Best Thanksgiving Dinnerware Set Reviews 2017

(Updated )
Family, friends, shared food, and good conversation – these are some of the things that make Thanksgiving such a special holiday. The right dinnerware set can help create the warm, hospitable environment that you want when welcoming loved ones into your home for the holiday meal. We’ve researched the best dinnerware brands and selected 5 that we think have some nice looking dinnerware sets that could grace any your table with style. We’ve picked one great Thanksgiving dinnerware set to feature from each brand, but there are plenty more to choose from.
Overview
PROS
CONS
SPECS
Total Pieces
Material
Includes
Practicality
Extras
Our Top Choice
Platzgraff Plymouth Dinnerware Set for Thanksgiving
Pfaltzgraff makes high-quality dinnerware, serveware, flatware, and more. The Plymouth dinnerware set, displaying festive pumpkins, corn, and acorns, is perfect for both autumn and Thanksgiving.
Festive seasonal design will work all fall long. Optional accessories can be purchased for an extremely attractive Thanksgiving tablescape. High quality stoneware.
A little pricey (but beautiful quality for the price).
32 Pieces, Service for 8
Stoneware
Plates (11.5” & 8”), Bowls, Mugs
Microwave and Dishwasher Safe
Matching Serveware Available
Best Value
Johnson Brothers His Majesty Dinnerware Set for Thanksgiving
Johnson Brothers makes beautiful, traditional dinnerware, including the Your Majesty set, which displays gorgeous turkeys surrounded by autumn foliage.
Classic turkey pattern is perfect for Thanksgiving. Safe for dishwasher and microwave. Matching serveware available for separate purchase. Reasonably priced.
Muted colors (some may prefer this)
16 Pieces, Service for 4
Stoneware
Plates (10.5" &7.75"), Bowls, Mugs
Microwave and Dishwasher Safe
Matching Serveware Available
Sur La Table Pumpkin Dinnerware Set for Thanksgiving
Sur La Table is dedicated to providing the right tools for cooking and hospitality. Their Pumpkin dinnerware set is ideal for Thanksgiving or for the whole fall season.
Durable earthenware construction. Pumpkin pattern can be used for Thanksgiving dinner and throughout the fall season. Coordinates with the Harvest Gathering collection.
Microwave safe, but gets quite hot when heated in the microwave
16 Pieces, Service for 4
Earthenware
Plates (10.75” & 8”), Bowls, Mugs
Dishwasher and Microwave Safe
Coordinating Pieces Available
Gibson Elite Shangri-La Court Dinnerware Set for Thanksgiving
Gibson is a trusted name in dinnerware, offering a huge variety of different sets. The deep amber hues of the Shangri-La dinnerware set make it a good choice for Fall, Thanksgiving or any day.
Includes 2 different bowl sizes – 7.5” and 4.5”. Reactive glaze gives each piece a unique, hand-crafted look.
No mugs or teacups included (but many people don’t need these).
16 Pieces, Service for 4
Stoneware
Two sizes of plates and bowls
Dishwasher and Microwave Safe
Reactive Glaze
Rachel Ray Cucina Pumpkin Orange Dinnerware Set for Thanksgiving
Rachel Ray’s love for entertaining is reflected in the quality and design of her dinnerware sets. The Cucina stoneware set is available in rich pumpkin orange, as well as other fall colors.
Deep pumpkin color is ideal for Thanksgiving and the rest of autumn. Microwave, freezer, and dishwasher safe. Oven safe at 250°F for up to 30 minutes. Affordable.
Stoneware can chip if not handled carefully
16 Pieces, Service for 4
Stoneware
Plates (10.5” & 8”), Bowls, Mugs
Dishwasher and Microwave Safe
Freezer and Oven (to 250°F) Safe

Related Reviews
Best Dinnerware – Fall/Autumn Dinnerware
Best Dinnerware - Winter Dinnerware
Best Dinnerware - Everyday Dinnerware
Best Dinnerware – Fine Dining

What is the Best Thanksgiving Dinnerware Set?

When choosing a dinnerware set, you’ll need to consider material, shape, price, and the type and number of pieces included. If you’re looking for holiday-specific dinnerware, color and design will also be top considerations. For your Thanksgiving dinnerware set, you may want to select turkey or pumpkin designs, or you may want to choose solid fall colors, such as red, orange, or brown. Let’s take a look at a sample of what these trustworthy dinnerware brands have to offer.
Our Top Choice
Pfaltzgraff is one of the most trusted and respected makers of dinnerware and other kitchen items. The Plymouth dinnerware set is sure to wow friends and family all through the fall season. To make it special for Thanksgiving, we recommend adding the Turkey shaped serving dish, the gravy pitcher and covered pie plate, or one of the many other serving dishes and platters that are part of the Pfaltzgraff Plymouth collection.
Platzgraff Plymouth Autumn Dinnerware Set -- Microwave and Dishwasher Safe Stoneware

Platzgraff Thanksgiving Dinnerware Plymouth – 32 Pieces


Features
Pfaltzgraff, which started as a small pottery company in Pennsylvania, has over 200 years of experience providing consumers with quality items for home use. Today, they offer expertly crafted dinnerware, drinkware, flatware, and home accents. Their dinnerware is available in a wide range of colors, designs, materials, and prices.

