Best Gel Eyeliner Reviews 2018

Gel eyeliner is a great option if you’re looking to add definition to your eyes and make them pop! We love gel eyeliner because it’s very forgiving, easy to apply, and you can get a high-quality product without spending a fortune. Picking the right one is not that easy though, but you can always make this an easy feat if you know where to look. We are here to help. Read on to learn about our five favorite gel eyeliners from some of the best gel eyeliner brands on the market.
Overview
PROS
CONS
Our Top Choice
L’Oreal Paris Infallible Gel Lacquer Liner
L'Oreal Paris is a popular American drugstore makeup brand that originated in France. They produce a variety of beauty products, such as the L’Oreal Paris Infallible Gel Lacquer Liner.
Pigment-rich finish. Glossy. Safe for contact lenses. 5 shades. 24-hour color. Paraben-free.
Allergic reactions, though rare, can occur.
Best Value
Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel Liner
Maybelline, a division of L’Oreal, was founded in 1915. They’ve launched several industry-changing products, such as the Lasting Drama Gel Liner, and are renowned for their innovative beauty line.
Long-lasting. Easy to apply. 4 shades. Matte black. Smear-proof. Waterproof. Oil-free. Safe for contacts.
Fades with wear. Some dislike thick formula.
Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Eyeliner
Bobbi Brown is a luxury makeup brand founded by professional makeup artist Bobbi Brown. Brown believes makeup, such as this Long Wear Gel Eyeliner, should be used to enhance a person’s natural beauty.
Matte or metallic finishes. 14 shades. Waterproof. Creamy texture. Designed for all-day wear. Dries fast.
Brush is not included. Higher priced than competitors.
TonyMoly Backstage Gel Eyeliner
TonyMoly is an affordable Korean makeup line with a few locations in North America. They offer a line of cute and unique makeup and skincare products, such as the Backstage Gel Eyeliner.
Tons of product. Attractive design. Built-in brush. Water-resistant. 6 shades. Great for thin, sharp lines.
Dries out quickly if left open. Some shades are less pigmented than others.
e.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Eyeliner
e.l.f. Cosmetics, also known as Eyes Lips Face, is a budget makeup line that targets $1, $3 and $6 price points. They have a lot of great products, including this e.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Eyeliner.
Affordable. Water-resistant. Creamy formula. Brush included. Long lasting. 4 shades, including gold.
Low-quality brush. Hard to achieve sharp lines.

(Updated )
Related Reviews
Best Liquid Eyeliner
Best Makeup Magnification Mirror
Best Powder Foundation
Best Eyeshadow Palette

How Do I Choose the Best Gel Eyeliner?

If you are a makeup fanatic, it is probable you already have liquid liners, eye pencils, kajal, pen liners, and all that, but you always feel like something is still missing. Well, gel eyeliner is all you need to complete your arsenal. Everyone needs something to make them feel pretty. Gel eyeliner will help you command attention at the office and provoke a little envy from friends too. However, this comes with considering several factors.

One of the aspects you should make sure to get right is the shade. Gel eyeliners come in an extensive range of shades. So you need to get the one that naturally blends with your complexion. A little touch to your waterline usually goes a long way. It’s best to choose one that does not have shine or shimmer, as this type can be easily wearable for different types of complexions.

When it comes to the pigmentation and texture, you cannot afford to be careless. A buttery smooth gel, for instance, will offer the touch you need to feel comfortable all day long. You will most likely forget you have your eyeliner on. It’s easy to apply, and it will provide you with a natural look all day long. Such eyeliners go evenly on the lid for a simple application with your makeup brush.

The pigmentation comes in quite handy when it comes to getting the desired results. All you will need with the right pigmentation is a single thick stroke, and you are ready to go. After all, you have your eyeshadow and other things to do.

In most cases, you will have limited time to have your makeup in place before heading to work. So you need an eyeliner that can set pretty quick to make the most of the few minutes you have to get this done. Even though you are limited on application time, you still want to make sure your makeup will stay in place throughout the day. Make sure you get an option that will stay on until you are ready to take it off with your makeup remover.

It is time to step up and check out our top five gel eyeliner options.
Price
Gel eyeliners come with impressive features, but the price most of these makeup options come with will blow you away. Be ready to spend any amount within the price range between $3 and $20 to get an ideal gel for your everyday needs. But if you want a higher quality, you can always spend a little more to get a more top quality product.

