Best Ice Maker Reviews 2018

Summer brings the allure of bright sunshine, warmth, and loads of fun activities with family and friends. The weather is ideal for outdoor activities such as camping and fishing trips. However, the hot temperatures spur serious cravings for ice-cold drinks. Ice makers are a convenient alternative to traditional refrigerators as they are easy to use and make ice cubes in a matter of minutes. Whether you’re at home or on-the-go, an ice maker will get your drink cold in minutes. Let’s go straight into some of the best ice maker brands we have reviewed in detail and see what they have to offer.
Overview
PROS
CONS
SPECS
Type
Size
Cycle
Capacity
Color(s)
Our Top Choice
Whynter Stainless Steel Under Counter Ice Maker
Whynter are experts in all things cool, from air conditioners to refrigerators. The Whynter UIM-155 combines a sleek design and durable material with great ice production.
Easy Installation. Compact size. Durable. Energy efficient. LCD display.
Slow to start. No sleep mode.
Under counter
18"x 15" x 25", 54lbs
12 lbs per 24 hours
6 lbs capacity
Available in silver
Best Value
Avalon Bay Countertop Ice Maker
Avalon Bay is a leader in the small home appliance market. This small but very fast ice maker has decent features at an affordable price.
Makes ice cubes very fast. Compact size. Saves on space. Two different ice sizes. Easy setup and operation. Light weight.
Noisy. Small ice bucket. Ice will melt if you don’t remove from tray.
Portable Ice maker
11"x14.8"x14.7", 20lbs
9 ice cubes every 6-13 minutes
26 lbs capacity
Available in 3 colors
EdgeStar 12 lb. Freestanding Ice Maker
EdgeStar create stylish and functional home appliances, including ice makers. Their Freestanding Ice Maker features a compact design that can fit in small spaces.
Space and energy saving. Large storage. Attractive design. Works as advertised
Can be noisy. Needs qualified professional for installation.
Built-in Ice Maker
25”x19”x17”, 54 lbs
12 lbs per day
6 lbs capacity
Available in black
Magic Chef 27-Lb. Ice Maker-Portable
Magic Chef offers a whole host of household appliances. The 27lbs Portable Ice Maker produces ice in quick cycles. Great features and produces different ice sizes.
Fast production. Easy to clean. Quality material. Reputable brand
Little noisy. Doesn’t keep ice frozen for long. No auto-shut feature.
Portable Ice maker
15”x11.7”x17.7”, 23.8 lbs
9 ice cubes in 7 minutes
27lbs capacity
Available in silver
NewAir Countertop Ice Maker
Newair is ”A name you can trust” when it comes to home appliances. Their AI-100S icemaker is compact and delivers ready ice within a few minutes.
Huge capacity. Quick production. Beautiful design. Easy to use and maintain. Dependable brand.
Non self-cleaning. Ice melts quickly. Must dry ice.
Portable ice maker
14.5”x11.75”x15”, 24.3lbs
9 ice cubes every 6-15 minutes
28lbs capacity
Available in 5 colors

(Updated )

How Do I Choose the Best Ice Maker?

We can all agree that one of the best diffusers of tension in a film scene is when one of the characters leaves a highly charged conversation, walks to a cabinet, picks a glass, adds some ice cubes, and pours his or herself a drink. We’ve seen it in classics such as the Godfather as well as blockbusters such as James Bond. The narrative here is that cool people love cool drinks and ice cubes are at the center of it all. How cool it would be if the directors gave ice makers their much-deserved credit by placing them in the frame. After all, they wasted no time featuring drones when they came out!

An ice maker is a highly functional appliance owing to the fact that it produces the highly sought-after ice cubes. Apart from putting them in drinks, ice cubes also have numerous other uses. For example, when reheating rice in a microwave oven, one can prevent it from drying out by placing an ice cube on it. Ice cubes can also come in handy when removing gum from surfaces. Let’s assume the class bully got jealous of your new backpack and stuck a piece of gum on it as you were walking home. All you have to do is walk to the ice maker, take out a few ice cubes, and place them on the part where the gum is. The gum freezes, making it easy to remove with a knife.

