Best Cookie Cutter Reviews 2019
When any occasion draws near, you start thinking about what you can contribute to the party or what gift to get someone, and it can get quite stressful. We don’t want you to be stressed at all, especially near holidays or birthdays. They’re a time for joy, laughing and, of course, eating! So, instead of panicking about what to bring to the party, get yourself a set of cookie cutters and all your problems will be solved! (Okay, maybe not all of them, but definitely the cookie-related problems). With many shapes and designs to choose from, navigating the world of cookie cutters can be harsh. That’s why we’ve done the hard work for you and researched five of the best brands of cookie cutters. So, sit back with a cup of something hot and take a look at what we came up with. If you are specifically looking for round cookie cutters, we have a separate review for those too that you can check out!
(Updated May 11, 2018)
How Do I Choose the Best Cookie Cutter?
Like the popular quote from the hit series game of thrones, “Winter is coming” which means baked treats!... well the quote doesn’t say anything about baked treats but we think it should! Winter is the time when we pull on our woolly jumps in our warm cozy homes and bake treats for family and friends (and ourselves) for the festivities ahead. Whether that’s Halloween, thanks giving or perfecting our cookies with our children to feed Santa Clause, we love it all! And if we are to feed the famous Santa Clause himself, we think we need to test on ourselves first…just to be sure. This means trying out different recipes, shapes and sizes.
So, time to crack out that whisk or even invest in a new stand mixer or cookie press if you fancy yourself a new toy to your collection. But let’s not forget the classic cute cookie cutters that come with assortments of circles, hearts, stars and people for that gingerbread man/woman! With all that variety, it can be easy to forget about the classic cookie created with a rounded cutter
that is a winner for dunking…and no gingerbread people were harmed in the process!
With so many awesome brands out there making cookie cutters it’s difficult to choose between them. We even had to leave a couple of awesome brands off our review because there’s so many. StarPack Home is one of them. They manufacture high-quality, functional home products, including their 18-Piece Christmas Cookie Cutter Set
. Alternatively, some brands like Ateco make more simple designs but with heavy-duty, durable materials. That’s certainly the case for the Ateco Plain Edge Round Cutters
which have graduated sizes and are made from stainless steel.
Whichever shape is your favorite for cookies, we’re here to help you decide on the ideal cookie cutter for you. Let’s delve in deeper on the different factors to consider when making this purchase.
Buying a new cookie cutter will not break the bank but there is, of course, some cheap cookie cutters and some high-end ones. The price range of a good cookie cutter is between around $8 up to about $20. The price varies depending on a number of things, like the material used, for example. It may be made from a more durable steel which is more likely to last longer than plastic counter parts. Another area that you may want to consider is the variety of shapes provided. Are you looking for the classic star, heart, flower and circle we all know and love, or are you looking for something a bit niche for maybe a fancy dress party or special occasion?
You’d be surprise about some of the varieties you may come across, I’m pretty sure I saw some cookie cutters on Instagram of popular rappers and we’re talking about the return of 2pac in cookie form so maybe you fancy baking with your homies… Now, there are cheaper products available, but sometimes it’s worth treating yourself on something a little different to impress not only the taste buds but also the eyes or just knowing that it may last you for years to come!
Believe it or not but cookie cutters have adapted over the years with the growth in technology. Who would have thought that there was a time where dishwashers didn’t exist and everything had to be washed by hand? (it’s been a lifesaver in our TopProducts office!). With the introduction of tech like this means our classic steel and tin cutters may not be suitable for dishwashers but we have a solution for you! Plastic cutters tend to be dishwasher friendly which is helpful for those whom prefer baking but not necessarily the cleaning up (I think that applies to a lot of us!). This is especially important as there are a variety of quirky shapes available on the market with more nooks and crannies to clean up. But when it comes down to it, one of the most important features of the cookie cutter, regardless of the shape, is ensuring a nice clean cut so you can create your identical gingerbread army ready to march into hungry bellies.
Construction and Design
When looking at the construction and design of the cutter, it’s worth thinking about who will be baking. If it’s for adults, the steel or tin cutters tend to be more reliable and durable. So, if you’re considering being the next cookie version of Buddy Valastro (Cake Boss), you may want to opt for these and you can expect neat and precise shapes. However, these tend to be a little sharper and not suitable for young children, but plastic cutters are a great alternative for all the family.
If it is likely that you will baking with children, some cutters are BPA free and FDA approved, giving you peace of mind if that is something that concerns you. And when it comes down to the construction, nothing is worse than cutting into cookie dough expecting a nice clean cut, only for it to get stuck to the cutter and ruin its shape. It can make a batch of cookie baking more frustrating than it needs to be. Luckily there’s a solution for this; some cutters are designed to have non-stick features to minimize the risk of your dough getting stuck.