Also, keep in mind that gel eyeliner prices significantly depend on the features of the product. A waterproof and smudge proof eyeliner that also comes with a brush will cost you a little more than most other types. The other influential factor affecting gel eyeliner prices is the manufacturing brand. Most customers would go for the brand everyone is going for on the market, and this means spending a little more for the higher quality.

However, what you need to be keen on is some cheap gel eyeliner offers on the market. Most of these products come at low-cost that could be pocket-friendly but lack the essential features for reliable eyeliner. Quite often, these kinds of eyeliners don’t come with the features that you would find in their higher-priced counterparts.
Features
Getting the right gel eyeliner can prove to be tricky sometimes. But this does not have to be a big problem if you find the one with the best features. Perhaps the best thing is the fact that most gel eyeliners on the market have several impressive features.

Some of the features that you need to check out include the following:
  • Size – Different gel eyeliner comes in different package sizes depending on the brand. You can always research before purchasing to be sure of what you are getting into, but there is a brighter side. Most of these gels come in enough amount to last you for long enough for the return of your money.
  • Shades – The shades in different gel eyeliner types can also differ significantly. Some come in four shades, others have as many as 14 shades, and everything in between. The best thing to do is identify the number of colors in any gel that you are going for to be sure it will offer you the variety you need.
  • Brush Type – To use your eyeliner with ease, you need to have a brush for the job. Most of these gel eyeliners are made with this necessity in mind, and several of them come with a brush that you can use to apply it quickly and efficiently. The brush could be a fine-point or a slanted one depending on the particular option.
  • Contact Lens Safe – Several people need to use contact lenses, but this does not mean they cannot use gel eyeliners without problems. As such, most of these eyeliners are ophthalmologist tested and designed as safe for use with lenses, so you need not worry; this type of makeup has something for everyone.
  • Water-resistant – You will most likely come into contact with splashing water as you go about your daily business. This can prove devastating for your look if the type of makeup you have is not tailored for such conditions. You are lucky since most gel eyeliners are waterproof. You don’t have to worry about changing weather or water splashing onto your face during the day. Besides, most gel eyeliners are smudge proof too, which helps ensure nothing compromises your cute look.
Construction and Design
Gel eyeliners are made differently depending on the manufacturer, but you will always notice some similarities on most of them, mostly on the crucial features. When it comes to looking at the design of any gel eyeliner, here are few things you will find interesting.

Waterproof

Avoiding contact with water can be almost impossible to some people, but this does not mean you should shun using your eyeliner altogether. Besides coming with an attractive design, most gel eyeliners in the market are built such that it can be washed away by water. This means the makeup stays put until the moment you want to take it off, in which case you can use your remover to clean it off. What’s more, some of these eyeliners are smudge proof to guarantee convenient use.

Different shades

Everyone has a particular favorite color, and when it comes to using gel eyeliners, the situation is no different. But things cannot get better than when you have a variety of options. These eyeliners are tailored to offer just that since most of them come in a wide array of shades. Some of the options on the market have as many as 14 shades for you to choose from, giving you every opportunity to select the one that brings out the best in your complexion.

Contact Lens Safe

Using contact lenses with most types of makeup can turn out to be a problem. This is why most of these eyeliner types are designed with contact lenses in mind. Find the right eyeliner out there, and you will not have to worry about having your lens on when you have applied your eyeliner.

Brush Type

In most cases, gel eyeliners come with brushes for easy application of your makeup. The best part is that, depending on the brush you find easy to use, there will always be something for you. These brushes vary from the fine-point options to the slanted ones so that you can select the eyeliner with your preferred brush. The included brush means you don’t have to undergo any extra costs down the road in buying a brush separately to use with your eyeliner.
Performance and Ease of Use
When it comes to shopping for gel eyeliner, getting one that cannot perform to your expectations will be just a waste of your time. There are several factors you need to check out in order to avoid any possible disappointment.

Durability

Any eyeliner should be tricky to wipe off unless you want to clear it from your face. This is one of the exciting things about gel eyeliners. Since most of these eyeliners are smudge proof and water resistant, the makeup offers reliability in all types of weather or conditions. If your face is exposed to water, your gel eyeliner will be able to withstand such conditions. This is all you need to be sure using your eyeliner will not end up becoming a source of frustration or embarrassment.

