Best Round Cookie Cutter Set Reviews 2017

With the numerous choices available in the market today, choosing the right round cutter set becomes an onerous task, but with our thorough research that covered many brands with round cutter sets, you’re assured of quality picks that’ll suit your needs. We present to you the top 5 brands with the best round cutter sets in the market, showing off one product per brand. This doesn’t take anything away from the fact that the featured brands have other great cookie cutters that you may like and we encourage you to take a look at them too.
WATCH OUR
ROUND COOKIE CUTTER SET
REVIEWS NOW
Overview
PROS
CONS
SPECS
Set Size
Edge
Size Range
Material
Color
Our Top Choice
Ateco 11 Piece Plain Round Cutter Set
Ateco is a maker of cake decorating tools and other equipment that are in popular demand by professionals and pastry lovers worldwide.
Sturdily-built stainless steel cutters; not thin or fragile. It has 11 different sizes, a tin storage box and all edges are rounded to prevent injury. It’s easy to clean.
It might get rusty when improperly stored.
11-Piece
Plain
0.75 to 3.63 inches
Stainless Steel
Silver
Best Value
Wilton Round Fondant Double Cut-Outs Set
Wilton Enterprises is the leading food-crafting brand holding the topmost position in cake decorating and bakeware.
They’re functional, versatile and affordable. They have both straight edges and scalloped edges. They’re of good quality as they aren’t flimsy, don’t bend and are easy to maintain.
Its edges are sharp and might be uncomfortable to grip during use.
6-Piece
Fluted
0.875 to 2.875 inches
Stainless Steel
Silver
Cake Boss Fondant and Cookie Cutter Set
The Cake Boss sees cakes in everything and is unwaveringly dedicated to providing the tools and services that will bring those fantasies to life.
Durable and rust-free. Their tapered end gives clean cuts and easy release. Easy to clean. Come in a handy storage container.
The lid of the storage container doesn’t fit the container tightly.
9-Piece
Plain
0.5 to 4.5 inches
Stainless Steel
Red
HIC Harold Import Co. Round Cookie Cutter Set
The belief that quality, value, and superior service are forever in style has kept HIC, Harold Import Co. in business for 60 years.
Reliable. Features 11 graduated sizes. Reasonably priced, clean cutting, long-lasting set of round cutters.
The cutters will rust if put in dishwasher.
11-Piece
Plain
0.75 to 3.5 inches
Tin
Silver
Fox Run Stainless Steel Circle Cookie Cutter Set
Fox Run is the food lover’s one-stop-shop for excellent kitchen tools. It has earned a place for itself as a leading supplier of kitchenware.
5 pieces. 1.5 to 3.5 inches in size. Comes with storage tin. Affordable. Comfortable handle.
The cutters are rough where they join.
5-Piece
Plain
1.5 to 3.5 inches
Stainless Steel
Black

Related Reviews
Best Cookie Jar
Best Baker’s Rack
Best Mixing Bowl Set
Best Electric Oven

How Do I Choose the Best Round Cookie Cutter Set?

(Updated )
Cookie cutters call to mind sweet memories of baking cookies as a child. It’s one culinary instrument that can be used by everyone; even kids in the kitchen get to make different-shaped cookies and have great fun while at it. Traditional cookie cutters make short work of cutting doughs into different shapes as desired and in record time too. They make baking more fun, precise and neater. They also come in different shapes and sizes; whatever shape you can imagine, you’re sure to get it in a cookie cutter set and they’re available for any season, theme or occasion.

A round cutter set is one of the many shapes of cookie cutters available. It’s used to cut out circular shapes from your dough for bread, cookies, dumplings, English muffins, doughnuts and plenty of other pastries. It can also be used to shape foods into circular molds or to cut thinly sliced fruits. People have been known to use cups or small round plates as improvised round cutters, but investing in a real round cutter set is guaranteed to make your work a whole lot easier and neater, saving you time and giving your work that professional look without costing an arm and a leg. Outside the kitchen, it’s been employed in other capacities like in pottery and ceramics where it’s been used to cut clay and other malleable materials. Round cutter sets come in different sizes and are made from different materials.

