Best Fireplace Grate Reviews 2023

So many people are shocked at the sheer number and different types of fireplace grates (that are made from different materials) that they usually find it daunting to choose one. So, to make your choice easier, we have searched far and wide and picked 5 of the most efficient fireplace grate brands. What you have here, in this review, are indeed the best fireplace grates on the market. These grates are available in a variety of styles and we have featured one fireplace grate from each brand. You will also do well to check out other fireplace grates from these brands since they have a number of other ones.
TopProducts may earn commissions when you purchase through links on our site. Learn More.
Bar Width
Our Top Choice
Liberty Cast Iron Fireplace Grate
For many years, Liberty has been producing high quality fireplace grates with a range of materials and in different styles. Its grates are also very affordable.
It is very durable and easy to maintain. Its long legs allow for better ventilation and more room for ashes to accumulate between cleaning.
It is not very deep; only 12 inches.
Available in 19.5, 24, 27 inches
Cast iron
Info NOT provided
29 lbs
Best Value
Pleasant Hearth ¾” Steel Fireplace Grate
Pleasant Hearth specializes in making fireplace grates with the best and most durable materials for optimal effect.
It does not overheat or melt due to the materials used in its construction. It is sturdy and durable.
It is difficult to figure out the appropriate size you want.
Available in 7 sizes
¾ inch
22.5 lbs
Grate Wall of Fire Vertical Fireplace Grate
Grate Wall of Fire, founded many years ago, manufactures and retails some of the most innovative and efficient fire grates in the market.
It is very durable, easy to use, solves 99% of smoke problems and is backed by a 30-day guarantee. It protects the back of your fireplace and is available in different sizes.
It could be considered expensive to some.
Available in many sizes
¾ inch
30 lbs
Landmann Wide Bar Fireplace Grate
Landmann is all about providing quality, durable and efficient products at affordable prices. Its grates are used in many homes across America.
It is very sturdy, has a durable painted coating and is also affordable.
It bends at very high temperatures.
Available in 23 and 30 inches
½ inch
7.3 lbs
Panacea Cast Iron Fire Grate
Panacea has built a reputation for making top quality products over the years. It is a bestselling fireplace grate maker.
It is sturdy, has a solid design and is quite affordable.
It is not very durable.
Available in 24 inches
Cast iron
Info NOT provided
17.2 lbs

Related Reviews
Best Fireplace Insert
Best Fireplace Tong
Best Electric Fireplace
Best Rocking Chair

What is the Best Fireplace Grate?

Now that you have taken time to read our buying guide of fireplace grates, we hope that you have sufficient information to enable you choose the right grate for your fireplace. We have, therefore, taken time to highlight the features of grates from 5 top brands with the hope that one of them will be the grate for you so, go ahead and take a look at them.
Our Top Choice
The Liberty Cast Iron Fireplace Grate is a product made specifically to increase the efficiency of your fire place. It also prevents your flooring from getting damaged. If you want something with as much durability but with removable legs, you should take a look at the Liberty Sampson Series Cast Iron Fireplace Grate.

Liberty Cast Iron Fireplace Grate with 4 Inch Legs – Available in 3 Sizes

Liberty has been in the market of manufacturing fireplace products for many years, and it has a reputation for combining quality and creativity. Its goal is to provide its products at affordable prices without compromising quality. Its success is attributed to its outstanding repeat customer base and referral network. If you choose to do business with Liberty, you can be assured that it will strive to earn your complete satisfaction.

The Liberty Cast Iron Fireplace Grate is a fireplace grate that is designed to contain firewood safely, thereby preventing the mess made by firewood that falls on the floor. It has a 4-inch cast-on leg and is a one-piece cast iron flat-bottom-styled grate which accounts for its durability.
Best Value
If you’re looking for a fireplace grate that is easy to use and maintain, we recommend the Pleasant Hearth ¾ Steel Fireplace Grate. It is made to ensure optimum efficiency of the fireplace. Want something else? You should check out the Pleasant Hearth Solid Steel Fireplace Grate which is very heavy duty; its bars are made of ½ inch solid steel.

Pleasant Hearth ¾” Premium Solid Steel Fireplace Grate – Available in 7 Sizes

With a line of state-of-the-art products, ranging from electric fireplaces to outdoor fireplaces to fireplace grates, Pleasant Hearth offers products which its customers consider to be of unique style and unparalleled quality. Its products can be found at most major home centers, hardware stores and internet retailers across North America.

