Best Cake Knife Reviews 2017

Choosing a cake knife is an entirely different ball game from choosing a bread knife or any type of knife. While you can just stroll into a shop and pick up the first knife with a sharp edge that catches your fancy, you can’t do that with a cake knife. There are many factors at play, and you need to work them all out to get to the right option. We have taken the time to carry out extensive research, and have come up with our list of five top products from five top brands. These five brands have more than the product featured. But for the purpose of this review, we are featuring these five products. Feel free to check out the other options if the ones featured don’t appeal to you.

Watch Our Cake Knife Review

Overview

PROS

CONS

SPECS

Style

Material

Size

Care

Extras

Our Top Choice

Godinger 2 Piece Gold Leaf Cake Server Set

Godinger has everything you need for an elegant event. It offers chic, functional products at budget-friendly prices.

This set adds class to any special event, and would make a great gift. Looking for that perfect Mother’s Day gift? Look no further!

The color is more yellow than gold.

Serrated

Stainless steel and brass leaf

12.9 × 1.8 × 0.6 inches; 1.2 lb.

Hand-wash and wipe clean

Unique wedding flavor

Best Value

Mikasa Love Story Cake Serving Set

Mikasa has always meant top quality and unique design through the years. It manufactures products that are not only gorgeous and well-made, but reasonably priced to accommodate everyone’s budget.

The blades are consistently durable and rustproof, and it can be coordinated beautifully with other Love Story dinnerware.

No problems have been reported.

Handle

Stainless steel blades

2.7 × 1 × 11.6 inches; 0.9 lb.

Hand wash

Includes one pie server

Reed & Barton Francis Sterling Cake Knife

Reed & Barton manufactures authentic dinnerware, flatware, and silverware. Its products deliver good value for money spent.

It has flawless craftsmanship, with a blade that can be easily monogrammed. It's elegantly packaged in plastic, in a Reed and Barton blue box, and ideal as a gift item.

No negatives reported.

Hollow handle

Luxurious sterling silver

13.8 x 3.2 x 1.2 inches; 0.77 lb.

Hand wash

Curvaceous scrollwork

Lenox True Love Cake Knife

Lenox Corporation is one of the market leaders in tabletop and gift items. It delivers quality products and services at reasonable prices.

It can be used for anniversary dinners, because the set can be personalized with the names of the couple and their wedding date.

No problems reported.

Butterfly meadow handle

Porcelain and stainless steel

11.2 × 1 × 0.8 inches; 0.25 lb.

Dishwasher safe

Butterfly and colorful blooms

Fashioncraft Touches Wedding Cake Knife

Fashioncraft provides almost anything you can think of to make your special day or occasion memorable. Its products are unique and affordable.

It has handles that are decorated with dipped beading and lifelike seashells and starfish, and a beautiful light blue sea foam design at the bottom of the handles.

No problems have been reported.

Beach theme handle

Stainless steel, white poly resin

13.5 × 4.3 × 1.3 inches; 0.712 lb.

Hand wash

Dipped beaded design tops

(Updated July 28, 2017)

Skip ahead and go directly to the reviews.

Related Reviews

Best Cake Decorating Set

in Home Products and Decor

Ateco 14-Piece Cake Decorating Set – Available in 1 or 2 Sets

Best Cake Pop Maker

in Home Products and Decor

VonShef Electric Cake Pop Maker – Bakes Dozen Round Mini Cakes at Once, Comes with Stand and 50 Sticks

Best Bundt Pan

in Home Products and Decor

Wilton Excelle Elite 6-Cup Mini Fluted Pan

Best Stand Mixer

in Home Products and Decor

KitchenAid 600™Series 6-Quart Professional Stand Mixer – 10 Speeds, Bowl-Lift Style, 25 Colors

How Do I Choose the Best Cake Knife?

A wedding day is one of the most memorable and unforgettable days in one's life. That's why a lot of people go to great lengths to ensure that everything is just right, from the champagne glasses to the flowers to the dinnerware on the reception tables.

