Best Butter Dish Reviews 2023

As Julia Child would say, “Butter is good for you!” Everything’s better with butter, but it needs to keep well in the refrigerator after you place a pat or two on your favorite food. Once you take the packaging off, it’s every stick of butter for himself in the cold confines of the refrigerator, where butter tends to take on the odor of its neighbors. We want you to keep your butter happy, and that is why we have selected 5 great butter dish brands for you to browse. Read on through the buying advice we have for you, and soon, your butter will stay fresh until the last pat is gone
TopProducts may earn commissions when you purchase through links on our site. Learn More.
Good For
Lid Type
Our Top Choice
OXO Good Grips Butter Dish
OXO is a thoughtful company that takes notes on how everyday people interact with their products, so they can make them as user-friendly as possible.
For a better-behaved butter, get this non-skid butter dish w/stoppers on the sides to stabilize the butter while cutting. Extra wide for European or regular size available.
Lid rests on top, but does not have a feature to secure it firmly in place.
Clear wide butter dish
7.7 x 2.2 x 3.7”, 6.4 ozs
8 oz block/(2) 4 oz sticks
Clear, removable
Best Value
Norpro Double Covered Butter Dish S/S
Explore Norpro’s Swedish and Danish line of cookware with lots of classic and specialty items to choose from.
This butter dish has the classic look of elegant silver, with generous proportions that can accommodate an 8 oz. block of butter or cream cheese.
Cover does not fit snugly.
Covered wide butter dish
Stainless steel
7.7 x 2.5 x 4”, 9.4 ozs
8 oz block/(2) 4 oz sticks
Stainless steel, removable
Homer Laughlin Fiesta Covered Butter Dish, X-Large
If you’re a fan of Fiestaware, then Homer Laughlin is the brand for you, with a gorgeous array of colors to choose from.
Richly-hued Fiestaware dresses up any table. Wide variety of colors to choose from in addition to our highlighted Cobalt Blue.
Expensive due to the excellent quality of the vitrified ceramic construction.
Extra wide Fiestaware dish
Vitrified ceramic
8.1 x 5.1 x 3.2”, 1.1 lbs
8 oz block/(2) 4 oz sticks
Removable Fiesta dome
Circleware Glass Butterfly Butter Dish
Circleware manages to merge quality and design quite well with an endless array of glassware in a variety of shapes, colors, and sizes.
A limited edition amber glass butter dish that will dress up the table on a special occasion, or every day of the week if you like to live with a little flair.
With the butterfly handle and intricate design, probably not a good choice if you have modern, streamlined tastes.
Butterfly handle butter dish
Amber glass
9.5 x 4.6 x 4.5”, 1.5 lbs
8 oz block/(2) 4 oz sticks
Money back guarantee
MyGift Sleek Ceramic Butter Dish with S/S Lid
MyGift offers stylized products for the home that bring function and design to the table. They have several serving dishes, racks, and trays to choose from.
Extremely elegant and refined ceramic butter dish with domed stainless steel cover. Can also be used for serving small hors d’oeuvre or chocolates.
Very small dish. Most appropriate for one or two people.
Covered serving dish
Stainless steel & ceramic
3.5 x 3.5 x 2.8”, 8.8 ozs
1/2 stick of softened butter
Includes cleaning cloth

Related Reviews
Best Bread Box
Best Bread Maker
Best Toaster
Best Everyday Dinnerware Set

What is the Best Butter Dish?

We went out of our way to see you gain control over the freshness of your butter to the last piece! We are confident that you will settle for a butter dish of your choice. But, if not, don’t worry, these brands have a range of other best selections for you to choose from.
Our Top Choice
Make your butter better by keeping it fresh and secure in an OXO Good Grips Butter Dish in regular or extra wide. For the perfect accompaniment, take a look at the OXO Good Grips Spreader. Its wide blade is perfect for smearing butter, jams, jellies or cream cheese, as well as soft cheeses.

OXO Good Grips Butter Dish with Clear Top and White Base – Fits Short and Long Sticks, Available in Standard or Wide Width

Taking pride in the excellent execution of products that serve the public well, OXO approaches the design of each of their household items with a precise eye for detail, making their products as user-friendly as possible. They have an extensive line of over one thousand household products.

This butter dish by OXO features convenient stoppers on either side, to brace the butter while you slice it. It is a newly released item by OXO, and rests steadily on the table thanks to its non-slip feet.

We have chosen to highlight the wide version, which measures 7.7” x 2.2” x 3.7” and weighs 6.4 ounces. It can accommodate two 4-ounce sticks of butter, a wide European-style butter bar, or an 8-ounce bar of cream cheese. Another option for you from this brand is the regular size dish, which holds one 4-ounce stick of butter.