Ice remains a must-have on hot summer days. By investing in a sleek ice maker, you will be assured of dense ice cubes that meet your cooling needs.
Price
While we don’t want to come off as salesman-like, we have to say that the last thing that should be on your mind when purchasing an ice maker is the price. This is because the items we’ve selected suit everyone regardless of their income status. However, if you want a product with impressive top-line features, we suggest you zero in on a pricier one. That said, do try and steer clear of cheap ice makers as they may lack a warranty or have no automatic shutoff feature.

The price of our featured ice makers ranges from around $130 to $400, with differences being accounted for by features and brand. For instance, an ice maker that has an auto shutoff feature will cost you more than one which doesn’t. When it comes to brand, a company such as Whynter has a niche in refrigeration equipment and is well-known for producing high-quality items. As such, its items will cost you more than those made by a lesser-known brand.
Features
An ice maker should produce definitely-shaped ice cubes. Apart from color, other features you might want to keep in mind when purchasing an ice maker are highlighted below.
  • Capacity - How much ice an ice maker holds plays a crucial part in a person’s purchasing decision.
  • Cycle - This is primarily concerned with the rate at which the machine produces ice cubes.
  • Indicator Lights - This feature is especially important if you’re not good with machines as it tells you when to add water or when the basket is full.
  • Ice Size Settings- The size of the ice cubes that we need differs depending on intended use.
  • Portability - An ice maker will be more useful to you if you can carry it around with you.
  • Compactness - Does it fit well in all kinds of spaces?
  • Automatic Shut-off - You may not always be there to switch off the ice maker when it’s done producing the ice cubes.
  • Dual Functionality - Apart from producing ice, what else can the ice maker do?
Construction and Design
Ice makers come in a variety of shapes and sizes. Look out for capacity, cycle length, indicator lights and auto shut off features when browsing. Let’s dive into the reasons why these are important consideration factors.

Capacity

Capacity will undoubtedly be at the top of your agenda when purchasing an ice maker. If you engage in activities where a lot of ice is needed, an ice maker that has a large capacity will suit you. However, if you’re the type to unwind by reading a book while drinking a martini, you may not require a large ice maker as you don’t need a large volume of ice.

Cycle

The second feature you should look for when selecting an ice maker is its cycle. An ice-making cycle is the time the machine takes to convert water to ice. In a high-traffic setting such as a pub where ice is frequently needed in large amounts, an ice maker that can produce nine ice cubes in 6-15 minutes would be a valuable addition.

Indicator Light

Not everyone is blessed with the patience to understand the technicalities of a new household appliance. With some ice makers, it may be difficult to tell when to add water or take out the ice. Fortunately, some of our selected products come with an indicator light that tells you when the ice basket fills up and when to add water. That way, you never have to sit there waiting for the ice to form only to realize later that there was no water to make it in the first place.

Automatic Shutoff

The automatic shutoff feature is also an important element in an ice maker. It switches the appliance off once it’s done making ice, thereby helping you to make savings on your electricity expenses.
Performance and Ease of Use
Certain factors like size settings, portability, compactness and dual functionality are important things to consider too. Next we will tell you why!

Size Settings

The ideal ice cube changes depending on the setting. Small ice cubes are more suitable for mixed drinks such as martinis, while large ones are at home in whiskey glasses. An ice maker that can produce a variety of ice cube sizes is a big plus for you, and our selected brands understand this. In fact, some of their products have ice size settings that allow you to make three different sizes of ice cubes.

Portability

Portability is also an important aspect to consider when buying an ice maker. If you’re always on-the-go and need an appliance whose carrying logistics don’t give you headaches, a great pick will be something that weighs 20 pounds. On the other hand, if you’re more reserved and your ice needs are within the confines of your home, a bulkier ice maker will do the job.