We can’t think of a better way to set the Thanksgiving table than with the Plymouth dinnerware set, which features embossed acorns, pumpkins, ears of corn, and leaves. Available as a service for 8, the set comes with 8 each 11 ½ inch dinner plates, 9 inch salad plates, 20 ounce soup/cereal bowls, and 12 ounce mugs. All pieces are crafted of high-quality stoneware. Another thing that especially attracted us to the Plymouth pattern was the variety of coordinating pieces available. Here’s a sampling:
  • Plymouth sculpted pumpkin serving plate, 7 ½ inch
  • Plymouth rectangular bread basket, 15 ¾ inch
  • Plymouth turkey-shaped covered serving dish, 2 ½ quart
The Plymouth pattern isn’t your only choice for Thanksgiving dishware though. Pfaltzgraff makes several other sets that are perfect for Turkey Day, and quite a few that are great for both Thanksgiving dinner and everyday use all autumn long. Here are a some others you might want on your fall and Thanksgiving table:
  • Gourmet Basics Autumn Nights
  • Filigree Autumn Berry
  • Gourmet Basics Linden
Best Value
Johnson Brothers, once famous for “semi-porcelain” dishware, continues to produce fine dinnerware, serveware, and teapots in classic patterns. The His Majesty dinnerware set is a traditionally styled set of dishes featuring turkeys on the plates. If you like the look of this set, you will love the matching platter and vegetable serving bowl.
Johnson Brothers His Majesty Stoneware Dinnerware Set – Microwave and Dishwasher Safe, Coordinates with Serveware

Johnson Brothers Thanksgiving Dinnerware Set – 16 Pieces


Features
Johnson Brothers, an English company founded in 1883, was originally famous for “white granite” dishware, also known as “semi-porcelain” due to its china-like appearance. Later, transferware and flow blue patterns would cement the company’s reputation and popularity in the United States. His Majesty is a stoneware dinnerware collection featuring plump turkeys in fall hues. What could be more appropriate for the Thanksgiving table?

The 16-piece set is a service for 4, which includes 10 ½ inch dinner plates, 7 ¾ inch salad plates, cereal bowls, and mugs. The pieces are dishwasher and microwave safe. If handled with reasonable care, they should last for years to come. There are also some lovely coordinating pieces available, including:
  • His Majesty open vegetable bowl
  • His Majesty 15 ½ inch oval platter
  • His Majesty cups and saucers
If you’re looking ahead to the winter season, and want something with a nostalgic feel, we recommend checking out the Johnson Brothers Friendly Village and T’was the Night collections.
Sur La Table is all about connecting cooks and entertainers with the tools they need to create great food and a hospitable atmosphere to serve it in. We think nothing says Thanksgiving like pumpkins, and Sur La Table’s Pumpkin dinnerware set is great for Thanksgiving and fall. If you love this set as much as we do, you will love all the matching serveware and accessories.
Sur La Table Pumpkin Autumn Dinnerware Set – Dishwasher and Microwave Safe Earthenware, Part of the Harvest Gathering Collection

Sur La Table Thanksgiving Dinnerware H3552-16PC – 16 Pieces


Features
Sur La Table began in Seattle’s Pike’s Place Market in 1972. The company’s vision was to offer superior quality culinary tools from around the world. The company has expanded greatly but has never lost sight of its original purpose. Sur La Table’s Pumpkin dinnerware set is perfect for creating a rustic fall setting for your Thanksgiving dinner.

The Pumpkin dinnerware collection features rich orange pumpkins on winding vines printed on durable earthenware. The salad plates have a large pumpkin in the center, while the dinner plates have a border of smaller pumpkins and vines. We like the variety this adds to the set. The 16-piece set serves 4, and includes 10 ¾ inch dinner plates, 8 inch salad plates, cereal bowls, and mugs.

