Best Cutting Mat Reviews 2023

Choosing a cutting mat is a decision that will affect the end-product of whatever craft project you’re undertaking, which is why it’s necessary for you to get the right one. This might be a task that you don’t have time for or that you don’t know how to carry out. That’s why we’re here: to help you narrow down your options. After extensive research, we have come up with a list of five top cutting mats from five top brands. These brands have more than the featured products, but we’ll feature only one product per brand here. As you go through the review, you might come across another product from the brands; please check them out as our sole concern is that you get a product that gives you the best value for your money.
TopProducts may earn commissions when you purchase through links on our site. Learn More.
For Use With
Our Top Choice
Quilting Bee Self Healing Cutting Mat
Quilting Bees was born out of a passion for quilting, and it makes products that are valuable tools that help quilting lovers get the best out of their quilting experience.
Dual-sided for a two-in-one mat. 3 millimeters thick. Designed to last long. More working surface than other mats of the same size.
Some customers found it to be a bit soft.
Rotary; X-acto; Razor
3 millimeters (0.1 inches)
Full 24 x 36 inches grid lines
More working surface
Best Value
Alvin Self-Healing Cutting Mat
Alvin & Co., is a producer of drawing tools and drafting supplies. It aims to provide for various markets and ensure customer satisfaction.
Complex vinyl material. Nonglare surface. Multifunctional as table pad or work mat. Easy to store.
There’s no difference between the one-inch and half-inch lines.
Rotary; Straight
3 millimeters (0.1 inches)
24 x 36 inches
Nonglare surface
OLFA Dual-Sided Rotary Cutting Mat
OLFA is a brand of World Kitchen, LLC, an organization that’s always growing through imaginative and inventive household and craft products and excellent customer service.
Dual-sided. One side for general craft work. The other has inch grid lines for accurate cutting. Angle markings for ease of use.
It has a strong chemical smell.
Double-Sided, Self-Healing
1.5 millimeters (.05 inches)
24 x 36 inches double sided grid
Smooth surface
Fiskars Self Healing Cutting Mat
Fiskars has become one of the leading world suppliers of merchandise that enable people to carry out tasks that they enjoy in easier and more fun ways.
Self-healing. Doesn’t easily show lines and marks from cutting. Measuring grids on both sides are easy to read.
It’s not as self-healing as other brands.
Self-Healing Rotary Cutting Mat
3 millimeters (0.1 inches)
24 x 36 inches both sides
Long-lasting cutting surface
Omnigrid Gridded 18 x 24 Cutting Mat
Omnigrid is a brand of Prym Consumer USA, a producer and distributor of all things quilting and sewing for over 400 years; its products are functional and affordable.
Self-healing base for continuous use without leaving cutting lines or marks. Long-lasting double cutting surface.
It has a strong smell that persists for a long time.
Self-Healing Base
Rotary; Straight
2 millimeters (.08 inches)
18 x 24 inches grid
Durable surface dual sided

Related Reviews
Best Tape Measure
Best Gaffer Tape
Best Circular Saw
Best Jigsaw
Watch Our Cutting Mat Review

What is the Best Cutting Mat?

We can’t rightly say that a particular product is the best cutting mat that’s available on the market. It all depends on your needs and preferences. The aim of this review is to help you know the important features that make a good cutting mat, and with this knowledge you can get the best cutting mat for you. So, let’s take a look at our featured products—we hope you find something you like!
Our Top Choice
The Quilting Bee Self Healing Cutting Mat is a high-quality, strong, and durable cutting mat which heals and restores itself. It can be used with any kind of craft blade. Are you looking for a kit for a beginner? Then check out the Quilting Bees Starter Kit.

Quilting Bee Self Healing Cutting Mat - Available in 4 Sizes

Quilting Bees was born out of love for the craft of quilting and everything about it. Its products are valuable tools that help quilting lovers get the best out of their quilting experience, and build strong and loving memories with friends and family.

The Quilting Bee Self Healing Cutting Mat is a high-quality, strong, and durable cutting mat which restores and heals itself. It's compliant with any kind of cutting blade, such as the x-acto knife, rotary cutter, or razor blade. It has other great features that include:
  • It’s dual-sided, which provides two mats in one, with a side that’s green with a yellow grid and another side that’s blue with a white grid. It serves well in both low and bright light situations and makes it more flexible.
  • It's 3 millimeters thick, which makes it bulkier than most other mats. It’s also built to last long.
  • It's self-healing, which means that it automatically repairs the cut surface so that you can continue to have a smooth surface to work on.
  • It has more working surface than other mats of the same size.
  • It has overall dimensions of 36 x 24 x 0.1 inches.
  • As a guarantee of its durability and top quality, it comes with a ten-year manufacturer's warranty.
Best Value
The Alvin Self-Healing Cutting Mat is a reversible self-repairing mat that’s designed for both straight and rotary blades, and withstands cuts with no marks to show for it. If you want a cutting mat with different features at a lower price, we recommend the Alvin Translucent Professional Self-Healing Cutting Mat.