Wedding cakes are an important aspect of any wedding. The cutting of the wedding cake is a tradition in many marriage ceremonies and is believed to bring good luck to the new couple. Because of this belief, many couples decide to buy a special knife for this purpose. Wedding cake knives are usually more elegantly and beautifully designed than your regular chef knife, and may become a special family memento.

Making the right choice of a cake knife may seem inconsequential at the beginning, but when you begin to browse the options, you understand why you need to be armed with the information we are about to share. Please read on!

Price

There are many cake knives available for sale. You can get almost any design and style of knife that you want. The price range is wide because of many factors, such as the material that was used to make the knife, its design and the brand.

From gold-plated knives to ones made of stainless steel with porcelain handles, these knives are designed to fit different tastes and lifestyles. Naturally, ones made with any precious metal will be high-end items, while others are less expensive. In general, a good cake knife can be gotten for anything from $11.50 to $200. While carrying out this research, we came across a number of cheap cake knives, but we did not feature them because they are not made of high-quality durable materials and might disappoint you on that big day. We are confident that any choice you make based on this review will be a good one.

Features

A cake can be cut with any type of knife, so what’s the distinction between a cake knife and other types of knives? More thought and care is put into the production of a cake knife, because it’s not only used to cut cakes, it's also part of the accessories at weddings and special events. There are a number of features that you should look for when choosing a cake knife, such as:

Size of the knife in relation to the size and type of the cake
Material - choose a material that will be durable, not break if the cake's too dense and is easy to clean
The overall design and how it ties in with rest of the décor and tabletop
The sharpness of the blade - it should be able to cut cleanly through the cake
Other accessories that the knife comes with
The kind of packaging it comes in
The option of personalizing or monogramming it
Weight and sturdiness

Construction and Design

There are many designs and styles of cake knives, which gives you a wide variety from which to choose the one that fits in with your theme or overall concept. The two most common materials used to make cake knives are stainless steel and silver-plated metal, but there are many options for monogramming and/or customizing your knife. Good quality stainless steel and silver-plated metal are rustproof, and are generally more affordable and popular options. But if you can go for the one with an authentic silver blade, why not? It'll remain in the family for generations to come.

The blades of most cake knives are serrated. This enables the knife to cut through the cake easily. Be sure that it’s sharp enough for a clean cut.

Most cake knives come with a server, which is a good addition because it further enhances the overall ambiance of your table. It's a good idea to get a cake knife set (one cake knife and one cake server).

Performance and Ease of Use

Cake knives are designed with aesthetics in mind, but you need to know the strength of the knife (you wouldn't want it to break as you're cutting the wedding cake). Most of these knives look elegant and fragile, but are actually strong enough to get the job done. Pick one that is commensurate to your cake size and texture.

If you want a cake knife that can be a family heirloom, or you want to give it as a gift, consider the kind of packaging it comes in. Many cake knives come in white or ivory boxes and have a variety of designs, in keeping with the design of the knife.

There are also many theme-styled cake knives. Keep in mind the other decorations being used, so that the knife you choose won't detract from the overall effect, but rather add to it.

What is the Best Cake Knife?

There's no such thing as the best cake knife for every purpose and chef. They come in different shapes, styles, and designs, as individuals also have different taste, styles, and budgets. Just note the features that would work for you to get the result that you want, and look for them as you go shopping.That should be easy now that you’ve read our buying guide.

Our Top Choice

The Godinger 2 Piece Gold Leaf Cake Server Set consists of a cake knife and a cake server. It's made of stainless steel and brass, and has a two-tone leaf design. Are you looking for a cake knife with a whimsical design? You’re in luck! Check out the Godinger Butterfly Cake Knife\/Server.

Godinger 2 Piece Gold Leaf Cake Server Set with 1 Cake Knife & 1 Cake Server

Godinger Cake Server Set 0028199094709

Features

For over 40 years, Godinger Silver Art, Co. has specialized in handmade crystal, pewter, silver and other unique gift items. For everything you need to host an elegant event, Godinger is the go-to brand. Most importantly, Godinger offers elegant and chic products with substance, at budget-friendly prices. It has maintained its philosophy of putting customers first. Its excellent customer service has made it one of the most successful manufacturers globally.

