerspring crib mattresses have thin vinyl edgings and coverings that can tear, dry, and crack easily. If the covering is thicker, reinforced double or triple laminates, puncture-resistant, or has fine organic cotton, the longer the mattress will last.

Additionally, an innerspring crib mattress that has high-quality cushioning or has better-gauge steel will weigh more. The same applies to foam mattresses that are denser and have better quality foam. Everything that matters in a mattress is on the inside, buts cover also matters a lot. A waterproof crib mattress will serve your baby longer compared to mattresses that allows liquid and stain penetration.
Here is an overview of the features of crib mattress and brief description of each;
  • Foam Density:: The denser the better. To assess the density of a mattress, place your hands on both sides of the mattress and press. The more dense mattresses will not allow your hands to sink far. The density spec can be checked from the manufacturers’ site.
  • Foam Firmness:: A crib mattress should not conform to your palm when you press it and should snap back immediately after you press. You do not want a mattress that conform with your baby’s head.
  • Convertibility—if you are planning to use the same mattress as your child develops, buy a dual-functional (dual-firmness convertible) crib mattresses. They are firmer on the infant’s size and cushier for toddlers on the flip side. We look at some excellent dual-firmness mattresses in this article.
  • Cover— vinyl or fabric covers are normally used to cover the whole mattress. Fabric covers breathe more than vinyl ones. However, a multilayered vinyl cover will be more durable than a fabric cover. When purchasing a crib mattress, it is important to look for a three-ply cover that will add to its toughness and longevity.
  • Waterproof Covers—besides their make, it is also important to look at other cover qualities. A waterproof cover will protect your baby’s mattress from stains and liquids sipping through. The best thing about this option is that you can purchase a separate waterproof cover even if your crib mattress is not waterproof.
  • Antimicrobial Covers—do you need this new feature? Manufacturers say that such covers will slow down bacteria growth but will not prevent them.
  • Innerspring layers—this feature applies to innerspring mattresses. If you are planning on purchasing this type of mattress, consider one with several layers. The more layers a mattress has, the better the quality.
  • Border Rods—a good innerspring crib mattress should have border line rods all around its perimeter. This will better support the mattress and prevent instances of sagging when the baby plays in the crib.
  • Steel Gauge and Coil count—this also applies to innerspring mattresses. Look for a moderate to high coil count of about 135-150 and a steel gauge of 15.5 and below. In the same case, you should consider the quality of an insulator pad (a thick pad on top of a steel coil that prevents it from poking outside). A good insulator pad should be able to hold up for long.
Construction and Design
When choosing a crib mattress, there are a number of structural factors that you are supposed to consider and the first one is firmness. A baby’s mattress should be firm enough to avoid suffocation. As we just mentioned, a soft crib mattress may take the shape of to the baby’s face or head and increase the chances of suffocation. It shouldn’t be too stiff either because your baby spends over 18 hours a day sleeping, so a severely stiff mattress wouldn’t be comfortable enough. There should be proper balance in firmness for safety and comfort. The mattress’s cover also matters a lot. Remember that at this stage, babies like to spill the juice or milk a lot, so a waterproof crib mattress would be ideal for durability. Other construction and design consideration factors include functionality (dual-sided or not), weight, material type (foam or cotton), and product dimension (in terms of inches).

There are two types of crib mattresses; foam and innerspring. Either type is fine as long as you focus on a good-quality. The better the quality, the higher the safety and comfort your infant or toddler will enjoy.
  • Foam Crib Mattresses—these types are normally made using polyurethane and the covers might differ. They might be antimicrobial, organic, waterproof etc.
  • Innerspring Crib Mattresses—these types are made with several layers of better-gauge steel as well as a layer of cushioning. More layers and better cushioning add to the safety and comfort of your baby.
Performance and Ease of Use
An infant/toddler mattress should fit the crib to allow the sheets to remain static throughout your baby’s sleep hours. Additionally, a good crib mattress should be lightweight to allow for easy shifting and crib cleaning from time to time. Dual-functional crib mattresses are cost effective; they can be used both when the baby is an infant and a toddler. Ideally, you should look for a crib mattress that features a more sophisticated design. For example, one which comes with a side that is firm enough to support the infant and allow for a cozy nap, and another side that is comfortable enough to support the increased and continually increasing weight of a toddler.

