Best Cast Iron Skillet Reviews 2023

A cast iron skillet is one of those kitchen products that one may think is easy to purchase. Though not rocket science, there are features that you need to look out for when making your selection. It is important to get a good cast iron skillet because that can mean the difference between a lifetime purchase and a waste of money. We know that a lot of people may not have the time and patience to browse through the myriad of products that are out there in the market. To save you the time and stress that is involved in shopping, we have taken time to research the multitude of products that are on the market and have narrowed them down to a short list of five products from five of the best cast iron skillet brands. These brands have more than one product in this category, but for the purpose of this review, we are featuring only one product per brand. As you read through this review, you are sure to come across other products by these brands; please feel free to check them out, as they might be just what you have been looking for.
TopProducts may earn commissions when you purchase through links on our site. Learn More.
Our Top Choice
Lodge Square Cast Iron Seasoned Grill Pan
Lodge specializes in indoors and outdoors cooking equipments. The L8SGP3 skillet model is durable, efficient and comes with a heat-resistant red holder.
Good value for money. Versatile and lightweight. Offers an even cooking experience. Easy to wash. 100% made in USA.
Few customers complained that it rusted. Wash according to instructions manual to prevent this.
Cast-iron square grill pan
10.5 inch/ 7.33 lbs
Hand wash only
Best Value
Utopia Kitchen Pre-Seasoned Cast-Iron Skillet (UK0037)
Utopia Kitchen is a prestigious manufacturer of kitchen utensils. The 10.25 inch cast iron skillet is reasonably priced and it will enrich your cooking experiences!
Amazon Best Seller. Easy to clean. Versatile. Excellent for indoor and outdoor use. Chemical-free. Lightweight.
Does not come with a cover. While solidly constructed, may not produce the same quality results as a higher end skillet.
Cast-iron skillet
16.3 x 10.1 x 2.1 inches/ 4.8 lbs
Hand wash using dishwashing soap
Royal Dutch Cast Iron Cookware Set with Cast Iron Skillet
The Royal Dutch Cast Iron 1815 makes high-quality cast-iron cooking tools. The 11-piece cooking set contains numerous cast-iron kitchen utensils, essential in any kitchen.
Complete set, saves you money and time. Easy to clean and hygienic. Comes with carrying case. Tools can last a lifetime.
Expensive, but remember that you can actually save money instead of buying these tools separately.
Cast iron 11 piece cook box set
23.2 x 10.6 x 15.3 inches/ 42 lbs
Includes cleaning utensils
Yes, all pieces
T Fal E96405 Emeril Pre-Seasoned Cast-Iron Skillet Cookware
T-Fal is one of the biggest names in the kitchen tools industry. The Emeril pre-seasoned skillet is cadmium-free and comes with lifetime warranty.
Excellent value for money. Large and long handle. Oven safe. Can be used both indoors and outdoors. Lasts for a lifetime.
Some say that it rusted quickly. Make sure you following the instructions in the manual carefully.
Cast-iron skillet
17 x 11 x 3 inches/ 5.5 lbs
Hand wash only
Matte enamel coating
Pioneer Woman Timeless Cast Iron Skillet
The Pioneer Woman specializes in kitchen and dining accessories. The Timeless cast-iron skillet offers a large cooking surface and it is oven safe.
Attractive design. Versatile and easy to use. Can be washed using regular dishwasher soap. Durable and long-lasting.
Some say that food sticks to it. Not everyone knows how to use such skillets.
Cast-iron enamel skillet
25.3 x 17.4 x 5 inches/ 12.5 lbs
Hand wash only
Enamel coating

Related Reviews
Best Cookware Set
Best Indoor Grill
Best Pre Seasoned Skillet
Best Grill Pan

What is the Best Cast Iron Skillet?

There are many good cast iron skillets in the market, so we can’t reasonably say that any one product is the best cast iron skillet. One thing we can tell you, however, is that the value of a product is determined by the level of satisfaction it affords the user. One thing that will ensure that you get good value for any purchase is the features it carries. Therefore, as you read through this review, we encourage you to pay close attention to the features listed and discussed, and this will keep you informed on what to look out for when you go shopping. Only when you get a product with the right features can it be said that you have gotten the best cast iron skillet for you.
Our Top Choice
The Lodge L8SGP3 is a cast-iron square grill pan which ensures even cooking and features superior heat retention. You can buy it with a silicone handle as well. If you are looking for a traditional flat bottom cast iron skillet, Lodge has a wide variety, including the 10.25 inch pre-seasoned skillet, another Amazon Best Seller.

Lodge 10.5-inch Pre-Seasoned Cast-Iron Square Grill Pan – Good for Both Indoor and Outdoor Cooking

Lodge is a brand that specializes in cooking accessories and kitchen tools particularly made from cast iron. This company sells a wide variety of skillets, grilling pans, Dutch ovens as well as outdoor cooking tools and even recipe books. While doing the research for this review, we were impressed by the Lodge L8SGP3 skillet and we think it is indispensable in every kitchen.
Here are the highlights of this cast iron skillet.
  • You can buy it as a standalone 10.5 inch grill pan or together with a hot handle holder.
  • It is ready to use and pre-seasoned.
  • The bottom of the grill is ribbed for low-fat cooking.
  • This skillet can be used on all cooking surfaces, both indoors and outdoors.
  • The hot handle holder is made from silicone and it is dishwasher safe.
If you are interested in cooking gloves, lid lifters or other kitchen accessories, make sure that you browse Lodge's products as they are reasonably priced and highly practical.
Best Value
The pre-seasoned cast iron skillet from Utopia Kitchen ensures an even cooking experience and it is currently an Amazon Best Seller! If you are looking to build a full cast iron cookware collection, we recommend checking out Utopia Kitchen’s Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Dutch Oven that comes with a cover (and can be used for casseroles too).

Utopia Kitchen 10.25 Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast-Iron Skillet – Available in Other Sizes

We are happy to report that Utopia Kitchen is a professional manufacturer of kitchen appliances and tools and many of its products are Amazon Best Sellers at the moment of this writing. We were particularly impressed by their 10.25 inch cast iron skillet because it is versatile, easy to use and it can withstand a lot of wear and tear.
Let's discover the features of this product.
  • It can be washed using regular dishwasher soap.
  • The skillet is perfect for cooking vegetables, steaks, paninis and more.
  • Because it is made entirely from cast iron, it is safer and more hygienic than nonstick pans.
  • This skillet can be used in the oven or even during a campfire.
  • It is completely lead-free.
We would like to remind you that Utopia Kitchen makes many other useful kitchen accessories such as knife sets, knife sharpening stones, vegetable slicers and so on. These products are well received by the general public and useful in any household.
The Royal Dutch Cast Iron 11 Piece Cook Box Set provides everything you need in a modern kitchen! This cast-iron bundle includes a 12" skillet, a Dutch oven pot, a small sauce pot, a heavy-duty cast-iron griddle and several other accessories. These cooking tools are pre-seasoned and ready to use!

Royal Dutch Cast Iron 11 Piece Cook Box Set with Vintage Carrying Storage Box

Just as the name implies, the Royal Dutch Cast Iron 1815 is a company that specializes in cast-iron tools and accessories. For our #3 spot in the review, we wanted to include a complete set which can serve all your cooking needs. This cooking set contains 11 pieces and they arrive in a beautiful, vintage-style wooden box.

Let's find out more details about this complete cook box set.
  • In the package you will find a lid lifter, a trivet, a silicone hand holder and other accessories.
  • All these utensils are pre-seasoned and made from chemical-free cast iron.
  • You can use these cooking tools both indoors and outdoors.
  • The rustic wooden box ensures easy transport to the nearby barbecue park.
  • Organic vegetable oil can be used for pre-seasoning and keeping your tools clean.
The Emeril E96405 from T-Fal can withstand temperatures up to 600 degree Fahrenheit and it is made entirely from cast-iron. We also loved the pre-seasoned cast iron pizza pan which is not only safe for both the oven and stove, but doubles as a griddle.

T Fal 10-Inch Emeril Lagasse All-Clad Pre-Seasoned Cast-Iron Skillet – Matte Enamel Coating, Oven Safe Up to 600 Degrees

T-Fal is one of the most popular and reputable brands of kitchen equipments and accessories in the world. This company specializes in skillets, deep fryers, saucepans, non-stick pans and many other cooking tools. We liked the 10 inch pre-seasoned skillet from this brand and we think it is essential in any kitchen.
Let's discover the benefits of this cast-iron skillet.
  • It has a lifetime warranty, provided it is washed by hand.
  • It arrives pre-seasoned and it also comes with seasoning instructions.
  • The handle is large and long, for easy maneuvering.
  • This skillet is lead-free and doesn’t contain harsh chemicals.
  • It is also oven safe and can be used to cook a wide variety of foods.
Remember that if you need a sandwich maker, straining spoon, a basting cup or even an electric kettle, T-Fal is the brand to go for as its products are sophisticated and durable.
The 12 inch Timeless Cast Iron skillet from The Pioneer Woman offers generous cooking space and it is completely oven safe. This quality enamel coated cast iron skillet is available in several other colors that would fit perfectly in any country kitchen, including linen white, plum and turquoise blue.

The Pioneer Woman Ree Drummond 12 Inch Timeless Cast Iron Skillet with Enamel Coating – Available in Multiple Colors

The Pioneer Woman is another brand that makes high-quality kitchen & dining accessories and tools at affordable prices. For example, the glass tumbler sets, kitchen gloves and cutlery sets this company makes are highly-appreciated on Amazon and they are designed with utmost attention to details. In a similar fashion, the 12inch Timeless Cast Iron skillet would be a great addition to your kitchen.
Here are the advantages of this cooking tool.
  • It is made entirely from cast iron and comes with a durable handle for easy maneuvering.
  • The skillet can be used on a stovetop and in an oven.
  • It is designed to be oven safe and retains its color.
  • You can even use it as a serving dish, not only a cooking tool.
  • It is available in several color options for you to choose from.
If you liked this one, maybe you are also interested in a Dutch oven, ceramic measuring cups or lunch bags. All these products are made by The Pioneering Woman and they worth checking out.

How Do I Choose the Best Cast Iron Skillet?

It is often said that a workman is no better than his tools; we couldn’t agree more. Kitchenware and appliances determine the ease with which a chef operates and the quality of the end result of her endeavors. Cast iron skillets are time-tested cookware that help you achieve excellent results in your cooking. It is one kitchen tool that can be passed down as a family heirloom and will be greatly appreciated by those who understand its value. It is a versatile and multi-functional utensil; on those days when you do not feel like pulling out your panini press and frying pan, you can use this skillet for golden brown omelets and scrumptious panini. It’s also good to go from the stove top to the oven; no hassle of transferring food from pot to baking pan or any other specialized bakeware.

Every chef that’s worth his salt knows that your cookware set is incomplete without one or two good cast iron skillets; they really make a difference in your cooking. Although technology has brought us electric skillets, a lot of people still prefer the traditional heavy-duty cast iron skillets. Most would even go out of their way to look for vintage cast iron skillets at auctions and yard sales. If you are one of those, be sure that you are fully equipped with the knowledge and patience to restore your purchase to its original glory. However, if you don’t have the knowledge of what to look out for when shopping for a vintage cast iron skillet, there are guides and articles online that will give you an idea of what to look for. You’d do well to avail yourself of those resources.

Top 5 Cast Iron Tips from Someone Who Knows!

Proper cleaning, seasoning, storing and cooking with cast iron – Tip # 1 NO paper towels. | Courtesy of Cowboy Kent Rollins
Cast iron skillets are generally pricier than ordinary frying pans or cookware. We all appreciate the fact that there are a lot of factors that affect the price of a commodity. These factors include: the quality of the material used to manufacture it, the size, number in a set, design and features, as well as the brand that manufactured it. A skillet made by a well-known and established brand will most definitely be costlier than those made by no-name brands. Those that have been featured on celebrity TV shows or endorsed by celebrity chefs are also at the higher end of the price range.

That said, a good cast iron skillet can be bought for as low as $29 and as high as $250, depending on whether it’s a single piece or a set, and the number of items in the set. However, there are cheap cast iron skillets in the market and also costlier ones, so this price range is not absolute. We assure you that the products in the price range we have stated will give you good value for your money. As always, we advise you against making any choice based solely on the cost of a product; remember that you get what you pay for.
Cast iron skillets are some of the most durable cookware of all time. They can be used for a large variety of cooking tasks. A good cast iron skillet gives you a whole new and exciting experience in your cooking, but you need to have one with the right features to enjoy this experience.

There are many features that a good cast iron skillet must have, and we have listed some of them below so that you can look out for them as you shop. Here they are…
  • Design/Style – Most cast iron pans are basically round, but some may have other features in their design, like a pouring spout.
  • Capacity – This refers to the quantity of food it can be used to prepare.
  • Material – The material the skillet is made of determines the durability, lack of chemical substances and its ability to be nonstick.
  • Size – Cast iron skillets come in graduated sizes so you would do well to select the right size for your culinary needs, especially if you are buying just one pan.
  • Carry and Storage Option – Some skillets come with carry bags or containers, which makes it easy to store or move about.
  • Heat Retention and Distribution – It is essential that you get a skillet that not only distributes heat well, but also retains it for long.
  • Types of Handles and Knobs – This would affect the maneuverability of the pan.
  • Versatility and Multifunction – You should be able to use it to cook different types of food.
  • Ease of Cleaning and Maintenance – Consider how easy it will be for you to clean and maintain your skillet.
We will now go on to explore in greater detail the benefits of these features; please read on…
Construction and Design
Cast iron skillets, as the name clearly shows, are made of cast iron, which is a material that can last a lifetime; this makes it an all-time favorite with both home cooks and veteran chefs. When shopping for a cast iron skillet, ensure that your product of choice is actually made of cast iron and not a mix of materials. When you get a cast iron skillet that’s made of top-quality materials, you are assured of a chemical-free utensil that won’t rust (given the proper care and maintenance) and also can last even to the next generation.

Some cast iron skillets come pre-seasoned from the factory. This means that you can use them straight from the box, while others may require that you season them. This process is not rocket science, neither does it require salt and pepper (lol). All you need to do is apply cooking oil to the pan, wipe it thoroughly, and allow it to heat for one hour in the oven, then leave to cool. You do this for a skillet that’s not pre-seasoned, but you can also do it when you notice that your skillet has started to stick.

A good skillet should have a handle or handles that makes it easy to maneuver; you don’t want a handle that will burn your fingers or cause you to drop your pan. Look out for a handle that’s heat resistant or, better still, double handles which make it easier for you to carry the pan without placing your hands on hot metal.

Brand new cast iron skillets will often come in a set of graduated sizes, but we know that most home cooks will want to just pick one or two from the set. We noted that the most convenient sizes for home use are the 8’’, 10’’ and 12’’ – anything outside this might either be too small or too big. But, if you are starting out as a professional chef, of course we advise that you get a whole set! You never can say when a particular size will come in handy.

How to Properly Clean & Re-season Cast Iron After Cooking

How to Clean and Season Cast Iron Pan Using Cast Iron Conditioner. | Courtesy of Cooking With Cast Iron
Performance and Ease of Use
A good cast iron skillet should be able to distribute heat evenly and retain it for a long time. You may be wondering how on earth you would be able to know whether the product you are thinking of buying will do this effectively; don’t sweat. One way of ascertaining this is by reading reviews by verified buyers who have used the product you are thinking of purchasing.

Another feature that you should look out for is a skillet that’s versatile and can be used for multiple functions, both indoors and outdoors. This means that you can throw it into your camping gear and use it to boil water over an open fire, cook the fish you caught in the stream, and also bake some flat bread! To facilitate this feature, some skillets come with carry bags or boxes that make it easy for transportation. And, even if you don’t plan to go camping with yours, the carry bag or box makes for ease of storage.

Although cast iron skillets are not dishwasher compliant, they are not difficult to wash, all that’s required is a little dishwashing soap and a scouring sponge. Again, look to reviews to confirm this, but we promise that our featured products are easy to clean and maintain.

Get the Best Cast Iron Skillet of 2023!

Thank you for taking out time to read through to the end of this review. We are optimistic that we have provided you with adequate information that will help you make the right choice. Why not go ahead and place that order? We know that surely you’ll get a good fit for your requirements from one of these featured products, or any other by the featured brands.

Our Top Choice
Lodge Square Cast Iron Seasoned Grill Pan
Best Value
Utopia Kitchen Pre-Seasoned Cast-Iron Skillet (UK0037)
Royal Dutch Cast Iron Cookware Set with Cast Iron Skillet
T Fal E96405 Emeril Pre-Seasoned Cast-Iron Skillet Cookware
Pioneer Woman Timeless Cast Iron Skillet