Before buying a circle cookie cutter set, it’s recommended that you take a look at some features affecting the functionality of the round cutter such as its manufacturing material, set size and range, type of edge and even the cost implication. This buying guide is meant to give you valuable insight on these features so you can make the best choice of a round cutter set that will suit your needs perfectly.
Price
Although round cutter sets are relatively budget-friendly items, it’s still good to know that you’re spending your money on an item that’ll serve the purpose for which you paid. The price of a set of round cookie cutters largely depends on the material with which it was manufactured, which directly affects its durability. A copper round cutter set will naturally cost more than a tin or plastic cutter set so you’d want to have a clear cut idea of what you need the round cutter set for and how often you’ll be using it so as to plan accordingly.

The price range for the round cutter set reviewed here is between $5.99 and $16.99. This price range covers quality products from reputable brands in the baking supply industry. Of course, during the course of our research, we came across several cheap round cutter sets, but we overlooked them because they’re usually manufactured from low quality and flimsy materials that won’t stand the test of time. Thus this review is solely based on high quality and durable round cutter sets, so you should stay with us.
Features
The material with which a round cutter set is crafted is of the utmost importance when looking for a great round cutter set that will suit your needs. There are other features that you also need to consider carefully before making your final decision, which include:
  • Set size and range
  • Type of edge
  • Storage
  • Extra features
  • Ease of use
Construction and Design
Round cookie cutter sets are just one out of the numerous shapes available in the market and, like the other types, they are made from different materials at the discretion of the manufacturers. Most brands employ the use of metals, plastics or wood materials in crafting their round cutter sets. Metal round cutter sets can be made from tin, aluminum, stainless steel or copper. A tin round cutter set is extremely pliable and the most inexpensive of the metal round cutter sets. It rusts easily, especially if not well dried before storing. Aluminum round cutters are also pliable and inexpensive but they keep longer than tin cutters. Stainless steel crafted round cutter sets are stronger than either the tin or aluminum ones, they also last quite longer especially when kept moisture free during storage. Copper makes arguably the best and sturdiest round cutter sets. They make quite beautiful collectibles and don’t rust, though they may tarnish over time.

Plastic round cutter sets are budget-friendly too, and one big plus to these is that they’re very safe for little ones to use. They don’t rust and are super easy to properly clean and store. Wooden round cutter sets aren’t too common and are bought more for their vintage and decorative properties than any real functional need.

Round cutter sets are built with edges that easily and neatly cut into doughs and other malleable foods or clay. These edges can either be smooth or serrated (scalloped). The smooth edge makes round, smooth cuts while the serrated edge adds a touch of style to the cut outs by giving the round shapes serrated edge design. Whatever type of edge the round cutter set comes with, it’s designed in a way that ensures quick release of the cut dough with minimum amount of sticking.

The round cutter sets come in different set sizes and ranges. A round cutter set can come in a set size of between 2-piece to 11-piece or even more, depending on the manufacturer. These different sizes in a given set have different size ranges. The sizes differ in height and diameter so you can have different sizes or round shapes to work with.
Performance and Ease of Use
Round cutter sets are extremely easy to use and care for; you hardly need an instruction manual before you can use it. For the aluminum, copper and stainless steel round cutter sets, you can simply put them in the dishwasher and then dry them off carefully before storing. The tin and plastic cutters aren’t ideal to be used in a dishwasher as they may get warped, or even melt in the case of a plastic cutter. A simple hand wash with soapy water is sufficient and then followed by careful drying before storage. Round cutter sets made from tin and aluminum are pliable, and so are prone to bending out of shape. This means that you have to be more careful when cleaning them and also during storage so they don’t get reshaped.