Compactness

Like with all household appliances, the space taken up by the ice maker is something you should think about. If your kitchen is already congested and you’re not sure where to place the ice maker, keep calm as all our selected items are compact and, therefore, take up very little space.

Dual Functionality

While an ice maker’s function is to produce ice, it would become infinitely more useful if it could serve another purpose, say as a freezer. One of our selected ice makers does just that, thereby making it possible to store food and drinks for longer periods of time.

What is the Best Ice Maker?

If your refrigerator has been giving you problems when making ice cubes and troubleshooting it doesn’t appear to work, an ice maker will come in handy. It can produce ice cubes in minutes and doesn’t take up as much space as a fridge does. Since you have an idea of what to look for when purchasing one, let’s proceed to the best ice makers in the market, positive that you will find one that meets your needs.
Our Top Choice
The Whynter UIM-155 works perfectly for a compact under counter ice maker, making 12 pounds of ice per day. It is built by a reputable manufacturer with loads of good reviews on Amazon. If you prefer a portable model, the Portable 49lb ice maker may come in handy.
Whynter Stainless Steel Built-In Ice Maker, Auto Shutoff Feature, CFC-free Compressor

Whynter Ice Maker UIM-155


Features
Whynter is one of the most recognized companies that manufactures home appliances. Whynter ice makers feature outstanding home climate control, saving on energy while giving optimum performance. The UIM-155 ice maker utilizes space utilization and performance through a high efficiency CFC-free compressor.

One feature we liked about this ice maker is the ease of use. The one button operation is a convenient and easy way to make crescent-shaped ice cubes.

The Whynter UIM-155 ice maker has a beautiful stylish silver color that matches most kitchen and bar décor themes. This ice maker has a retail price of $425, although when we have checked, there’s been quite a sizeable discount on Amazon!

Here are some of the main features of the UIM-155 ice maker:
  • Silver stainless steel door with black cabinet
  • Auto shut off feature
  • Defrosts Manually
  • Doesn’t require a drain
  • Consumes 120W power
  • 1-year limited warranty
  • 108 Feet and 0.25 inch grade water line
  • Stores 6 pounds of ice
  • Easy to use free standing installation
Best Value
Make ice whenever you like with the Avalon Bay AB-ICE26S Portable Ice Maker. It is a great portable ice maker that doesn’t need a permanent installation. In the market for other home appliances? Avalon Bay also offers an air-fryer with the same stylish design as their ice makers.
Avalon Bay Portable Ice Maker 26lbs Capacity

Avalon Bay Portable Ice Maker AB-ICE26S - Silver


Features
Avalon Bay is one of the top manufactures of home appliances. The Avalon Bay portable ice maker is one of the coolest portable icemakers you can find. It is fast and very convenient when you need ice at home or during your break at work.
The Avalon Bay AB-ICE26S Portable Ice Maker has a small sleek shape indicator light that lets you know when the ice basket is full and when you need to add more water. For just $163.37 you can make your own bullet-shaped ice cubes (very chewable) in less than 10 minutes.

Let’s look at the main features of the Avalon Bay AB-ICE26S Portable Ice Maker:
  • Makes 26lbs of ice in 24 hours
  • LED indicator
  • Power consumption, 230 watts
  • Includes ice scoops
  • Two Ice cube sizes
  • Easy-to-use push buttons
  • Easy-to-clean bottom drain
  • Automatic overflow indicator
This stylish, modern ice maker comes in silver, black or red, so you can choose whichever color suits your home best.
The EdgeStar 12 Lb. Built-In ice maker is a great, functioning choice. Along with its compact design, the storage bin ensures the ice doesn’t melt. In case you are looking for a more affordable portable model check out the great range of EdgeStar ice makers.
EdgeStar Built-In Ice Maker 12lbs of Ice Per Day

EdgeStar Ice Maker IB120SS


Features
A portable ice maker is the ultimate companion on a trip. Be it a long Sunday afternoon fishing or a road trip in your RV, you need an appliance that will keep you going with ice cold drinks, for as long as you want. EdgeStar sets the standards when it comes to manufacturing portable appliances. Their vast ranges of products are space-saving and offer great functionality.