The Godinger 2 Piece Gold Leaf (twig) Cake Server Set consists of a cake knife and a cake server. It has a two-tone leaf design and is made of stainless steel and brass. It's ideal for serving cakes and desserts at fancy dinners, weddings and other elegant events. It can also be given as a gift for housewarming, Mother's Day, a wedding or Christmas. It's of good quality, beautiful and elegant yet strong and durable. This set is a part of Godinger's new line of flatware that’s made of beaten stainless steel, and adorned with brass stems and leaves. It's currently the rage on the catering scene.

Godinger has more beautiful cake knives, some of which are listed below:

Godinger Baroque Cake Server/Knife - Silver-colored, has ornamental handles, and is versatile and elegant
Godinger Bamboo Cake Knife and Server - Each handle is wrapped with dark bamboo that makes them comfortable to hold; it gives an antique look that only real wood can offer, and has other matching serveware available
Godinger Golden Blossom Cake Knife/Server - A two-tone set that's made of quality stainless steel and brass. It’s elegant and has handles that look like branches

If you want to see more options before making your choice, Godinger has many beautiful cake knives for your perusal.

Best Value

The Mikasa Love Story Pie and Cake Serving Set is made of high-quality stainless steel blades that are decorated with fanciful ribbon accents. The handles sport a delicate heart design at the bottom. If you want a cake knife that comes in a keepsake cake-shaped box, get the Mikasa Parchment 2-Piece Stainless Steel Cake Set.

Mikasa Stainless Steel Love Story Pie & Cake Serving Set with Swirling Heart Design

Mikasa Cake Serving Set 5665277

Features

For over half a century, Mikasa, a division of Lifetime Brands, Inc., has consistently manufactured decorative accessories, crystal, flatware, stemware, dinnerware and barware. It’s proud to be globally recognized as one of the leaders in tabletop fashion and the other products mentioned. Its brand name has always meant top quality and unique design. It manufactures products that are not only gorgeous and well-made, but reasonably priced to accommodate everyone’s budget.

The Mikasa Love Story Pie and Cake Serving Set is sure to have sentimental value for years to come after you take this crystal accessory back home from your wedding. The blades are decorated with a whimsical ribbon accent, and the handles each sport a delicate heart design at the bottom. The blades are made of high-quality stainless steel. Some of its other great features include:

Rustproof
Includes a pie server and a cake knife
The stainless steel blades are consistently long-lasting
Can be coordinated beautifully with other Love Story dinnerware

If you are looking for other cake knife designs, see the rest of Mikasa's line.

The Reed & Barton Francis Sterling Cake Knife comes from the line of one of America's most wonderfully authentic flatware patterns (Francis I). It follows the superb designs of Renaissance and Baroque periods with its elaborate fruit and flower bunch design. If you want a cake knife with server set, try the Reed & Barton Lyndon 2-Piece Dessert Set.

Reed & Barton Francis Sterling Wedding Cake Knife

Reed & Barton Cake Knife 5400320

Features

Reed & Barton makes great tabletop items, such as dinnerware, flatware, and silverware. Its products are designed to become family heirlooms. Its commitment to top quality and unique design makes it one of the best-known and most highly respected brands in the industry. Its products are high-end but deliver good value.

The Reed & Barton Francis Sterling Cake Knife is a product from the line of one of America's most magnificent authentic flatware patterns (Francis I). It resembles Renaissance and Baroque designs with its elaborate fruit and flower bunch on each piece. This wedding cake knife is specially made to cut your cake at any event. Here are some of its great features:

Made in USA
Made of authentic silver material
Other coordinating flatware is available
Flawless craftsmanship by veteran artisans
Adequate place size
Elegantly packaged and comes in plastic in a Reed and Barton blue box; ideal as a gift item
The blade can be easily monogrammed

If you want other options for cake knives, view what else Reed & Barton has to offer.