For easy storage, some brands pack their round cutter sets in a tin container so you don’t need to look for where to store them. But since these are round shaped, you can easily stack them according to their sizes in any convenient container or inside the cabinet, away from moisture.

For ease of use, some round cookie cutters come with a handle so you can get a firm grip when making your cuts, especially if you’re making a large batch of cookies. A few of them, like one of the products in our product review section, feature a rolled-top design that ensures the top part of the cutter is blunted and rolled for easy and firm grip.

Note that round cutter sets with handles make it a little bit difficult to store as the handles may get in the way.

For increased performance and value for your money, some round cutters are double-edged, having a smooth-rounded side and a serrated side. This increases that particular cutter’s versatility and makes it easier for you to add designs to your baking without having to buy an entirely different set just for that feature. For this type of round cutter set, you may want to pay closer attention to the Wilton Round Fondant Double Cut-Outs Set in our product review section.

Round cutter sets also come in a large variety of eye-catching and vivid colors that add fun to your baking time and also make them great pieces for display on your kitchen cabinet.

What is the Best Round Cookie Cutter Set?

There are several things you need to consider when going for a round cookie cutters and, having gone through our buying guide, we believe you now know the features that you should look out for. A highly recommended way to start is by taking a look at our product review section with detailed information on top round cutter set models and picking the model that best suits you.
Our Top Choice
The Ateco 11 Piece Plain Round Cutter Set is a set of 11 plain-edged, stainless steel round cutters that range from ¾ inch to 3 5/8 inches. It can be used to cut dough, pastries, cookies and more. If you’re looking for a plastic, 9 piece set then we recommend the Plain Edge Round Cutter Set by Ateco, which is made with food-safe plastic.
Ateco 11 Piece Plain Stainless Round Cutter Set in Graduated Sizes

Ateco Round Cutter Set 5357


Features
The August Thomsen Corporation, ATECO, was established in 1905 by its founder (and namesake) in Brooklyn, New York. He was a German immigrant of Danish ancestry. Combining traditional designs from his home country with his own new designs, he produced a modest line of cake decorating tools. This is a 4th generation family-owned business that’s today owned and operated by two of Thomsen’s great-grand sons, Doug and Jeff Schneider. It has more than 250 styles, types and sizes of pastry tips alone. It also has decorating tubes, bags, pastry rings, pastry molds, cutter sets, spatulas and plenty more. Being a player in this field for a century and a dozen years, it’s carved out a niche for itself as a prominent name — one that’s been trusted for generations.

The Ateco 11 Piece Plain Round Cutter Set contains 11 stainless steel round cutters (12 if you add the tin storage container it comes in). The different diameters of each piece include: 3 5/8, 3 3/8, 3 1/6, 2 3/4, 2 1/2, 2 1/4, 2, 1 3/4, 1 1/2, 1 1/4 and 1”; they’re all 1.25 inches tall. Each one appears to be joined by spot welding at three points along the point where the seam is expected. It’s a smooth joint that doesn’t leave any impression on the fondant, cookies, ravioli or anything else you decide to make with it. It can also be used to cut thinly sliced fruit, bread dough, English muffins, doughnuts, dumplings, and what’s more it can mold food into circular shapes. If you’re interested in using them outside the kitchen, we’re glad to inform you that they’ve been reported to be pretty useful in cutting clay for pottery and ceramics too.

A crucial aspect to their life span and usefulness is maintenance; they can be hand washed or put in a dishwasher. You have to remember to dry them properly, leaving no moisture at all, before storing either in its storage container or in your preferred storage space.