Finally, when it comes to design, that’s a matter for personal preference. You may want a classic circle, a mix of generic shapes to use all year round, or a special shape that will only get used on the odd occasion. Luckily, these days, you can get cookie cutters in almost any shape, so you shouldn’t have an issue finding what you need. If you’re buying these cutters to enjoy with your little ones, you might consider getting some that are brightly colored as your kids will love to choose their favorite shape and color to use.
Performance and Ease of Use
Using a cookie cutter is pretty easy, whether that’s pressing down into cookie dough or letting your child create shapes with it in their play dough (It’s not just for cookies!). It’s a simple process; just line up your doughy goodness (or playdough in some cases) and press down the cutter into the dough to make the desired shape. You’ll know if your cutter is good because the proof will be in the pudding. You will either have people commenting like “wow that really looks like a snowflake!” or “what’s that supposed to look like?” That’s a good indication as to whether your cutter has performed to what is expected.
Also, cleaning your cookie cutter couldn’t get much easier if you decide opt for the plastic option as they are usually dishwasher safe. But, if you do opt for the more tradition style of steel and tin, then it will likely take you back to the more traditional ways, which is nice because it can give you a bit of nostalgia of the time you cooked with your parents or grandparents when you were little and dishwashers didn’t exist.
What is the Best Cookie Cutter?
When you choose cookie cutters, there’s a lot to think about. Mainly, you want to make sure you get the shapes that you want, or a variety of shapes if you haven’t got a particular design in mind. Then you need to think about material. If you have small children that will be “helping” you bake, you might want to opt for child friendly plastic cutters, but if your baking is your “me time”, then going for a durable, steel cutter could be the way to go. With all things considered, we think we’ve got quite a good variety for you here. And also, if you like the look of the brand we’ve featured but aren’t sure on the specific set chosen, check out what else they have to offer—some of these brands are really nuts about cookies!
Our Top Choice
The Ann Clark Cookie Cutters Christmas Cutter Set is a great addition to your baking supplies, and could also make a very thoughtful (and inexpensive) Christmas present this year! However, if Christmas isn’t really your thing (really!? Bah humbug) then why not take a look at the equally high-quality, Football 3 Piece Cookie Cutter Set
Ann Clark Cookie Cutters Christmas / Holiday Cookie Cutter Set - 5 Piece - Snowflake, Star, Christmas Tree, Gingerbread Man and Angel
Ann Clark Cookie Cutters Cookie Cutter A6-133
Ann Clark Cookie Cutters is the true definition of a family-run business. The company was founded by Ann Clark, a woman from Maryland who had a love of painting and baking, and her husband. The small business has grown and grown, and now they are America’s largest cookie cutter manufacturer with thousands of happy customers. In true family style, Ann Clark’s son, Ben, is now the CEO of the business and her grandchildren are known to lend a helping hand when it comes to cookie tasting and decorating!
This company was born and bred in the USA, and they manufacture their product 100% in-house! Their Christmas Cookie Cutter Set is made in Vermont and uses heavy duty, tin-plated steel which gives them their durability. This also means that these cutters do not necessarily have to be used with cookies only. You can also use them for bread, sandwiches, fondant, soft fruit, cheese or even craft clay if you’re feeling artsy.
Baking is a great way to relieve stress, and in the hustle and bustle of the holiday season, it can be a great way to unwind. Within this cookie cutter set you will receive a snowflake, snow-covered tree, angel, gingerbread man and star; you can’t get more festive than that! Get baking with these Christmassy shapes, and you’re bound to put a smile on everyone’s faces, even on a Monday! The only thing you won’t be smiling about is the washing-up! Yes, unfortunately these cookie cutters are not dishwasher safe, but hey, if you want a set of cookie cutters to last, hand-washing is the best way forward!
The Wilton 101 Piece Colorful Cookie Cutter Set has everything you could need to keep your little ones entertained and yourself! If you are looking for something more specific, you might be interested in the Mickey Mouse Cookie Cutter Set
, great for a themed party!
Wilton 101-Piece Cookie Cutter Set
Wilton Cookie Cutter 2304-1050
Wilton Brands LLC is a corporation with many departments. They don’t put all their eggs in one basket, one might say! Although they’ve got many interests, this does not detract from the quality or time spent making all their products high-quality and functional for the everyday user. The Wilton Enterprises department focuses on an innovative selection of cookie making, cake decorating and baking products. They’re known worldwide as a leader in the baking products business.
With their 101 Piece Cookie Cutter Set, you’re sorted for all your cookie needs. Do you have a child who changes their mind frequently about what they want? Okay, yes, they all do! But this set is perfect for them. With shapes ranging from numbers, geometric shapes and letters to seasonal, everyday and animal shapes, there’s always a cutter to please your little one. The bright colors and the 1/3 inch comfort edge make these cutters ideal for children. And, the cherry on top, they can be used for other craft activities too; did I hear the word playdough, anyone?