The Lenox True Love Cake Knife & Server, made with silver-plated metal and porcelain handles, is a romantic set that you can use to serve anything from elegant wedding cakes to fancy dinner desserts. Not particular about customizing your knife set, but still want a Lenox product? Consider the Lenox True Love 2-Piece Dessert Set.

Lenox Butterfly Meadow Pie/Cake Knife – Available in 13 Styles including Cake Server, Casserole Spoon & Serving Set

Lenox Cake Knife 600894-865710

Features

Lenox Corporation is a market leader in the production of quality tabletop and gift items. It markets its product under three brands (Lenox, Gorham and Dansk), and a shared dedication to good quality and innovative designs puts the brands among the best known and most admired in the industry. It relies on professional, skillful and meticulous finishing to deliver top-quality products and services to the market promptly and at reasonable prices.

The Lenox True Love Cake Knife & Server is a romantic set that you can use to serve cakes and desserts. The cake knife and the server both have an elevated image of entwined hearts. It's made of silver-plated metal and can be customized with the names of the couple (12 letters each for the names and 18 characters for date).

Lenox has a lineup of great cake knives that include:

Lenox 865710 Butterfly Meadow Pie/Cake Knife - Made of porcelain and stainless steel, dishwasher safe and can be gift wrapped
Lenox Bridal Adorn Cake Knife and Server - Made of silver-plated metal and decorated with ribbon design. It's ideal for serving wedding cakes and other desserts, and is a good gift item too
Lenox Everyday Gatherings Stainless Cake Knife by Lenox - Aluminum blade and glass beaded handle

If you want to examine other options, Lenox has many more cake knives for your perusal.

. The Fashioncraft Beach Theme Wedding Cake Knife and Server Set comes in a white gift box that has an ivory seashell design and a clear acrylic top. It’s a brilliant accessory for a beach wedding. If you are looking for a set with a smaller knife and a unique design, check out the Fashioncraft From Paris with Love Collection Cake Serving Server Set.

Fashioncraft Touches Collection Beach Theme Wedding Cake Knife & Server Set – Available in 4 Quantity Options

Fashioncraft Cake Knife 2417 - 1

Features

Fashioncraft offers a wide range of products, from wedding accessories and favors, to baby shower gifts and christening accessories and everything in between. As a haven for events planners, it has almost anything you can think of to make your special day or occasion memorable. Its products are unique and budget-friendly.

The Fashioncraft Beach Theme Wedding Cake Knife and Server Set is a brilliant accessory for a beach wedding. It has handles that are decorated with dipped beading, and lifelike seashells and starfish. It has a beautiful light blue sea foam design at the bottom of the handles, and the beach design is boosted by faux pearls and sparkling blue rhinestones. It’s packaged in a white gift box with an ivory seashell design and see-through acrylic top.

Fashioncraft has other cake knives with great features, and they include the following:

VINTAGE DOUBLE HEART DESIGN KNIFE AND CAKE SERVER SET - Made with stainless steel zigzag blades and polyresin handles that are painted in epoch ivory; designed with a cut-out of two intertwined hearts
FAIRY TALE DESIGN CAKE SETS - Stainless steel blades and handles that are made of tough white polyresin. The handles are designed with a chiseled three-dimensional high heeled shoe that's inspired by Cinderella. It's a great accessory for a fairy tale themed/inspired wedding
BUTTERFLY DESIGN CAKE KNIFE/SERVER SET- An excellent accessory for a butterfly-themed wedding, or for adding a touch of class and pizzazz to any wedding reception. Beautifully designed with butterflies, made with anti-rust stainless steel and polyresin handles

If you want to examine other cake knives before making a choice, please feel free to browse Fashioncraft's collection.

Get the Best Cake Knife of 2017!

With the knowledge that you have gained from this review, we hope that you’ll be able to make a more informed choice that will give you good value for your money. Have an exciting shopping experience.

Our Top Choice

Godinger 2 Piece Gold Leaf Cake Server Set

Best Value

Mikasa Love Story Cake Serving Set

Reed & Barton Francis Sterling Cake Knife

Lenox True Love Cake Knife

Fashioncraft Touches Wedding Cake Knife