Ateco has plenty of other round cutters on offer which include:
  • Ateco 6-Piece Double Sided Round Cutter Set with sizes from 2 inches to 4.5 inches. Each cutter has a plain cutting side and a flute cutting end. The cutters are made of long-lasting stainless steel
  • The Harold Ateco 11 Piece Stainless Steel Fluted Round Cutter Set with cutters ranging from ¾ to 3 ¼ inches across and can be used to cut cookies, dough, fondant and more
  • The 2X Ateco 12-Piece Plain Stainless Steel Round Cutter Set with cutters ranging from 0.75 to 4.38 inches with a height of 1.7 inches for cutting dough, cookies, pastries and more
Best Value
Wilton’s Round Fondant Double Cut-Outs have one side of each as straight edges and the other side as scalloped edges. It’s a 6-piece set with cutter sizes from 7/8 inches to 2 13/16 inches and are about 2.8 inches high. If you’re looking for plain-edges cutters with rolled edges we suggest you take a look at Wilton’s 4 Piece Round Cookie Cutters.
Wilton Round Nesting Fondant Double Cut-Outs Set with 12 Cutting Designs

Wilton Round Cutter Set 417-2581


Features
The Wilton story is one of passion, vision and growth. It started with Dewey McKinley Wilton who began his career as a candy maker at the age of 15 and grew into an expert in the fine art of pulled sugar by the early 1920s. He was so good at it that his creations were sought by exclusive caterers and grand hotels from all around the Chicago area, including the Hiltons (formerly known as the Stevens Hotel). In 1929, he began the Wilton School of Cake Decorating that today has become a state-of-the-art facility and the Wilton brand has grown to offer the most extensive and comprehensive and innovative collection of baking, cake decorating, cookie and candy making, kitchen, party and seasonal products. Apart from its great products, its publications and classes have empowered thousands of people around the world to create and enjoy impressive desserts.

The Wilton Round Fondant Double Cut-Outs Set offers you up to 12 designs as it’s a 6-piece set with each cutter having double sides that offer a smooth round cut on one end and a round scalloped (or, in the words of Wilton, crinkled) cut on the other end. With these graduated cutters, you can create intricately layered decorations with two edge finished fondant for any cake. From smallest to largest, its sizes are 7/8 inches, 1 ¼ inches, 1 7/16 inches, 2 inches, 2 3/8 inches and 2 13/16 inches.

It can be put to an interesting variety of food cutting purposes that include cutting meat (processed sandwich meat), cutting cookies, doughnuts, brownies, salt dough and lots more; it cuts clay as well for pottery, ceramics or ornamental purposes. They’re easy to use and clean; the manufacturer’s recommendation is to hand-wash before first use and after every use with warm, soapy water, rinse well and dry off completely with a soft cloth.

There are more round cutters from Wilton and these are just a few of them:
  • The Wilton Round Linzer Cookie Cutter Set of fluted cutters with 6 interchangeable center shape cut-outs. It includes instructions and easy-to-make recipes/li>
  • The Wilton 2 Piece Emoji Cookie Cutter Set with 3 ¼ inch round cutter and 1 ½ inch mini heart cutter for making emoji cookie with heart-shaped eyes. It is made of plastic.
  • The Wilton Mini Pie Cutter Set with 1 round cutter and 2 decorative-leaf cutters for delicious, autumn-themed details
  • The Wilton Comfort Grip Round Cookie Cutter with extra-deep sides and cushioned grips. It has a cutting diameter of 3 3/8 inches and is available in other shapes
The Cake Boss Fondant and Cookie Cutter Set is a 9-piece set of sturdy, red, nylon fondant and cookie cutters that create ½ - 4 inch wide and approximately 1 ½ inch high circles. If you’re making sports-themed cakes this company has got you covered with its Cake Boss Decorating Tools Sports Cake Kit; we invite you to take a look at it.
Cake Boss Decorating Tools 9-Piece Round Fondant and Cookie Cutter Set, Red

Cake Boss Round Cutter Set 59469


Features
Cake Boss is a family-owned brand that at present is run by celebrity baker and chef, Buddy Valastro, a 4th generation baker of Italian descent. His father Buddy Sr. bought Carlo’s Bakery in 1963 and moved it to its present location in Hoboken so that its customer base could increase and it could become a household name. At the age of 17, Buddy had to step into the role of cake boss after his father passed on and, though it wasn’t easy at first (it took a lot of struggling to recreate his dad’s signature recipe), he has managed to make his and his father’s dream come true. Today, there’s a second Carlo’s Bakery in NJ, a television show, 5 bestselling books, a 50,000 square foot baking facility and a fast-selling cake baking and decorating product line. On how he has managed to combine all these with being a loving husband and father, he attributes it to being open-minded and creative.