What is the Best Crib Mattress?

Regardless of their form or type, there are various important factors you should consider before buying a crib mattress. The first thing is the size of the infant mattress in relation to the crib. The mattress should fit precisely with the crib to avoid spaces that can be hazardous to your baby. To help you out, we have analyzed multiple crib mattresses available on the market today and picked 5 exquisite ones in a mixture of price points. Check them out and see which one fits your preferences the best.
Our Top Choice
The Naturepedic Organic Cotton 2-Stage crib mattress provides layers of comfortable organic cotton to create an impeccable balance of comfort and firmness. On the other hand, if you prefer a similar mattress that features 150 coils for increased coziness, check out the 150 Seamless Crib Mattress from the same manufacturer.
Naturepedic Waterproof Mattress for Cribs, 100% Organic Cotton, Dual Firmness Design, Greenguard Certified

Naturepedic Baby Mattress MC34


Features
Naturepedic specializes in crib mattresses and all-natural baby bedding and they have earned a great reputation in the last years. They produce an entire line of mattresses which are specially designed for babies and made from organic cotton. We have selected the Classic model from this manufacturer because it offers excellent value for money and it is probably the healthiest, safest type of mattress crib you can find on the market today.

Here are the highlights of this unbelievably soft mattress.
  • It is made 100% from organic cotton
  • The mattress is waterproof which prevents development of mold and mildew
  • The cotton layers make this mattress comfortable and firm at the same time
  • It is made in the USA
  • The design of this mattress is hypoallergenic which prevents allergies and skin irritations.
  • It comes with increased protection against fire, keeping your baby safe and sound for years
  • It can be cleaned with little to no effort as it features waterproof seams
Construction and Design
This is a 100% organic crib mattress. It has a dual-firmness effect, firmer on the infant’s side and softer on the toddler’s side. The organic cotton mattress from Naturepedic is as strong as an innerspring one, but it doesn’t weight as much. It also features a design with dual firmness and it is highly technologically advanced, allowing your baby to sleep like an angel every time. The mattress weighs just 10 pounds and the manufacturer meets the strictest regulations when it comes to chemical emissions, so your loved one will be fine.
Performance and Ease of Use
Due to its lightweight nature, the mattress is very easy to handle. Its dual-functionality gives it dual firmness for infants and toddlers. It provides a natural and comfortable environment for children to grow in. Here are some of the design highlights of this high-quality product.
  • It is easy to clean.
  • It is easy to mount and remove from the crib.
  • It can be fitted in sheets without problems
  • The mattress is firm and comfortable for the baby.
Best Value
Simmons is known for production of high quality and eco-friendly mattresses. They strive to produce items that are durable and pocket friendly. Even better, this manufacturer also makes comfy, 2-sided changing pads from vinyl which we all know are necessary when raising an infant.
Simmons Beautyrest Beginnings Natural Cotton Mattress for Babies w/ Pocketed Coil Springs

Simmons Baby Mattress M55984-3146 - Neutral


Features
Simmons is a company that create a multitude of mattresses made from superior materials and which are designed to enhance the quality of your sleep. They even have a special mobile app that monitors your sleep cycles and gives valuable information about your sleeping routine.

With these being said, it is impossible to ignore their offerings. For example, the Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Crib and Toddler Mattress comes with a lot of features, all meant to guarantee the safety and comfort of your kid. Here are just a few of them.
  • It has 231 pocketed springs to provide uniform support.
  • It has a waterproof organic woven cotton fabric cover with medical value.
  • It has a natural fire protection wrapper with no toxics
  • You benefit of lifetime warranty which will cover for damages and deterioration
  • Reinforced border and corner protectors for better stability and durability.
  • The mattress is GreenGuard Gold & CertiPur-Us certified meaning that it provides a healthy environment for your baby.
Construction and Design
The Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Crib and Toddler Mattress is made with your baby’s safety and comfort in mind. This mattress provides a dual-purpose for superlative firmness for your newborn baby while the flip side offers convoluted foam comfort for toddlers. This crib mattress is GREENGUARD GOLD and CertiPUR-US certified, so you can rest assured that it delivers the safest environment possible for your baby.

You might be happy to find out that this toddler mattress from Simmons Kids comes with a cover made from organic woven cotton and it features dual sides that will be very comfortable for your baby. For added safety, it comes with border protection as well as special corner protectors. Moreover, the material from which this mattress is made contains no chemicals and it is non-toxic, so your loved one won't develop an allergic reaction or become sick in the long run.