The Pleasant Hearth ¾ Steel Fireplace Grate is a highly efficient fireplace grate which lifts firewood off the chimney floor and allows air to circulate, thereby making work much easier for the fireplace and the fireplace owner. It also has a heat resistant black finish and its bars are made of ¾ inch premium steel, which makes it very durable and sturdy. It is designed to contain firewood safely and has an adequate surface area for optimum utilization of the fireplace.
Is your fireplace filling your home with smoke? If yes, you should invest in the Model M-5 High Efficiency Smoke Free Fireplace Grate, which is specially known for its ability to solve smoke problems. If you are looking for something stronger and can withstand the harsh environment of a wood burner, you should try the Model TG-36 heavy duty fireplace which is built from 1¼ solid steel bar.

Grate Wall of Fire High Efficiency Smoke-Free Fireplace Grate 21" x 15"

Grate Wall of Fire has built a reputation of making top quality fireplace products over the course of the years. It is known for high quality products with innovative designs that always produce a positive result. Its specially built grates will change your perception of burning wood in a fireplace. They reduce wood consumption dramatically and lower the risk of pesky "spark popping fires". Furthermore, you can say bye-bye to a burning log rolling out of the fireplace. To crown it all, when the logs are burned completely, they leave a nice, neat pile of ashes. The Model M-5 High Efficiency Smoke Free Fireplace Grate, which is one of the best in its collection, has all these benefits and more.

The Model M-5 High Efficiency Smoke Free Fireplace Grate is, as the name implies, a highly efficient grate that allows a magnificent wall of warmth, producing fireplace embers which develop at the base of the grate, while firewood burns slow and controlled from above. It has a wide range of sizes so it can be used in almost any fireplace.

It is usually placed at the extreme rear of the fireplace, thereby preventing smoke from spilling into the home. When burning in the M-5, the wood burns completely without fire moving in a gravitational, nearly automated fashion, resulting in a steady, heat-efficient fire.
The Landmann USA Wide Bar Fireplace Grate is a product that is very easy to use and is highly efficient. Its wide bar characteristic means more surface area to hold wood securely. You could also take a look at the Landmann Steel Fireplace Grate with Ember Retainer. which is available in 4 sizes and has an ember retainer.

Landmann USA Made Wide Bar Fireplace Grate – Available in 2 Sizes

LANDMANN was founded in 1966 in Osterholz-Scharmbeck, and it produces numerous high quality products for the fireplace. Its mission is to always produce high quality and user-friendly products.

The Landmann USA Wide Bar Fireplace Grate is a fireplace grate that has V grates, designed to hold fire starters and kindling close to firewood for easy lighting of fires. It is also made from solid half-inch square steel bar, which makes it sturdy. Its wide bar has more surface to hold wood firmly and increases the overall efficiency of the fireplace.
If you want to make your fireplace more efficient, the Panacea 15424 Cast Iron Fire Grate could be the grate for you. It is very easy to use. If you need a smaller fireplace grate, check out the Panacea Products Corps Black Wrought Iron Fireplace Grate which is 18 inches in dimension.

Panacea Cast Iron Fire Grate, Black, 24-Inch

Frank Paniccia started Panacea Products in 1967, and 40 years later this family-owned company has grown as a manufacturer of high quality metal products. It has its headquarters in Ohio with distribution and production facilities located throughout North America and the Far East. This brand is a best seller in fireplace grates.

The Panacea 15424 Cat Iron Fire Grate is an efficient grate that is made of cast iron, which makes it very sturdy. Smaller pieces of burned wood fall to the fireplace floor through openings in the grate, thereby creating a bed of hot coals and allowing your fire to burn from the bottom up. It also raises the fire off the floor of your fireplace which not only creates a hotter fire, but helps draft the smoke and fumes out the chimney instead of into your home

How Do I Choose the Best Fireplace Grate?

If you’ve never used your home’s fireplace, you’re missing out on a lot of toasty, comforting nights. Maybe you’ve wished for a traditional and real fireplace, rather than an electric one, only to discover that although your new home does have a fireplace, it’s too small or low and almost unusable. It might also be that that the heat is slowly damaging the floor of the fireplace, and you’re torn between saving the floor and indulging in the toasty fires on cold winter evenings. Whatever be the case, we’re here to ensure you get your roaring fire, save your precious floor and get as warm as you deserve.

Fireplace grates go a long way in creating a safe and efficient wood and charcoal burning in the house. Instead of burning fuel directly on the floor of the fireplace, you can place the wood or charcoal or any kindling of your choice on the grate.

The grate has several advantages over direct floor fuel burning. Apart from saving your fireplace floor from direct heat, it also makes for a better and bigger fire. The raised design makes it possible for oxygen to properly circulate from all angles and below, ensuring complete combustion of the wood or charcoal. This makes the fire burn brighter and bigger, providing more warmth and more importantly, less smoke.

It also makes for a beautiful complement to your firewood rack, adding to the ambience of the room.

