Best Diaper Genie Reviews 2023

Diaper Genies (or Diaper Pails) are a great way to keep your child’s nursery clean and tidy when changing time eventually rolls around. Their odor-locking technology removes any nasty smells, and their easy-to-clean design makes cleaning up a breeze! However, there are many styles available on the market, and choosing the right diaper genie for you and your little one can get a little bit confusing. But, don’t fret; we’ve got your back! We have selected the best diaper genie brands and a product to feature from each to give you a better feel for what these brands have to offer.
TopProducts may earn commissions when you purchase through links on our site. Learn More.
Our Top Choice
Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail
Ubbi create products that make the lives of parents the world over that little easier, evident in their Steel Diaper Pail.
Available in 16 colors. Made from powder coated steel. Rubber Seals. Can use any trash bag.
Product is known to start to smell after use.
Steel and Rubber
Up to 50 Diapers
7 Pounds
Childproof Security Lock
Best Value
Dekor Diaper Pail Plus
Dekor specialize in creating products that go the distance and can be enjoyed for years to come, evident in their Diaper Pail Plus
Available in 6 colors. Can be used as a trash can or diaper pail. Odor control technology.
Not as aesthetically pleasing as other diaper pails on the market.
Up to 60 Diapers
9 Pounds
100% Hands Free
Munchkin Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail
Munchkin are renowned in the baby-ware industry due to their durable designs that work like a charm, evident in their Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail.
Available in 3 sizes. One hand technology. Comes with 10 refill bags. Self-sealing system.
Smaller in comparison to other products.
Up to 25 Diapers
8.1 Pounds
Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe
Baby Trend make products that are designed specifically with your little one in mind, evident in their Diaper Champ Deluxe.
Odor control. Large capacity. Requires no assembly.
Some bags won’t fit in this product.
Up to 30 Diapers
7 Pounds
No Assembly Required
Playtex Diaper Genie Pail
Playtex create top quality baby products that are simple and easy to use, evident in their Diaper Genie Pail.
Customizable. Odor control. Large capacity. Stylish design.
Does not work with all trash bags.
Up to 50 Diapers
4.9 Pounds
Maximum Odor Control

Related Reviews
Best Baby Changing Table
Best Baby Bathtub
Best Baby Oil
Best Baby Formula

What is the Best Diaper Genie?

As you can see, diaper genies come in different capacities, construction materials, and sizes. It’s now time to look at our top five picks from these reputable brands. Remember, if the models we’ve reviewed are not the right fit for you, these brands have multiple options.
Our Top Choice
We are BIG fans of Ubbi’s Diaper Pail due to its strong, durable design and the fact its available in over 16 different colors! If you are after refill bags for this pail then make sure you check out Ubbi’s Pack of 3 Plastic bags too!

Ubbi Steel Diaper Genie – Available in 16 Colors

Ubbi create innovative products that are designed specifically with both parents and children in mind. Their easy to use, simple products are of the highest quality and unique to Ubbi, keeping your little one safe and secure. Their award winning products will certainly make Ubbi your one stop shop for all your baby’s needs. We wanted to feature Ubbi’s Steel Diaper Pail due to the brands overall popularity and the fact its available in an impressive 16 different colors too! Made from powder coated steel, this diaper pail has rubber seals in order to prevent any nasty odors. There is no special bag required for this product either, the pails improved design holds any bag securely to avoid breakages and any mess too!
Best Value
Dekor’s Diaper Pail Plus is an indeal product for anyone after a pail that won’t leave any nasty smells behind! If, however, this product isn’t for you then make sure you take a look at Dekor’s Classic Hands Free Diaper Pail instead!

Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail – Available in 6 Colors

Dekor, created in 2000, is one of the largest distributors of pails and refills across the United States and Canada. They are one of the leading retailers in the baby product market and are widely available in stores such as Bed Bath & Beyond as well as Babies “R” Us too! We are big fans of Dekor’s Diaper Pail Plus due to its hands-free design and the fact it comes in 6 snazzy colors too! This diaper pail is one of the most cost effective diaper pails on the market today, with triple odor control technology to keep those nasty smells inside the pail too! The closed-cell ABS plastic in this product works in the same way as metal, meaning it won’t absorb odors either. This pail is also perfect for cloth diapers and can convert from a diaper pail to a trash can in one easy step!
If you are after a simple to use diaper pail with no fuss or mess then Munchkin’s Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail is the one for you! If, however, you are after a hands free diaper pail then make sure you check out Munchkin’s Step Diaper Pail instead!

Munchkin Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail with Refill Bags – 3 Bag Refill Sizes Available

Munchkin create modern, innovative and effective baby products that make the lives of parents around the world that little bit easier. Founded in 1991, Munchkin now has 7 offices worldwide and are incredibly passionate about what they do. We decided to feature Munchkin’s Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail due to its heavy duty design and the fact the brand itself is so popular. This product is powered by odor eliminating baking soda that prevents and nasty smells from lingering around your home. The pails patented self-sealing system also seals the bag as it closes meaning you don’t even have to touch the bag when cleaning and allows for one handed use too! Munchkin’s diaper pail also comes with a handy 10 bag refill and is already assembled too!
Baby Trend’s Diaper Champ Deluxe allows you to keep your diaper station clean and tidy without any nasty smells! If you are a fan of this product then make sure you check out the pink version too!

Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe in Grey/White

For over 26 years, Baby Trend has been distinguishing itself as one of the leading manufacturers of juvenile products in the world. Their innovative products and designs are what have made them so popular amongst parents from all walks of life, with a goal to provide the safest and most reliable products on the market today. We decided to feature Baby Trend’s Diaper Champ Deluxe due to its large capacity and its very reasonable price too! The superior odor control in this product prevents any nasty smells lingering around your home and can hold up to 30 diapers at a time! This product is simple to use and requires no assembly either, what’s not to love!
We are BIG fans of Playtex’s Diaper Genie Pail due to its customizable design and the fact it has exceptional odor control too! If, however, you are after a pail that includes refills then check out Playtex’s Essential Diaper Genie with Starter Refill instead!

Playtex Diaper Genie Expressions Customizable Pail with Starter Refill

Playtex is one of the leading manufacturers of baby products worldwide with a strong focus on making the lives of parents that little bit simpler. Playtex sell a large variety of juvenile products such as feeding bottles, pacifiers, flatware and dinnerware as well as diaper genies too! If you are after a brand that is both durable and reliable then Playtex is the brand for you! We decided to feature Playtex’s Diaper Genie due to the overall popularity of the brand as well as the fact it’s customizable too! This product comes with designer fabric sleeves that allow you to add your own touch of personal style to the genie or keep it white for a classic, sleek look. This product also has exceptional odor control to prevent any lingering smells and can hold up to a maximum of 50 diapers.

How Do I Choose the Best Diaper Genie?

Let’s face it, nothing smells worse than soiled diapers. They really stink, particularly if left around for a night. It is the reason why people want to play with your lovely munchkin but will always hand him/her back to you once the diaper is soiled. It even gets worse when the child starts to take solid food; their soiled diapers tend to smell extra heinous. Throwing dirty diapers into the trash can might work for you at first, but, as the baby grows, you’ll find out that the smell cannot be contained. This can be nasty, and there has to be a way to deal with it. One way to deal with it may be to use non-disposable diapers, but that means you have to wash them daily. That’s where a diaper genie comes in. Diaper genies are designed to help you dispose of the used diapers and eliminate bad odors in your home. Diaper genies are available in different designs and styles and no matter what your baby’s changing station looks like, you’ll find one that blends in easily. While you throw the used diapers in a bathroom trash can or a regular trash can, they are not effective as they cannot lock the awful odor in quite like a diaper genie does.
728x90 Super Soft
FREE Diaper Bag for your baby, when you subscribe! Limited time offer.
While price should not get in your way while trying to make your home odorless, we understand you must operate on a budget. A high-quality diaper genie is priced between $20 and $70. The price is determined by the features of a diaper genie. For example, diaper genies that are made of steel and rubber are more expensive than the plastic models. Similarly, you’ll pay more for a diaper genie with a higher capacity than one that can only hold a small number of diapers. During our research, we identified some cheap diaper genies, but we did not feature them in our guide as they may not perform their functions well. They will still release the nasty odor even when tightly closed.
Capacity is an important feature to consider when purchasing a diaper genie. Consider the number of diapers that your munchkin uses in a certain period just to be confident that the genie you’re buying will meet your demand. You don’t want to empty your genie daily. One that can hold more than 20 diapers will be ok for you. However, if the odor starts to leak, you’ll have to empty your genie. Here are some other factors to consider:
  • Construction material (plastic or steel)
  • What is its weight?
  • Does it have a foot pedal?
  • Is it available in multiple colors?
  • What is its odor control mechanism and trapping?
  • Does it come with a childproof or a locking lid?
Let’s now explore these features in detail.
Construction and Design
There’s a reason why people consider the construction material. Plastic models retain odor over time with minimal deodorizing and management. On the other hand, metal models require diligent management and deodorizing to maintain odor. Plastic genies are light, making them ideal for portability and cheap as well. Metal models are expensive but durable. Go for the one that suits your preferences and style. The importance of a foot pedal cannot be overlooked. It makes it easier to use the genie. You can easily toss the dirty diaper into the genie while still concentrating on your baby. All you need to do is push the foot pedal to open the lid and toss the dirty diaper in. Check whether the diaper genie is available in different colors. You would want a genie that can easily blend with your baby’s nursery. Choose your favorite color as chances are high it will blend with other baby items.
Performance and Ease of Use
The ability to control the odor is the main reason why people invest in diaper genies. Before purchasing the diaper genie, it is important to check the maximum period it can contain the odor. Go for a diaper genie that will support your preferred frequency of disposal. Check also the odor control mechanism. Does it use baking soda, discs, seals or carbon filters? You don’t want a genie that has no odor control provision. Check out if the genie has a locking lid or childproof capability. You don’t want your little angel to be playing with dirty diapers.

Get the Best Diaper Genie of 2023!

Enlightened? Grab your favorite diaper genie and make that nursery environment fresh for you and your little munchkin. If you aren’t a fan of the particular product we have chosen, don’t panic! All of our chosen brands have a HUGE range of products available so simply browse through their other collections to find the ideal one for you!

Our Top Choice
Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail
Best Value
Dekor Diaper Pail Plus
Munchkin Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail
Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe
Playtex Diaper Genie Pail