The Cake Boss Round Fondant and Cookie Cutter Set is a red-colored set and comes in handy when creating baked goodies for birthdays, weddings, family get-togethers and any other special occasions. It’s a set of 9 round cutters that range in sizes from 3.86 inches, 3.46 inches, 3.07 inches, 2.68 inches, 2.28 inches, 1.89 inches, 1.50 inches, 1.10 inches and 0.71 inches. Each cutter is about 1 ½ inch tall and features an easy-to-grip lip and a tapered blade that cuts through dough and fondant up to 2 inches thick. With this set you can create a pattern of dots and circles with fondant, make rolled cookies that can be sprinkled in colorful sugar and whatever other baking application you can think up.

You don’t have to worry about these rusting as they’re made from a nylon material and are sturdily built so that they won’t bend or wear out easily. They’re strong enough to be used in cutting clay for pottery and decorations; in case of sticking, apply a light amount of oil on it. To maintain these cutters, hand-washing is recommended and the company promises to replace products that are found defective upon receipt.

Other cutters from Cake Boss include:
  • The Cake Boss 8-Piece Daisy Fondant and Cookie Cutter Set with sizes ½ to 4 ½ inches, each with a convenient lip and tapered end for making daisy-shaped treats
  • The Cake Boss 6-Piece Classic Linzer Cookie Cutter Set with round, fluted, crescent, heart and star-shaped mini cutters
The Round Cookie Cutter Set from HIC Harold Import Co. are made from tin and are graduated from 1 inch to 3.75 inches with rolled top ends for convenient handling. They come in a neat metal storage case. If you’d like round cutters with handles you should have a look at Mrs. Anderson's Baking Round Cookie Cutters from the very same company.
HIC Harold Import Co. Mrs Anderson's Baking 11 Piece Round Cookie, Fondant Cutter Set with Storage Tin

HIC Harold Import Co. Round Cutter Set 42114


Features
Since its establishment in 1957, HIC Harold Import Co. has aimed to provide the avid cook with the highest quality cooking supplies, food preparation equipment and essential cooking tools. It’s an award-winning, third generation family-owned company with an International Housewares Association Innovation Award and Gourmet Catalog Buying Group Lifetime Achievement Award to its credit. It maintains an extensive collection of brands — more than most of the other companies in its field. Its first product was a white porcelain dinnerware plate that’s remained in demand half a century later. Today, its products number more than 3500 and are available in its over 10,000 retail outlets that are scattered around the globe. Whether you’re looking for bakeware, grilling tools and accessories or any of the myriad of cooking supplies available today, HIC Harold Import Co. has got you covered.

Mrs. Anderson's Baking 11 Piece Round Cookie Cutter Set is suitable for homemade cookies, mini cakes, decorative fondants, gingerbread pieces and lots more. It’s made from tin for easy maintenance and is a set of 9 graduated round cutters with sizes 1 inch, 1.25 inches, 1.50 inches, 1.75 inches, 2 inches, 2.25 inches, 2.50 inches, 2.75 inches, 3.00 inches, 3.50 inches and 3.75 inches; each cutter is spot welded at its seams.

To use, simply press the preferred cutter firmly into the dough to cut out the desired size, dip the cutter in flour between cuts to prevent the dough from sticking to it. They come nestled in a metal storage tin with which the cutters can be stored after use. For maintenance, hand washing in warm soapy water is advised and they should be dried thoroughly after that.