Ease of Use

The other impressive thing about gel eyeliners is the fact that most of the makeup type comes with an inbuilt brush for easy application. Besides, applying your brush cannot take up much of your time, since all you need is a single stroke to get the job done. More importantly, when you want to remove it, you will only need to have your remover handy, and you can rub it off quickly.

Sets in Fast

Another interesting thing you cannot afford to miss about any gel eyeliner is the fact that it sets in pretty quick. Not forgetting, the eyeliner holds on well without budging from the lids during the day. You can always count on your gel eyeliner to get the most natural application of your makeup without necessarily compromising its efficiency.

Versatility

One of the best things you can count on this type of eyeliner for is that different people can make use of it efficiently. Since most of the gel eyeliners on the market come with several different shades, people with different complexions can make the most out of these gels. Besides, if you want to use different types of shades, you can always use different colors that match other types of makeup you are using. With gel eyeliner, the opportunities are almost endless.

What is the Best Gel Eyeliner?

Gel eyeliner is a very personal decision, so what is best for one person won’t be the same for another. When shopping for gel eyeliner, you’ll probably want to consider the price of the item, the colors it’s available in, and whether or not it includes a brush. In some cases, you’ll have to purchase a brush separately. Some of the products included in this review come with a brush, but you’ll still need to consider whether or not it’s the right style for you. Now that you are well informed, let’s take a look at our review.
Our Top Choice
L’Oreal Paris Infallible Gel Lacquer Liner comes in five rich shades that will complement anyone’s coloring and personal style. Now, you’ve got the perfect gel eyeliner, all you need to go with that is some long luscious lashes! Enter, the L'Oreal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes Mascara, also in black to match perfectly with their infallible liner.
L’Oreal Paris INFALLIBLE® Lacquer Liner 24H – Available in 5 Colors

L’Oreal Paris Gel Eyeliner K1229600 – Blackest Black


Features
L'Oreal Paris is a global leader in affordable beauty and hair care products. Widely considered to be one of the best brands available in American drugstores, L'Oreal Paris has built a reputation for its diverse and highly pigmented makeup selection, such as the L’Oreal Paris Infallible Gel Lacquer Liner.

Retailing for about $8.50, the L’Oreal Paris Infallible Gel Lacquer Liner includes one 0.08-ounce pot of gel eyeliner and a fine-tip brush. The brushes that come with drugstore makeup tend to be poor quality, but that isn’t the case with the brush in this duo. Its densely packed bristles feel soft, but are stiff enough to create both super fine and thick lines.

L’Oreal Paris claims that its Infallible Gel Lacquer Liner will last for 24 hours. Our research did find it to be long-wearing, though it’s important to let it sit and dry for at least one minute after application. Once dry, this eyeliner has a rich, deep color and a high degree of shine, making it ideal for winged or natural eyeliner styles.

Some other benefits include:
  • Ophthalmologist-approved
  • High-gloss finish
  • 5 beautiful shades
  • Rich, creamy texture
  • Stays put for 24 hours
  • Includes high-quality, fine-tip brush
Best Value
The Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel Liner comes in four intense shades that will make your eyes pop. If you want something a little different, take a little look at the Maybelline Eyestudio Lasting Drama Waterproof Gel Eye Pencil. It works like a regular eyeliner pencil, but with the long-lasting, sleek finish of gel!
Maybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner – Available in 4 Colors

Maybelline New York Gel Eyeliner K0709702 – Charcoal 954


Features
Maybelline New York offers a comprehensive line of beauty products ranging from mascara and eyeliner to foundation, concealer and brow pencils. Maybelline New York’s Eye Studio series is one of the most popular lines, which leads us to the Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel Liner.

Retailing for about $5.45 and touted by fashionistas worldwide for its rich color, the Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel Liner was an easy choice for our Best Value Product category. For this price, you’ll receive one gel eyeliner pot with 2.8 grams of product and a small brush. The brush is decent quality but you may prefer a slanted brush for application, especially if you’re trying to achieve a winged look or any style with a fine point.

Out of all of the products we researched, the Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel Liner was one of the absolute best in terms of length of wear and depth of color. We found the black shade to be a rich, matte and very black pigment that stayed in place for hours. This is a great product for gel eyeliner newbies or aficionados because it is very forgiving, which makes it easy to achieve a ton of different looks.