Some fireplace grate types are designed to blow hot air into different rooms simultaneously and are controlled by an in-built thermostat.

A fireplace grate makes all that possible and more. If you burn wood or charcoal directly in the fireplace, you’ll wonder how you’ve managed without a grate once you’ve used one. And if you’re new to using real fireplaces, a grate is the best way to get started.

Outlining the uses or importance of a fireplace grate is just one half of the equation; getting to know what to look for when making your choice of a grate is the other half. The most important features to look out are the material, bar width, type or design of the grate, size and the price. Stay with us as we detail these features in subsequent sections.
Most brands design their fireplace grate to be highly efficient and heavy-duty. It’s also meant to be a long term investment if chosen wisely. The most important thing to look for is the thickness of the metal bar to suit your needs. If using your fireplace often, you’d do well to invest in a medium to heavy-duty grate. A ½ inch bar will cost less than a 5/8 or 1-inch bar but the latter will fare better through regular or prolonged use.

You can get a good fireplace grate for as low as $20.00, but if you’re looking for durable, heavy-duty grates, expect to spend anything from $70.00 to $150.00 or more. Our featured brands have products spanning different price ranges so you can find one that suits your needs and is budget-friendly. We came across some cheap fireplace grates with flimsy looking materials and welding, but we didn’t include them in our reviews.
Choosing the right fireplace grater is extremely important, especially if you will be using your fireplace often. You don’t want to end up with a grate that is unusable simply because you didn’t do proper research before purchasing. Here are some features to help you make the right decision:
  • Size of the fireplace
  • Grate construction material
  • Type and design
  • Bar width
Construction and Design
Before you begin shopping for your fireplace grate, consider the size of your fireplace. There’s no one-size-fits-all since different houses are built with different sizes and shapes of fireplaces. A small fireplace is limited to the size of grate it can contain while a large fireplace can take a small, medium or large grate. It all depends on how large a fire you’ll want to make.

Also, make sure the fireplace grate will fit into the fireplace with enough room to spare. This makes for better air circulation so kindling can burn better and brighter and reduce the amount of smoke produced.

The construction material of a fireplace grate can be steel or cast iron. Steel fireplace grates are best suited for wood burning while cast iron grate is great for coal burning. The assignation of purpose is based on the design of the different grates.

The size of a steel grate is determined by the bar width and number of the bars on the grate. Note that the thicker the bar width, the better and more durable the grate is. Heavy-duty steel grate have steel bar widths of 5/8 to 1 inch or even more.
Most grates have a V-shape or U-shape design that securely holds the log of wood or coal safely so you don’t have to worry about it falling off.
Performance and Ease of Use
The fireplace grate is designed for comfort and safety of the home and its inhabitants. It’s easy to set up and use. And depending on the type, most of the cast iron grates are constructed from one-piece heavy duty cast iron material that requires no set up.

The steel grate usually comes in an easy-to-setup kit with pieces well aligned and precisely cut for easy assembly. They also come with well detailed instruction manual and the required hardware to ensure a stress-free assembly and installation.

In terms of design, a steel fireplace grate is designed mainly for wood burning with widely separated bars that can hold lots of wood and allow the easy passage of embers and coals down to the fireplace floor. The wide space design is so that oxygen can circulate since a log of firewood will require plenty of oxygen to get it crackling. Cast iron fireplace grates are designed for coal burning with smaller spaces.

Another type of fireplace grate is the one designed to heat up a hollow metal which then uses an in-built fan to blow the hot air out from the metal, heating multiple rooms up at the same time. This type of fireplace is expensive but the cost evens out in the long run.

Whichever type you choose, consider how often you’ll be using the grate. If the grate is to be used on rare or special occasions only, then you can go for a lightweight steel or cast iron (depending on fuel source) grate. There are medium grates that are good for frequent use.

On the other hand, if you’re a daily wood or coal burner, then you’ll need the thickest, heaviest and most optimally welded grate within your budget.

Choose your fireplace grate wisely according to how often you’ll be using it and the type of fuel burned.

To make things easier, some brands design their cast iron fireplace grate to be used with both wood and coal. Also, make sure the grate has good clearance from below, so oxygen can circulate freely from underneath and allow hot coals to fall from the grate.

Get the Best Fireplace Grate of 2023!

By now we hope you’ve found the fireplace grate that resonates with you, go ahead and place the order and enjoy the benefits it will bring to your fireplace.

Our Top Choice
Liberty Cast Iron Fireplace Grate
Best Value
Pleasant Hearth ¾” Steel Fireplace Grate
Grate Wall of Fire Vertical Fireplace Grate
Landmann Wide Bar Fireplace Grate
Panacea Cast Iron Fire Grate