With a soft non-slip grip, this clear plastic butter dish is BPA-free and can be placed in the dishwasher for cleaning.
Best Value
If you like the sleek and silvery look of stainless steel, then this butter dish by Norpro may be just what you’re looking for. We also loved the look of the Norpro 8370 Butter Dish with Lid. Made from white porcelain with a top knob for easy handling, it would be an attractive addition to any décor.

Norpro Stainless Steel Double Covered Butter Dish – Wide Width Fits 2 Standard Sticks or One Large Block of Butter or Cream Cheese

Norpro was founded in 1973 by Gunnar Lie, who passed his enthusiasm for the business down to his daughter Kirsten who currently runs the business as President of Norpro. Kirsten describes herself as having a passion for good food, which she puts to good use operating another company her father created called Elki, a distributor of gourmet specialty foods such as Scandinavian Delight Preserves.

For an attractive addition to your kitchen or dining room table, you may want to opt for this stainless steel butter dish by Norpro. It is extra wide, so it can accommodate 2 standard sticks of butter, or a large block of butter or cream cheese. The removable lid sits atop a 7.5-inch butter dish, and has a handle for easy access.

Keeps your butter nice and fresh, and makes an elegant presentation. Gently hand wash this butter dish to clean after use.
Bringing joy and warmth to the table, Homer Laughlin makes a brilliant line of butter dishes in a rainbow of cheerful colors. For a festive touch on your holiday table, take a look at the Fiesta Christmas Tree Covered Butter Dish with the same extra large size.

Homer Laughlin Fiesta Extra Large Covered Butter Dish - Vitrified Ceramic Available in Over a Dozen Colors and Designs

Colorful plates, dishes, cups and bowls make up the line of Fiestaware that Homer Laughlin is known for. They have decades of experience in crafting these brilliantly colored, lead-free ceramic dishes that add a cheerful quality to any table-scape. The founding brothers are from East Liverpool, Ohio, and their line of ceramic glazed dinnerware is made in the USA.

Paint a pretty picture with a vibrant pop of color offered by Homer Laughlin Fiestaware in their line of butter dishes. Made of vitrified ceramic, this practical and beautiful piece has been transformed from a basic ceramic dish to one that is glass-like in texture and impermeable to water.

The lead-free glaze on this Fiesta butter dish comes with a five-year warranty against chipping. It is dishwasher safe, and can be placed in the microwave or oven if you want to use it for a task other than keeping your butter fresh and beautifully presented.

The dish is extra large, measuring 8.1” x 5.1” x 3.2”, and comes with a cover. The dazzling array of colors to choose from include: Cobalt, Lapis, Lemongrass, Paprika, Peacock, Scarlet, Shamrock, Sunflower, Turquoise, Black, White, or Cream.
Dress the table up every day of the week, or for special occasions with this amber glass butter dish by Circleware. Don’t want something this fancy, but still want something with an elegant look? The Circleware Limited Edition Tavola Glass Butter Dish with Glass Lid would fit nicely upon any table or counter.

Circleware Glass Butterfly Butter Dish – Limited Edition Glassware Available in Amber or Green

Circleware brings an expertise to glassware that is immediately apparent when you view their line of products. From oversized one-gallon glass mason jars with a spout for dispensing your favorite drink, to tall, bee-hive shaped glass storage containers and old-fashioned garden gate drinking glasses saturated with color, they have something for everyone in glassware.

This butter dish by Circleware showcases their talent quite nicely. A standout among butter dishes, it will add a regal look to any fine affair you may be hosting.

Made of thick amber glass, this dish is solid and sturdy. The intricate design of the cover and dish is reminiscent of the baroque period with its fine detailing and touch of flair. The butterfly handle adds to its standout quality.

This trusted brand in glassware is offering this butter dish at a great value, so you’ll be quite pleased with the quality and affordability of your purchase.
The perfect gift for that high-end friend or loved one with discerning taste, this elegant butter dish by MyGift will show them you care. MyGift has another unique butter dish that you might like. Not only does their Decorative White Ceramic Lidded Butter Dish Set come with a knife spreader, but there is a holder for it built right in to the base.

MyGift Sleek White Ceramic Butter Dish with Stainless Steel Lid - Doubles as a Small Hor d'oeuvre Serving Tray

MyGift is full of surprises with their line of unique gifts and multi-purpose items. Whether it’s a spiral egg rack, turquoise blue bird butter dish, or a set of four ceramic condiment jars with tiny spoons, they bring that special something to your kitchen and dining room with innovation in design.

Only the best will do for you or someone you love with this bell-shaped butter dish that doubles as a miniature serving dish by MyGift. You’ll be living with the upper crust of society with the addition of this elegant piece to your table. The bell-shaped silver dome has a raised circular handle, and covers a white ceramic base dish to keep your butter cool.