There are more cutters on offer from this brand, which include:
  • The HIC Stainless Steel Food Ring Mold with a 2 ¾ Inch Cutter is a multipurpose ring cutter that’s dishwasher safe
  • The Mrs. Anderson's Baking Cookie Cutter Set by HIC Harold Import Co. a flower-shaped set with crinkled and plain edges that vary in diameter from 2 5/8 inches to ¾ inches
  • The Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Cookie and Fondant Cutters a 5 piece set of graduated crinkled hearts with storage tin
  • The Mrs. Anderson's Baking Donut Cutter a 3-inch stainless steel cutter with top side handle. It’s dishwasher safe
The Fox Run 5-Piece Stainless Steel Circle Cookie Cutter Set consists of cutters that are 1.5 inches to 3.5 inches in diameter. They come in a convenient storage tin and can cut cookies, fondant and more. For some fun-shaped cutters, you should check out Fox Run’s Mini Flower and Butterfly Cookie Cutter Set which comes with 11 pieces.
Fox Run Stainless Steel Circle Cookie Cutter Set, 5-Piece with Storage Tin

Fox Run Round Cutter Set 3681


Features
Fox Run was founded in 1971 as a manufacturer of domestic cookie cutters. Today it’s a major supplier of unique, high grade kitchen products to specialty retailers, numbering thousands, in North America alone. From its headquarters in Pennsylvania, USA, it operates its distribution facilities in Toronto and Shanghai from which it delivers more than 3,000 products for the kitchen and home. Although its specialty is bake-ware and barbecue grill-ware, it also carries a wide array of food prep, tea and coffee products, wooden ware and more. Its products are marketed under popular, reputable brand names like Fox Run Kitchens, Ironwood Gourmet, Outset, Nantucket Sea Foods and Kitchen Art.

The Fox Run 5-Piece Stainless Steel Circle Cookie Cutter Set consists of round cutters with sizes of 1.5 inches, 2 inches, 2.5 inches, 3 inches and 3.5 inches in diameter; each cutter is about an inch tall. They have a sharp cutting end that delivers clean cut circles and they release easily as well. To afford you a convenient and comfortable grip, each cutter has a rolled top end that do not hurt when you are pressing the cutter into the dough.

They’re made of stainless steel and can be put to a variety of baking uses; however, we don’t advise that they be used to cut clay for art projects or decorative purposes as they weren’t designed with such in mind. To maintain these cutters, the manufacturer’s advice is that should be hand-washed in warm, soapy water and thoroughly dried off immediately.

Fox Run’s other cutters include:
  • The Fox Run 7-Piece Plain and Crinkled Double-Sided, Plastic Cookie Cutter Set with diameters that range from 1.8 inches to 3.8 inches. It is constructed from food-safe, heavy-duty plastic
  • The Fox Run 5-Piece Stainless Steel Circle Biscuit/Cookie Cutter Set with cutters that range from 1.5 inches to 3 inches in diameter, each with an ergonomically designed handle
  • The Fox Run 9-Piece Stainless Steel Round Cookie Cutter Set with diameters that measure approximately 2 inches to 6 inches and are great for fondant, cookies, pastries and more
  • The Fox Run Ravioli Cutters a set of 2 cutters, one round and one square measuring 2.5 inches. It can be used to cut and seal homemade cheese, spinach or meat filled raviolis
  • The Fox Run 4 Piece Cookie Cutter Set for egg pancake, English muffin, crumpet, biscuits with 3 ¾ inch diameters for each cutter

Get the Best Round Cookie Cutter Set of 2017!

Now that you’ve made it to the end of this info-laden review of the best cookie cutter sets we could find, we’re quite sure that you’re well informed to conveniently choose a round cutter set that’ll suit your needs. So, go ahead and place that order now!

Our Top Choice
Ateco 11 Piece Plain Round Cutter Set
Best Value
Wilton Round Fondant Double Cut-Outs Set
Cake Boss Fondant and Cookie Cutter Set
HIC Harold Import Co. Round Cookie Cutter Set
Fox Run Stainless Steel Circle Cookie Cutter Set