Some other features we love include:
  • Ophthalmologist-tested – safe for contacts
  • Smudge- and water-resistant
  • Designed for 24-hour use
  • 4 highly concentrated pigments
  • Easy to apply and remove
  • Brush included
The Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Eyeliner comes in 14 enchanting, fade-resistant colors that are the perfect complement to any outfit. If you want more than just the gel eyeliner from Bobbi Brown, check out this awesome Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner 3 Piece Set.
Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner – Available in 3 Sizes and 7 Colors

Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner 716170007861 – 0.10 oz. – Black Ink


Features
Bobbi Brown is a luxury department store makeup brand. Founded by professional makeup artist Bobbi Brown in 1990 with the goal of defining and enhancing an individual’s inherent beauty, the line mostly consists of natural color palettes and gentle formulas. Bobbi Brown is frequently used by professional makeup artists around the world and the company markets Bobbi Brown Pro products specifically for that purpose.

The Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Eyeliner is one of our favorite Bobbi Brown products. Retailing for about $40, it may cost more than some other products in this category, but a single pot should last for months – and there’s something to be said for the fact that it is available in 14 unique, eye-popping shades! Please note that this product does not include a brush, so you’ll want to pick one up. Each pot includes 3 grams of product.

Check out these other luxurious benefits:
  • Available in 5 metallic/shimmer shades
  • Available in 9 vivid matte shades, including black ink
  • Made for 12-hour wear
  • Intense color
  • Smooth and creamy texture makes application a cinch
  • Fast-drying
The TonyMoly Backstage Gel Eyeliner’s built-in brush and thin consistency make application a breeze. If you prefer applying eyeliner with a pencil, but want the great gel finish, then the Perfect Eyes Longkinny Gel Pen Liner could be perfect for you.
TonyMoly Backstage Gel Eyeliner 4g – Available in 6 Colors

TonyMoly Gel Eyeliner - #5 Pearl Black


Features
TonyMoly is a well-known, economical Korean makeup and skincare line. They have several retail locations in the US, plus distribution deals with several different stores, such as Urban Outfitters. Many people love TonyMoly’s products for their cute packaging, bright colors and innovative design.

The TonyMoly Backstage Gel Eyeliner is one of TonyMoly’s many great eyeliners. For about $8.99, you’ll receive one gel eyeliner pot with 4 grams of product and a brush that is built into the lid – a feature that we really like. The TonyMoly Backstage Gel Eyeliner is a very smooth consistency, which makes it easy to apply, and the built-in the brush makes it ideal for on-the-go use. It comes in 6 vivid shades, two of which have a shimmery pearl finish.

The TonyMoly Backstage Gel Eyeliner also boasts:
  • Available in 6 shades
  • Durable plastic pot
  • Convenient design with nice, built-in brush
  • Comes off easily with makeup remover
  • Smooth, thin consistency>
  • Great value
The e.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Eyeliner boasts a creamy formula that, with the right brush, is easy to apply and looks great for hours. If you prefer the precision and control of liquid eyeliner, try the e.l.f. Expert Liquid Liner.
e.l.f. Cream Eyeliner

E.l.f. Cosmetics Gel Eyeliner #81164


Features
e.l.f. Cosmetics is an up-and-coming drugstore makeup brand. Designed with the consumer in mind, the line retails for significantly less than that of many major competitors. Since their debut several years ago, e.l.f. Cosmetics has worked hard to improve and expand their product line.

e.l.f. Cosmetics offers several beautiful eyeliners, including this e.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Eyeliner. It retails for about $4.80, and includes one .17-ounce pot of gel eyeliner and a small slanted brush. It comes in four different shades, including a shimmery gold that is very unique.

Some other great benefits include:
  • Smudge-resistant
  • Water-resistant
  • 4 unique shades
  • Brush included
  • Very cost-competitive

Get the Best Gel Eyeliner of 2018!

Whether you’re getting ready for a night on the town or want to look polished and professional at the office, you can achieve the results you’re looking for with any of the five gel eyeliners included in this review. However, if you did not find the gel eyeliner you were looking for, you can check out our recommended brands for other options that are available. Get out there and pick your favorite eyeliner!

Our Top Choice
L’Oreal Paris Infallible Gel Lacquer Liner
Best Value
Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel Liner
Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Eyeliner
TonyMoly Backstage Gel Eyeliner
e.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Eyeliner