The body of the EdgeStar 12 Lb. Black IB120SS is made of stainless steel with a reversible door that complements most kitchen interior décor.
Here is what you need to know in terms of features about the EdgeStar ice maker:
  • Front venting for built-in or freestanding installation
  • 12 lbs of crescent shaped ice every day
  • Storage bin that stores 6lbs of ice
  • ADA height complaint
  • 25 foot 0.25 inch water line connection
  • Auto shutoff feature
  • Reversible black door
  • Defrosts Manually
  • 1 year warranty
This product is one among a great line of ice makers from EdgeStar. The main differences in the product lines lies in amount of ice produced per day, dimensions, price and accessories. We particularly liked this product because it ranked high in functionality, good looks and great value for money.
Keep your drinks cold and your guests entertained with this great ice maker. It has a compact design and is perfect for home or camping. If you are looking for a larger capacity model, have a look at the 30-Lb. icemaker
Magic Chef 27-Lb. Portable Ice Maker, 3 Ice Cube Sizes, Large Capacity

Magic Chef Ice Maker MCIM22TS


Features
If you have a large family that seems to go through a lot of ice every day, but doesn’t seem to remember to fill the ice tray, the Magic Chef 27-Lb. Portable Ice Maker may be just what you need. It’s built by Magic Chef, a company with more than 85 years of experience in delivering convenient and durable kitchen appliances and home essentials.

The Magic Chef 27-Lb Ice Maker is a very sleek ice maker to have around the house, especially during summer. It makes 9 small cubes in less than 10 minutes, giving you almost instant cubes whenever you are in need. Currently retailing at $325.00 (and even lower on Amazon) this ice maker has decent features for its listing price.

Let’s break down some of the main features:
  • Convenient LED control pad with indicator lights
  • Ice basket is removable
  • Yields 9 cubes in a 7-minute cycle
  • Makes 27 Lbs. of ice per day
  • 3 sizes of ice, small, medium and large
  • Viewing window included
  • Built-in water drain cap
The featured product is part of a line of portable ice makers and compact refrigerators from the Magic Chef brand. Other ice makers from this brand are also great, but vary in terms of type, capacity, dimensions as well as price.
Keep your drinks cool with a beautiful ice maker that fits well on the countertop. The NewAir AI-100S ice maker is easy carry and is great for both indoor and outdoor activities. In case you’re looking for an ice maker with a bigger capacity, Newair also make a larger model.
NewAir Portable Ice Maker – Available in 5 colors

NewAir Portable Icemaker AI-100S - Silver


Features
Everything goes down well with a cold drink, especially in hot environments during work. NewAir is one the most recognized ice maker manufacturers in America. Their product lines have even been featured in the Best of Life magazine. What we particularly liked about this product is the great design and ease of use.

The water in the reservoir incorporated a recycling model and you only need to change it once per day. The push button and LED control lets you choose the size of ice cube you want. The ice cubes are bullet-shaped and you can choose from three sizes.
Let us take a glimpse at some of the main features:
  • Produces 28 lbs ice per day
  • 9 ice cubes per 6-minute cycle
  • Push button control panel with two buttons
  • Side-mounted drain plug for easy drainage
  • Environmentally friendly R-314 refrigerant
  • Available in Silver, Black, Red, Cyan Blue and Vermillion Orange
  • Ice scoop and basket included

Get the Best Ice Maker of 2018!

After going through this review, we’re confident that your selection of the perfect ice maker will be much easier. We must mention that all the brands we have examined are known for producing high-quality items that receive top ratings in customer satisfaction. If it emerges that none of the products we’ve featured match what you’re looking for, feel free to examine other items they manufacture.

Our Top Choice
Whynter Stainless Steel Under Counter Ice Maker
Best Value
Avalon Bay Countertop Ice Maker
EdgeStar 12 lb. Freestanding Ice Maker
Magic Chef 27-Lb. Ice Maker-Portable
NewAir Countertop Ice Maker