Alvin Professional Self-Healing Cutting Mat - Available in 9 Sizes

Alvin & Company is renowned for producing and making available products for use in multiple art fields, and has been doing so since 1950. It still has its place as one of the most important sources of these and more products, and uses its broad and trusted network to deliver in the USA, Canada, and abroad. Further, it offers products made exclusively, further showcasing its passion and skill. Its goal is clear: to keep making happy customers and wonderful products.

The Alvin Self-Healing Cutting Mat is a reversible self-repairing mat that’s designed to be used with both straight and rotary blades, and can be used for continuous cutting without showing cutting lines or marks. It's a functional craft tool that has other great features, which include:
  • It's 3 millimeters thick and long-lasting.
  • A one-of-a-kind complex vinyl material provides a nonglare surface.
  • It's multifunctional and can be used as a pad for your workspace or work mat for any purpose.
  • A hanging hole makes for easy storage.
  • Has overall dimensions of 36 x 24 x 0.1 inches.
  • The grid lines help you locate exact center when working on any task.
  • It’s dual-sided; one side is green, and the other side is black. Both sides have grids.
The OLFA Rotary Cutting Mat is a self-repairing cutting mat that's designed to handle any size of craft project; it’s durable and extends the lifespan of the blades used. If you’d prefer a high-end cutting mat and don’t mind paying more, we recommend the OLFA 17" Rotating Self-Healing Rotary Mat.

OLFA Dual Sided & Self Healing Rotary Cutting Mat

World Kitchen, LLC, and partners produce and distribute through its many reputable brands worldwide, including our featured brand OLFA. It offers a wide range of classic household products that are simultaneously pushing boundaries for the greater good of its customers. As it does this in the USA, Asia, and other places around the world, it holds true to its goal and beliefs—to keep growing and making things better for its customers.

The OLFA Rotary Cutting Mat is a self-repairing cutting mat that's designed to handle various craft projects. It’s a durable mat that also helps to extend the lifespan of the rotary blades that you use. It has other great features that include:
  • It's 1.5 millimeters thick.
  • Has overall dimensions of 36 x 24 x .06 inches.
  • It has two sides. One side is green and is ideal for general craft work, and the other side has grid lines that mark inches for precision cutting. It also includes angle markings that make tricky tasks a lot easier.
  • It has self-healing properties that reseal cutting lines, and marks are enhanced by varying the positioning for cutting.
  • It’s easy to clean and remove particles with a specialized eraser.
  • It’s specially designed to be used with rotary blades.
The Fiskars Cutting Mat is an ultra-sized mat that gives you ample room to work, even for full-sized pieces of cloth and other big projects. If you want a smaller cutting mat with different features at a lower price, check out the Fiskars Self Healing Rotating Cutting Mat.

Fiskars Self Healing Rotary Cutting Mat- Available in 3 Sizes

Fiskars was established in 1649 and has always taken pride in making top-quality designs for enthusiastic people. It has a firm belief that “All things, even the simplest, can be made better and smarter”, so through rigorous study and research, it makes products that provide solutions to everyday dilemmas to make its customers’ lives that much sunnier. Fiskars has developed to become one of the leading world suppliers of products that help people carry out tasks that they enjoy in easier and more fun ways.

The Fiskars Cutting Mat is an extra-large mat that gives you ample room to work, even for big project involving full-sized pieces of cloth from the bolt. It’s also self-healing, which allows you to use it for long periods of time and for bigger projects without needing to worry about cutting lines or marks showing up. Further, it’s double-sided to give you versatility and even more work space—and each side features an easy-to-read measurement grid.

To make this product even better, the manufacturers even gave it bias lines to make cutting shapes and angles easier for you. And speaking of easy, not only is the a simple-to-use mat, but easy to clean as well; all you need to do is wash it with mild soap and warm water. With overall dimensions of 24 x 36 x 0.1 inches, this mat is definitely large enough for your cutting and crafting needs. Finally, keep in mind that if anything goes wrong with your mat, it’s even covered by a lifetime warranty!
The Omnigrid Cutting Mat is ideal for craft projects on a large scale as it can hold a forty-five-inch folded width of fabric; it can also be used in other craft projects. Do you want a bigger, high-end cutting mat? We recommend the Omnigrid 24-Inch-by-36-Inch Gridded Mat.

Omnigrid 18 Inch by 24 Inch Gridded Cutting Mat

Omnigrid is a brand name under Prym Consumer USA, a big-name producer and distributor of a variety of quilting and sewing materials in the United States. It has a history of more than four hundred years and proudly commits itself to making quality products that showcase its creative and forward-thinking nature.