If you want the kids to have their own special place settings for Thanksgiving or any day, the Woodland 3-piece set is an adorable choice. For the grownups, Sur La Table has a number of dinnerware sets that will work as well for daily use as for Thanksgiving. Here are two that we saw:
  • Sur La Table Novo Deruta – Whimsical design in fall colors
  • Sur La Table Porcelain Square Collection – Solid, classic white so goes with anything
Hardcore decorators will appreciate that the Pumpkin dinnerware set coordinates with pieces from the Harvest Gathering collection, which includes serving platters, salt and pepper shakers, cocktail napkins, table decorations, and much more.
Gibson makes attractive and functional dinnerware, cookware, kitchen tools, and more. The Shangri-La Court set is our choice for Thanksgiving use because it comes with two different kinds of bowls and is available in rich fall colors. We chose to picture Shangri-La Court set in light amber, but we also loved it in dark brown with jade green accents.
Gibson Elite Shangri-La Court Amber Dinnerware Set – Dishwasher and Microwave Safe Stoneware, Plates and Bowls Only (2 sizes of each)

Gibson Elite Thanksgiving Dinnerware 92769.16 – 16 Piece


Features
While it’s possible that you may not recognize their name, Gibson is top producer of dinnerware, glassware, flatware, kitchen tools, cookware and housewares in the United States. Gibson’s family of brands include The Pioneer Woman, Oster, Mr. Coffee, Sunbeam and Crock Pot, just to name a few. It’s no wonder we chose them as one of the best dinnerware brands. They offer offer dinnerware in a wide variety of colors, shapes, and patterns.

One particular pattern that has a great fall feel is our featured set, the Shangri-La collection in amber. The 16-piece set serves 4 people and comes with 10 ¾ inch dinner plates, 8 ¼ inch dessert plates, 7 ½ inch bowls, and 4 ½ inch fruit bowls. Note that, unlike many dinnerware sets, this one does not come with mugs. Buyers who don’t drink coffee or tea may appreciate having fruit bowls instead, while caffeine addicts may want to choose a different dinnerware set if having matching mugs is important to them.

We think the 16-piece amber Shangri-La set is great for Thanksgiving, but there are plenty of other dishware collections to choose from, including some in lovely fall colors. Here are some of Gibson’s dinnerware sets that are excellent choices for your Autumn or Thanksgiving table, as well as for for daily use:
  • Gibson Elite Barberware Square, Brick
  • Gibson Elite Volterra, Red
  • Gibson Home Soho Lounge Matte Brick
  • Gibson Elite Orianna
Gibson also has melamine dinnerware sets for those looking for a durable and inexpensive option.
TV Personality Rachel Ray loves entertaining, and her brand’s dinnerware allows fans (and non-fans too) to host a superstar gathering. Her Cucina dinnerware in pumpkin orange sets a wonderful Thanksgiving mood. For more causal gatherings, we loved the Rachael Ray Rise Collection available in two-tone white and orange, or white and orange.
Rachel Ray Cucina Autumn Dinnerware Set in Pumpkin Orange – Microwave, Freezer, and Dishwasher Safe Stoneware

Rachel Ray Dinnerware 535036 – 16 Pieces


Features
Rachel Ray is best known for her work on the Food Network, but did you know she also has a line of colorful dishware, cookware, and other home items? One great thing about the dinnerware is that most pieces coordinate with Rachel Ray cookware, bakeware, serveware, and more. Rachel Ray dinnerware is reasonably priced, and you might even be able to save a bit of money by shopping on Amazon.

Our featured set, the the Cucina dinnerware set in pumpkin orange, is constructed of solid-colored stoneware with a glazed finish. The service for 4 has 16 pieces, which includes 10 ½ inch dinner plates, 8 inch salad plates, 5 ½ inch cereal bowls, and 12 oz. mugs. These easy-care dishes are all microwave, dishwasher, refrigerator, and freezer safe. They can also be used in a 250 °F oven, which is pretty convenient for keeping your food warm.

If the pumpkin-colored set isn’t for you, don’t worry – there are other options, in the Cucina collection that also invoke the feeling of autumn leaves and a Thanksgiving harvest such as Cranberry Red, Mushroom Brown and Almond Cream. If you choose any one of the Cucina dinnerware set syou might also consider a matching oval platter, round baker, or oven-to-table casserole dish - or mix and match for a table full of fall colors.

One of the things that we love most about the Cucina collecton is that the solid colors lend themselves not only to decorating your fall table scape, but with the right accents you can use them for other holidays – or just by themselves all year long. We can already picture the red set on a festive Christmas table. Now we just need someone to pass us the cranberries.

Get the Best Thanksgiving Dinnerware Set Today!

Whether you’re looking for a special dinnerware set for Thanksgiving Day, for the whole fall season, or for everyday use, we hope that we’ve been able to help you out. Our research led us to five of the very best brands, and we chose to feature one set from each. All of the sets we showcased will look beautiful on your Thanksgiving table, but each brand has plenty more to offer as well. Head on over to Amazon to see.

Our Top Choice
Platzgraff Plymouth Dinnerware Set for Thanksgiving
Best Value
Johnson Brothers His Majesty Dinnerware Set for Thanksgiving
Sur La Table Pumpkin Dinnerware Set for Thanksgiving
Gibson Elite Shangri-La Court Dinnerware Set for Thanksgiving
Rachel Ray Cucina Pumpkin Orange Dinnerware Set for Thanksgiving