Let's find out more features provided by this comfy crib mattress.

  • It is made in the United States
  • It features 2 sides: a firmer one for newborns and a cozier one for toddlers
  • The mattress is waterproof and it has a natural protection against fire
  • It is also hypoallergenic, so your baby won't develop allergic reactions whatsoever while sleeping on this mattress
Performance and Ease of Use
This comfy mattress from Simmons has springs that provide even support and increased comfort. The mattress grows with the baby due to its 2 stage capabilities; the infant’s side is firm for the baby’s support while the toddler’s side is softer and more comfortable. This design makes it easy to fit in sheets throughout the baby’s stay in the crib. It is also easy to clean due to its waterproof aspects.
The Eco Classica III crib mattress is completely waterproof and features memory foam for increased comfort and safety. Also, if you are a person who moves a lot, you can use a Colgate Kids Zippered Crib Mattress Storage Bag for easy transport.
Colgate Eco Classica III Infant Mattress w/ Organic Cotton Cover, Waterproof, 6" Thickness

Colgate Mattress for Babies EC600F


Features
Colgate produces kids mattresses to suit a range of needs and budgets. This manufacturer is committed to delivering excellent products that can be used for a long period of time and offer an exquisite user experience. For example, the Eco Classica III Crib Mattress is made in the U.S., it features memory foam and it can give your baby the most rejuvenating and comfy sleep ever. You might even end up buying one for yourself!

Here are the highlights of this mattress at a glance.
  • It offers protection against fire and it is completely waterproof, so you shouldn’t be worried about mold development
  • The mattress is GreenGuard Gold and CertiPur certified, giving you more peace of mind
  • It features dual-functionality to serve infant and toddler stages
  • It is eco-friendly
  • The mattress is compact and lightweight, making changing sheets a breeze
Construction and Design
The Colgate Eco Classica III Crib Mattress has polyurethane and cotton filling that warrants comfort and durability. It is odor, water, and fire resistant. This mattress also provides protection from bedbugs and dust mites. Moreover, this product is non-toxic and eco-friendly, which makes it safe to use for children and gives you, as a parent, more peace of mind. Colgate Eco Classica III Crib Mattress is 6 inch thick and its dual firmness ensures the proper and comfortable growth and development of your child. Its design allows you to effortlessly flip the mattress as your child transits to the toddler stage.

Here are a few technical aspects related to this mattress.
  • Weight: 9.6 lb
  • Dimension: 51.7 x 27.2 x 6 inches
  • Origin: USA
  • Material type: Foam, Cotton
Performance and Ease of Use
The Eco Classica III infant mattress from Colgate boasts 6 inches in thickness which means tight fitting sheets, so you won’t have to keep arranging the sheets if they do not require changing. Its waterproof cover allows you to easily clean the mattress when necessary. The way this mattress is designed ensures that you have an easy task to flip it to a softer side when your baby transits from an infant to a toddler. You don’t have to purchase another mattress! GreenGuard Gold certifies for no harm emissions, while CertiPur certifies safe foam, so you do not have to worry about harmful chemicals; your baby is in a safe environment.
The Sealy Soybean Crib Mattress has won the Women’s Choice Award in 2013, 2014, 2015 & 2016 for most recommended baby products. For additional protection, you can pair the mattress with the Sealy Organic Cotton Allergy Protection Crib Mattress Pad as well.
Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant Mattress, Lightweight, Voted America's Best Brand for Babies

Sealy Mattress for Babies EM710


Features
Sealy is an American brand that assures its customers of the quality of their products. They specialize in high-quality mattresses that are comfy, durable and reasonably priced. We have picked the Soybean crib mattress because it features a foam core and has won numerous awards with the passing of years.

Here are more details about this premium product.
  • It is crib-fit tested
  • It features a waterproof pearl cover
  • It comes with a square corner design
  • The mattress is GREENGUARD® certified, meaning that it is safe from dangerous emissions
  • The high density core with added cotton cushioning will ensure that your baby sleeps like an angel every night
Construction and Design
The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress is an extra-firm lightweight baby mattress. Its cover is pearl embossed with waterproof and stain-resistant aspects for easy cleaning. This crib mattress has won four consecutive Women’s Choice Award for best crib mattresses and pad from 2013 to 2016. Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress is GREENGUARD® Children & Schools certified for low chemical emissions and indoor air quality for a healthier sleeping environment for your child.