The Omnigrid Cutting Mat is perfect for craft projects on a large scale because it can accommodate a regular-sized breadth of forty-five-inch fabric. It’s a suitable size for quilting, sewing and craft classes, and more. It has other great features which include:
  • One side that has a one-inch grid and 1/8-inch edge notching and angle line markings for precise measuring and cutting.
  • An opposite side that doesn’t have any grid or markings, which you can utilize as a work surface for any craft project.
  • Overall dimensions of 18 x 24 x .08 inches.
  • Specially designed for use with blades that are either straight-edged or rotary.
  • Long-lasting double cutting surface.
  • Self-healing base that repairs itself so you can use the mat continuously without leaving cutting lines or marks.

How Do I Choose the Best Cutting Mat?

Quilting, sewing, knitting, and other craft forms have been proven to be therapeutic for some people and are also an expression of artistry. Many people have benefitted from engaging in one form of art or the other, and from being actively involved with a hobby; it’s one way of relieving stress and discovering one’s self.

A cutting mat is essential for anyone whose craft involves cutting up fabrics, samples, shapes, or cutting of any sort. Whatever craft project you’re involved in, you need a cutting mat to protect your work surface, extend the longevity of your blades, and give you precision in your cutting.
A good cutting mat is something that anyone involved in a craft should have. As we all know, there are a variety of things that affect the price of any product; this includes the quality of the material it was made of, the track record of the brand, the functionality of the product, and sometimes the size and weight. With cutting mats, all of the afore-mentioned apply.

There are many good quality cutting mats in the market and you’ll be able to get one for anywhere between $27 to $64, bearing in mind the factors we’ve talked about. In the course of our research, we came across some cheap cutting mats, but decided not to feature them because we didn’t want you to waste your time on low-quality items. Rest assured, however, that whatever product/brand you choose based on this review will serve you well.
Cutting mats are not complex products but when shopping for one, there are some features to look out for. They include:
  • Type - There are hard-surface cutting mats and soft-surface (also known as self-healing). Both have their advantages; it all depends on what you want to use them for.
  • Size - Look out for the size that’s adequate for the project you have or the size of your work table.
  • Thickness – This determines its appropriateness to the task at hand.
  • Surface texture - Some are nonglare, while others are not; this also affects its performance.
  • Measurement and grid lines – Check to be sure that its measurements are easy to read and use.
  • Durability – You don’t want to be replacing your cutting mat all the time, so the durability is an important factor to note.
  • Ease of cleaning and storage – This is also vital, as it determines the longevity of the mat.
Construction and Design
Cutting mats come in different sizes, and each size is appropriate for a particular type of project. If you constantly use long lengths of fabric or bolts of fabric, it's advised that you buy the extra-large size, but if you’re always traveling with your mat, it's better to have a small-sized mat. You might also decide to buy an extra-large mat for your workstation, and a smaller one that you can use for small projects and can easily carry around.

When choosing a cutting mat, consider the other tools that you’ll be using with it. For example, there are cutting mats that are specially designed for only rotary blades; unless that’s what you want, ensure that your mat can be used with any kind of blade to avoid issues.

The thickness of a cutting mat is important, and should be chosen based on the kind of work you do. Self-healing mats are usually two or three millimeters thick. Two-millimeter mats have more of a plastic surface and consistency, and are usually too rough or too smooth; they’re referred to as hobby-grade mats, so if you’re a professional and do a lot of cutting you need to look for a three-millimeter-thick mat that can withstand constant use.
Performance and Ease of Use
When buying a cutting mat, look at the cleaning and storage instructions to ensure that you’ll be able to clean and maintain it. For almost all cutting mats, you can clean them with mild soap and warm water, and use art eraser gum to remove fabric or lint that might get stuck on it.

Further, you’re advised to always store them flat and away from extreme weather or temperatures to allow it to retain its shape. Keep this in mind while determining the size you should buy, as storing a large mat flat may be difficult. That’s why it may be advisable to buy one that you can keep as a permanent fixture on your workstation.

The texture and glare of the mat are vital features; if the texture is too smooth, the things you want to cut may have a tendency of slipping, and if it's too coarse, it will affect the consistency of your cut. Some mats are glossy and reflect light, which also affects its effectiveness. An ideal mat should have a medium texture/consistency and be made of a non-glare surface. In short, get one that’s not too smooth or too coarse.

Look for a mat that’s divided up and completely numbered on all sides of the mat. Hash lines ought to go past the board of the mat on all four sides; this helps with proper alignment.

Get the Best Cutting Mat of 2023!

We appreciate the time you’ve taken to read this review, and we’re optimistic that you are well informed on what to look out for when shopping for a cutting mat. So go on and make that choice of the right cutting mat for you.

Our Top Choice
Quilting Bee Self Healing Cutting Mat
Best Value
Alvin Self-Healing Cutting Mat
OLFA Dual-Sided Rotary Cutting Mat
Fiskars Self Healing Cutting Mat
Omnigrid Gridded 18 x 24 Cutting Mat