While this dish can be used to dress up your butter when on the table, it also nicely highlights lots of other foods or special treats. Let your imagination run wild! Buy a few of them and fill them with candies and chocolates for a party or just to serve up something special to someone you love. You may also want to purchase this dish to highlight an amuse bouche or elegant hors d’oeuvre. Just keep in mind it is a petite size at 3.5” x 3.5” x 2.8”.

Treat yourself or someone you love to this beautiful serving-tray style butter dish with a stainless steel dome cover today!

How Do I Choose the Best Butter Dish?

Let’s face it, a little storage mistake and you will find that beloved butter that you spent a fortune on with a concoction of smells. Of course, we don’t want that, right? There is nothing so unwelcoming as a spoiled breakfast, especially when the thought of enjoying butter on those bread slices got you out of bed this morning! With a butter dish, you preserve that creamy taste from any foul taste intruders.

We all know bread and butter go together like – well, bread and butter. That is why we suggest that you also go for a nice bread box to maintain its freshness as well. You will be surprised how this will also maintain the bread’s softness, allowing you to effortlessly slice through it with your bread knife and easily spread over it with a butter knife.

With the right butter dish, you will soon find out how fast you forget wake up struggles while you enjoy that sumptuous breakfast. You may not know it but, this is just a small step toward ensuring you have a wonderful day. Oh, and after slicing your bread and spreading your butter, and of course enjoying your meal, don’t forget to safely put away those knives. You don’t want your morning to suddenly turn disastrous. A knife block is exactly what you need in anticipation of another spread!
Keeping your butter safe goes beyond saving you an extra coin due to spoillage. It also protects you from health risks characteristics of food contamination. That is why price should not be much of a factor while purchasing a butter dish.

Although there are cheap butter dishes, most of them are fairly priced. You can find one with anything from $5 to $35. It all comes down to the standout features that they come with. For instance, a vitrified ceramic butter dish that adds a stylish look to your kitchen will probably cost you more than a plain one. Similarly, those with customized handles have a similar effect in price.

Yes, it’s true the cheap ones may give you some benefits present in those on the higher side. However, we recommend you stick to the substantial ones because the cheap butter dishes may not give your butter the best service.
Going for a butter dish saves you from avoidable butter contaminations. Additionally, here are other features to consider while searching for the proper butter dish.
  • Material - Butter dishes are made of different materials ranging from plastics, stainless steel, amber glass, to vitrified ceramics
  • Capacity - They come in different volumes to suit the size block you want to store
  • Lid Type - You’ll find butter dishes with various lids based on your preferences
  • Handle - Some of them come with customized handles while others are plain
  • bullet
  • Design and Appearance - Butter dishes come in a range of designs from the plain ones to the stylishly made one to give your kitchen a flair touch
Construction and Design
We all want items that give us the best service. The material of a butter dish is probably one of the major factors for you to consider unless you want to keep running to the nearest sore for a new one. You will find that they come in different materials; some of which are reinforced to eliminate chipping risks. In this case, going for a stainless steel or one with a thicker amber glass will serve you longer.

Chances are that the butter dish can easily slip from your hands. That is such a saddening moment: losing both your butter and the dish! You can avoid this by opting for one with a handle for better grip. To add charm to your kitchen, you can choose a one with a stylish handle or body as well.

Most of these dishes comes with lids, which is important to ensure your butter is firmly secured from external contamination while in storage. Some are removable and clear while others are attached or opaque. So, if you often forget your spread, choose one that is clear so you can easily spot it.
Performance and Ease of Use
Ease of cleaning kitchenware is a priority for a kitchen lover. That is why you should go for a vitrified ceramic butter dish because it is dishwasher safe. You don’t want to leave anything to chances and have that butter contaminated the minute you store it.

The same goes for the type of lid on your dish. We recommend that you go for one with a lid that best enables you to firmly secure it while putting the dish away. Other than this, some lids come with a handle for better grip and ease of access. If you usually forget to place the lid back, we recommend you go for one with a non-detachable lid so you can keep your butter safely secured with a quick flip.

If you are butter lover, you probably don’t want to find yourself short of a pat when you most need it. The variance in capacity provided by these dishes allows you to stock as much as you need. That is why we recommend you go for one that can hold a full 8-ounce block. With this, you will definitely have enough time to restock before it runs out!

Get the Best Butter Dish of 2023!

The cream always rises to the top, and the best brands and products do too. Pick one of our featured brands to join the ranks of satisfied customers. Serve your butter nicely at the breakfast or dinner table so everyone can help themselves to fresh, perfect butter from the beginning to the end of the meal.

Our Top Choice
OXO Good Grips Butter Dish
Best Value
Norpro Double Covered Butter Dish S/S
Homer Laughlin Fiesta Covered Butter Dish, X-Large
Circleware Glass Butterfly Butter Dish
MyGift Sleek Ceramic Butter Dish with S/S Lid