These cutters are not just for kids though. With shapes for all kinds of holidays including Valentine’s Day, Halloween, Fourth of July, Christmas and Super Bowl Sunday, you can make the ideal cookies for any event. And once you’re done, just pop them in the dishwasher and you’re ready to try your sweet treats. Well, someone’s got to test them first, right?
The K&S Artisan Heavy Duty Cookie Cutters come in a set of 11 round cutters, each with the size stamped on for convenience. If you want a cookie cutter set for your children, you should definitely consider the K&S Artisan Sandwich Cutters for Kids
which comes with 10 bread cutters and 11 mini cookie cutters.
K&S Artisan Heavy Duty Round Biscuit Cutter Set – 11 Circle Pastry Cutters, Commercial Grade
K&S Artisan Cookie Cutter – 11-Piece Set
K&S Artisan was established in 2015 so it’s still a fairly new company. They strive for high-quality and low prices for all their products, but quality and functionality are a priority. K&S Artisan has a range of products in its line-up including a range of kitchen and baking products as well as some accessories like pens, keyrings and wallets.
The K&S Artisan Heavy Duty Cookie Cutters come in a set of 11 round cutters ideal for pastries, cookies, sandwiches and more. The cutters range from 1 to 3.5-inches and to avoid any confusion all the cutters are stamped with the size. Durability is key when it comes to cookie cutters which is why these are made from heavy duty, commercial grade stainless steel. The thin blades will cut through any sticky dough or even playdoh with ease.
Fully welded seams prevent any unwanted cuts and the cutters are all dishwasher-safe so you don’t even have to wash up after! With this set you’ll get a free biscuit and cake e-book so you can get going straight away with new and exciting ideas. What’s also special about these cutters is they’re oven safe up to 500˚F. Once you’ve finished baking, all the cutters fit inside each other neatly for storage. K&S Artisan don’t only make round cookie cutters though, they also have others in the shape of stars, flowers, hearts, butterflies and more.
The Hibery Mickey Mouse Cookie Cutters are fantastic for kids with their kid safe edge and cool Mickey design. If you’re going to get baking then you could probably do with a handy Hibery Stainless Steel Egg Separator
Hibery 2-Pack Stainless Steel Mickey Mouse Cookie Cutters for Kids
Hibery Cookie Cutter OFC-0036-1
Hibery is a company that’s committed strongly to providing excellent customer service. They believe that with great customer service comes happy customers and that’s all that matters! Their range of products includes some baby care, crafts and kitchen products.
We’ve decided to feature the Hibery Mickey Mouse Cookie Cutters because of their unusual design. It’s not everyday you get to tell your kids they can make cookies that actually look like Mickey Mouse. These 2 cookie cutters would also be perfect for a Mickey Mouse or Disney themed party. Hibery decided to go for a thicker stainless-steel material for durability, always good when it comes to kids, and there’s also a red safety strip around the top to prevent any accidents. The 4 x 4-inch cutters can be used for a variety of purposes including cookies and sandwiches.
Internet’s Best Set of 5 Heart Cookie Cutters – Kid Friendly
Internet’s Best Cookie Cutter – Heart, 5-Pack
Internet’s Best is a company committed to providing you with home goods and kitchenware that suit your lifestyle. They’ve got products in a range of categories including kitchenware, home goods, pet accessories and storage solutions, all at reasonable prices.
Today we’re featuring the Internet’s Best Heart Cookie Cutters. They’re made from plastic with wide edges so they’re very kid friendly. In this set you’ll receive 5 heart shaped cutters, all slightly different sizes so they fit neatly inside each other for storage. These versatile cutters can be used for sandwiches, fruit, cookie dough, cheese, playdoh and more. Kids will love these cutters for their bright, vibrant colors and parents will love them because they’re 100% dishwasher safe! Internet’s Best believes in providing consumers with a wide range of choices, which is why they don’t just make heart-shaped cookie cutters. They also have circles, flowers, stars, Christmas themed, alphabet letters, numbers and more!
Get the Best Cookie Cutter of 2019!
With all that to consider, you should have a fairly good idea of which cookie cutter set is right for you. Or maybe you’re even going to get a couple in preparation for the upcoming holiday or birthday! Whatever you decide, you can rest assured you’re getting a quality product from an established brand!
Our Top Choice
Ann Clark Christmas Cookie Cutter Set
Wilton 101 Cookie Cutter Set
K&S Artisan Heavy Duty Cookie Cutters
Hibery Mickey Mouse Cookie Cutters
Internet’s Best Heart Cookie Cutters