Sealy crib mattresses are designed, engineered, and produced in the United States of America. They measures 52 x 28 x 5 inches to fit USA standard size cribs and toddler beds. They are square in shape and have a high density soybean foam core. The mattress is topped with a waterproof pearl cover. The standard set by this mattress is frustration free because it is certified by GREENGUARD® Children & Schools. The seams are designed with a robust edging and lock-stitched to avoid unravelling.
Performance and Ease of Use
Easy-cleaning is very important for any crib mattress! The pearl embossed cover of this baby mattress is waterproof and you can clean it with mild soap and water or just simple baby wipe. Liquids and stains won’t seep into the mattress since the binding is also waterproof. Its high density increases the baby's comfort and general durability of the mattress. Thanks to the extra lightweight aspect, it will be easy for you to clean, mount, and remove the mattress from the crib.
The Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress comes at a reasonable price and it is CertiPUR-US® certified. You might also like the Milliard Premium Hypoallergenic Waterproof cover pad which delivers a natural feel and creates a safer, more comfortable environment for your baby.
Milliard Mattress for Babies, Waterproof and Washable Cover, For Babies and Toddlers

Milliard Baby Mattress – 27.5"x52"x5.5" Polka Dot


Features
You might be happy to know that Milliard is a brand that focuses on mattresses and bedding only and they make high-quality products for adults, newborns and even for your dog. Yes, you can get a memory foam mattress for your canine friend at a reasonable price, one which will improve its sleep and make him feel like a king. However, on this review we focus on mattresses for infants and that's why we have included the hypoallergenic model on our list.

Here are some more interesting features provided by this product.
  • The foam is CertiPUR-US certified
  • It comes with 5.5-inch thick luxurious, high quality foam
  • The mattress has been designed to regulate air flow and standardize sleep temperature
  • It is encased in a hypoallergenic waterproof cover
  • This product features a medium-firm feel, measuring 32 ILD with a density of 28D for safety and comfort
Construction and Design
The Hypoallergenic baby mattress from Milliard is an affordable and good choice for parents looking for a crib mattress under $100. It uses an exceptional blend of foam to create the perfect combination of comfort, and the firmness suggested for babies and toddlers. Its cover is waterproof and washable. The Milliard Foam is CertiPUR-US® certified and measures 52" x 27.5" x 5.5".

This product is designed for maximum air flow and to help standardize sleep temperature. Milliard employs a unique technology that helps increase air circulation and weight distribution for your baby’s comfortable and restful sleep. This infant mattress is 5.5" thick, constructed from a luxurious high quality foam and comes with a removable and washable waterproof cover. This foam contours gently with your baby's shape to improve comfort. The mattress is square cornered to conform best to a standard American Crib.

Here are some technical details for your information.
  • Weight: 8.7 Pounds
  • Dimensions: 52 x 27.5 x 5.5 inches
  • Model: UPC 804879477723
  • Style: Polka Dot
  • Origin: USA
Performance and Ease of Use
With this mattress you will not have a difficult time transitioning your child to the crib. Infants who are used to their mommy’s cozy mattresses find it difficult to be comfortable in their typically hard crib mattresses. But with the hypoallergenic baby mattress from Milliard, they are able to transit easily because of its cushioning. The mattress is also easy to clean, given that it has a waterproof, removable, and washable cover. This cover also adds a level of stiffness to ensure that the baby’s face doesn’t conform to the mattress, greatly reducing chances of suffocation. You also do not have to worry about bedbugs or dust mites because the form is naturally hypoallergenic, antimicrobial and resilient to allergens, mold, bacteria, bedbugs, and dust mites.

Get the Best Crib Mattress of 2017!

If you are a parent and you want the best for your little one, pick one of the crib mattresses we just presented. These products are built according to the latest standards in safety and comfort, so you will have more peace of mind in the future!

Our Top Choice
Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic Crib Mattress
Best Value
Simmons Kids Ultra Deluxe 2-in-1 Crib Mattress
Colgate Eco Classica III Crib Mattress
Sealy Soybean Waterproof Crib Mattress
Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress