Best Coffee Percolator Reviews 2023

There are over a thousand and one ways to do something wrong, and making coffee is one of those things that you can do wrong, especially when you’re inundated with all the coffee percolator options that are available. We want you to enjoy your cup of coffee; it’s one of the little pleasures of this life, and that’s why we’ve searched out five of the best coffee percolator brands available today and reviewed one percolator from each. Take your time to enjoy it and check them out for more, if you aren’t satisfied with these.

300x300 Coffee Wholesale USA 10% OFF Coupon

TopProducts may earn commissions when you purchase through links on our site. Learn More.
Our Top Choice
Farberware 12-Cup Percolator
Farberware specializes in coffee makers and percolators. The FCP412 model can brew from 4 to 12 cups and it is incredibly easy to use.
Durable, solid construction. Long handle. Powerful. Automatically switches to "keep warm" function. Compact and lightweight.
Isolated complaints regarding reliability.
Coffee percolator
43.8 x 7.3 x 13.5 inches/ 1.9 lbs
Stainless steel
12 cups
1000 Watts
Best Value
Presto 12-Cup Coffee Maker
Presto is a prestigious manufacturer of kitchen equipments and appliances. This coffee percolator is easy to use and built from durable materials.
Amazon Best Seller. Can brew up to 12 cups. Highly powerful. Attractive, elegant design. Stainless steel construction.
Some say that it rusted after a while. Make sure you clean according to the instructions in the manual.
Coffee maker
13.1 x 9.7 x 6.2 inches/ 3.5 lbs
Stainless steel
2-12 cups
Signal light  when coffee is done
Hamilton Beach 42-Cup Coffee Urn
Hamilton Beach is a well-known company specialized in kitchen appliances. The 40515 coffee urn can prepare lots of coffee at once and comes with a 2-way dispenser.
Amazon Best Seller. Reasonably priced. Easy to use. Attractive design. Side handles for easy transport. 2-year warranty.
Few customers complain about leaking problems. Remember that it comes with 2-year warranty.
Coffee urn
11.5 x 11.5 x 18 inches/ 1.1 lbs
spec answer – 33 characters max
12 to 42 cups
2-way dispenser
Coleman 12-Cup Stainless Steel Percolator
Coleman is a reputable manufacturer of kitchen accessories and outdoor equipments. The 12-cup stainless steel percolator has an attractive design and won't corrode.
Reasonably priced. Dishwasher safe, easy to clean. Can be used for a lifetime. Large and comfortable handle.
Isolated complaints regarding build quality.
Coffee percolator
6.2 x 7.1 x 8.5 inches/ 2.3 lbs
Stainless steel
12 cups
Corrosion resistant
Medelco® 8-Cup Glass Stovetop Percolator
Medelco is a professional manufacturer of coffee products and accessories. The 8-Cup Borosilicate Glass Stovetop Percolator is a great, portable coffee maker.
Compact, lightweight and attractive design. Borosilicate glass retains heat and keeps your coffee warm. Handle remains cool.
Small capacity, but Medelco makes larger coffee percolators.
Coffee stovetop percolator
7.4 x 5.5 x 7.3 inches/ 10 lbs
Borosilicate glass
8 cups
Thermal shock resistant

Related Reviews
Best Coffee Grinder
Best Automatic Coffee Maker
Best Cappuccino Machine
Best Espresso Machine
Watch Our Coffee Percolator Review

What is the Best Coffee Percolator?

You want to enjoy coffee that’s rich without being bitter, and quickly prepared without being weak; hopefully, the knowledge from our guide will help you spot the coffee percolator to give you just that in the reviews you’re about to read.

100% Direct Trade Coffee. Fresh-Roasted On Demand. 50% Off First Order!

Our Top Choice
The Farberware FCP412 coffee percolator has a total power of 1000 watts and it is made from durable stainless steel. It can brew up to 12 cups of coffee at once. On the other hand, if your budget is smaller, go for the Farberware Classic Stainless Steel Yosemite 8-Cup Coffee Percolator instead.

Farberware Stainless Steel Coffee Percolator with "Keep Warm" Function, 1000 W, Cup A Minute Speed

Farberware is a brand that specializes in making kitchen accessories, tools and appliances. This brand already has several best selling products on Amazon such as tool sets and nonstick pans. We also loved the Farberware FCP412 coffee percolator and we think it is worth a spot in our review.
Here are the highlights of this product.
  • It can brew from 4 to 12 cups.
  • It has a quick brewing speed and it is made entirely from stainless steel.
  • It features a "keep warm" function.
  • The cord is detachable.
  • It comes with a strong, durable and comfortable handle for easy maneuvering.
Remember to check out Farberware's products if you are looking for nonstick knife sets, wood rolling pins and even microwave ovens.
Best Value
The Presto 02811 coffee maker can make up to 12 cups of coffee at the same time with a speed of one cup every minute! This coffee percolator is currently an Amazon Best Seller! If you prefer a coffee maker with a different design then check out the Presto MyJo Single Cup Coffee Maker.

Presto Stainless Steel Coffee Percolator, Makes 2 to 12 Cups, Light Indicator, One Cup A Minute Speed

Presto specializes in kitchen and dining accessories and equipments. Many of their products are currently Amazon Best Sellers and this thing speaks about the quality of the products this brand makes. We loved the Presto 02811 coffee maker and we are sure you will love it as well.

Here are the main features of this coffee percolator.
  • It comes with a small spout for easy pouring.
  • This coffee maker is made from stainless steel which ensures its durability.
  • It features a small light to let you know that the coffee is ready.
  • The speed of this percolator is about 1 cup every minute.
  • You can choose to make from 2 to 12 cups at once.
We would like to add here that Presto also makes great Belgian waffle makers, food dehydrators, electric skillets and many other kitchen appliances. Check out their products and you will definitely find something interesting at an affordable price!
The Hamilton Beach 40515 coffee urn is ideal for preparing coffee for large groups of people. This model is an Amazon Best Seller and it can prepare from 12 to 42 cups of coffee at once. If you prefer a commercial coffee run then go for the Hamilton Beach D50065 coffee maker instead.

Hamilton Beach Coffee Urn, Makes 12 to 42 Cups, Stainless Steel Construction, 2-Way Dispenser

Hamilton Beach is a reputable and popular brand that sells a wide variety of kitchen appliances and accessories. For our review, we have picked a coffee urn, which is just like a coffee percolator except it can prepare large amounts of coffee at the same time. The Hamilton Beach 40515 coffee maker we went for can prepare up to 42 cups of coffee at once, but if you are interested in a smaller, simpler coffee percolator, Hamilton Beach definitely has lots of standard coffee makers for you to choose from.
Now let's discover the highlights of our 42-cup coffee urn.
  • It features a light that lets you know when coffee is ready to be served.
  • This coffee urn also has a 2-way dispenser.
  • It is easy to use and suitable for large parties or corporate events.
  • It comes with a 2 year warranty.
  • The coffee urn features a stainless steel, durable construction.
Hamilton Beach also manufactures exquisite food blenders, sandwich makers as well as full-size coffee makers for you to choose from. Take a look at this brand's products as they come at reasonable prices and are highly appreciated by the general public.
The Coleman 12-Cup Stainless Steel Percolator is corrosion resistant, compact and lightweight, You can take it with you wherever you go to prepare a delicious, fresh cup of coffee. If you prefer a slightly larger one then go for the Coleman 2000016405 14 Cup model instead.

Coleman 12-Cup Stainless Steel Percolator with Large Handle, Compact, Lightweight, Corrosion Resistant

Coleman is a brand known for making high-quality outdoor and camping products and equipments. This company is in the business for more than 100 years and it is a highly popular brand in the United States. For our list, we have chosen the 12-cup coffee percolator because it has an attractive design and it is made from stainless steel.
Here are the main advantages of this coffee maker.
  • It will not rust or corrode.
  • You can use it to prepare from 2 to 12 cups of coffee at once.
  • The percolated can be disassembled quickly for easy cleaning.
  • It comes with a large handle made from stainless steel.
We are happy to report that Coleman also manufactures high-quality tents, barbecue grills and camping/outdoor equipments. If you plan an outdoor adventure soon, check out Coleman's products to enrich your experience!
The Medelco 8-Cup Borosilicate Glass Stovetop Percolator  features a unique design and it is made from glass that retains heat. It is easy to use and dishwasher safe. On the other hand, if your budget is smaller, go for the Medelco Personal Coffee Maker which is equally practical.

Medelco 8-Cup Borosilicate Glass Coffee Percolator with Large Handle and Trivet, Dishwasher Safe

Medelco is a professional brand specialized in coffee makers, coffee percolators, coffee filters and almost anything related to coffee! We explored the products of this brand and we absolutely loved the Medelco 8-Cup Borosilicate Glass Stovetop Percolator because it offers excellent value for money.
Let's take a look at the highlights of this product.
  • The glass is capable of keeping your coffee warm for a long period of time.
  • This percolator is stain resistant and dishwasher safe.
  • The handle is large and remains cool to the touch.
  • In the package you will also find a trivet.
  • You are capable of preparing up to 8 delicious cups of coffee at once.
If you liked this product then you will probably also like the numerous types of coffee carafes Medelco makes. These products come at reasonable prices and have received lots of positive reviews on Amazon.

How Do I Choose the Best Coffee Percolator?

In spite of the “black sheep status” coffee percolators seem to have when it comes to coffee makers, it’s still a favorite of quite a number of people and, since you’re reading this, you are probably one of them. People hating on this coffee-making old timer have their reasons, chief of which is the bitter taste that is associated with coffee made with percolators. However, in fairness to the device, knowing how to properly use it takes care of that problem.

Coffee percolators are of two types; we have the electric percolators and the stovetop percolators. The electric percolators, like coffee makers, need to be connected to an electrical power source before they function, while their stovetop counterparts only need to be placed on a heat source, whether it’s a campfire or your kitchen stove.

To get great coffee with a percolator, timing is key. It’s also important that your coffee beans be well-ground so that you’re able to get all of the flavor out in the shortest time possible, and a good coffee grinder should be on hand to efficiently handle that task.

Not many people like their coffee cold – we’re yet to come across any – and the warmer feature on coffee percolators ensures that you don’t have to join that tiny demographic (seeing as we live in an interesting world, we wouldn’t be surprised to find that such people exist). If you don’t already have cup warmers, you’ll find this to be a very handy feature, as it’ll save you some trips to the kitchen for refills, since you can just place it on a table wherever you are.

Finally, we believe that you’re in the best position to decide what the best coffee percolator for you is and we do not intend to argue on that point, but we’ll tell you this – coffee can only be as good as the brewer allows, so don’t settle for something cheap.
When it comes to shopping for a coffee percolator, you’re going to find them at different price points. This is basically due to the fact that there are two types of coffee percolators: the electric and the stovetop percolators. They can be made with different materials and boast different features. This means that the price any of these coffee brewers are sold for will depend, to a large extent, on the type of materials it’s made with and the features it comes with. The coffee percolators we featured in our review fall into a $30 to $63 price range and, although cheap coffee percolators are also available, we didn’t consider them in this review, as they didn’t meet our standard for great quality.
As with all good things, you’ve got to know what to look for if you’re going to end up with a coffee percolator that you’ll be pleased with. So, what are those features that make a great coffee percolator? Here is a list of some of the more important ones:
  • Type
  • Capacity
  • Filter Size
  • Size
  • Material
  • Cleaning up
  • Prep Time
Let’s talk about these features some more, shall we?
Construction and Design
As we’ve already mentioned, there are two types of coffee percolators: the stovetop percolators and the electric percolators. They are similar in their basic construction, seeing as it’s the same principle at work in both of them. The obvious difference between the two of them is in the cover or lid. You see, while the stovetop percolator comes with a transparent lid which allows you to watch over the coffee so that you’ll know when it’s ready (using the color intensity of the liquid as an indicator), the electric percolator automatically shuts itself off when the coffee is ready (this one uses a preset timer). The only other major difference is in the fact that you’ll need electricity to run one, and you won’t need it to run the other.

Coffee percolators are made with a variety materials that include stainless steel, aluminum, glass, plastic etc. Always determine beforehand the type of percolator you want, as it will help you determine which material will best suit your purposes, seeing as some of these materials will require more care than others.
Performance and Ease of Use
If you’ll be making coffee for only yourself, or to drink with a few friends that drop by, it doesn’t make much sense to get a coffee percolator with a large capacity. It’ll just take up precious counter space and probably prolong the prep time. For a large family, or for those occasions where one has quite the number of coffee drinkers gathered in one place, a coffee percolator with a larger capacity would do just fine.

Talking about capacity brings us to two other issues – size and prep time. The standard prep time for percolating coffee isn’t quite established, but it’s somewhere between three and five minutes. Just bear in mind that the longer a pot of coffee percolates, the higher the chances that you’ll end up with bitter stuff when you turn off the heat.

Now, on to the issue of size. This may be a simple matter of aesthetics for some, but for those of us with limited counter or tabletop space, it’s a make-or-break feature. To avoid the dilemma that will arise from having to figure out how to work with a large percolator in a small space, check out the dimensions before buying.

it’s believed that the finer the ground coffee, the shorter the prep time and the sweeter the end product. However, the filter basket on some percolators may be wide enough to allow the ground coffee to pass though, resulting in grainy coffee. Look for percolators with fine filters, or you can add filter paper to the setup when it arrives.

Properly washing your percolator is essential to getting a delicious cup of coffee. Find out the maintenance requirements of the percolator before purchasing. Some of them have parts that can be washed in a dishwasher, heating element included. Read the washing instructions to learn this.

Get the Best Coffee Percolator of 2023!

We’re glad you read our review and we do hope you found that percolator; place your order and get to sipping!

100% Kona Coffee

Our Top Choice
Farberware 12-Cup Percolator
Best Value
Presto 12-Cup Coffee Maker
Hamilton Beach 42-Cup Coffee Urn
Coleman 12-Cup Stainless Steel Percolator
Medelco® 8-Cup Glass Stovetop Percolator