Best Liquid Eyeliner Reviews 2018

Liquid eyeliner is fast becoming the must-have makeup accessory of the century. With everyone seeming to rock this unique, fun, and chic style, we don’t blame you for wanting a piece of the action yourself! To help you choose the ideal liquid eyeliner for you, we’ve selected the best liquid eyeliner brands on the market today as well as a product to feature from each to give you a better feel for the different types of liquid eyeliner available to you.
Overview
PROS
CONS
SPECS
Size
Waterproof
Colors
Wear Time
Testing
Our Top Choice
L’Oreal Paris Infallible Super Slim Eyeliner
L’Oréal is a brand that’s all about making its customers feel beautiful everyday with its range of revolutionary life-proof products.
Available in 2 colors and 2 pack sizes. 12-hour stay. Goes on smoothly. Good for sensitive eyes and contact wearers.
Prone to smudging.
0.3 ounces
No
Black Only
12 hours
Not tested on animals
Best Value
Maybelline EyeStudio Precise Liquid Liner
Maybelline is all about creating products that are easy to use and create stunning looks that you’ll love.
12-hour stay. Smudge-proof. Water-proof. Fragrant free. Available in pack of 1-3.
Liner dries out quickly.
0.037 ounces
Yes
Black Only
12 hours
Tested on animals
Stila Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Liner
Stila is a brand that’s all about bringing cat-walk chic to the masses, and has done so excellently for over 20 years.
Available in 14 different colors. Waterproof. Smudge-resistant. Day-to-night lasting technology.
Product dries up easily.
0.8 ounces
Yes
14 Colors
All day and night
Tested on animals
Physicians Formula 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner
Physicians Formula is all about using high-end technology to bring you the best products possible, all of them perfectly suitable even for those with sensitive skin.
Available in pack of 1 or 2. Dermatologically tested. Paraben-free. Waterproof.
Doesn’t last as long as other all-day liners.
0.3 ounces
Yes
Black Only
Day and night
Not tested on animals
Golden Rose Extreme Sparkle Eyeliner
Golden Rose is all about creating fun, stunning products that bring out the best in its customers, and has done so since 1983.
Available in 9 different colors. Glittery. Can be worn day and night.
Can be tricky to apply.
2.1 ounces
No
Available in 9 Colors
Long-lasting
Not tested on animals

(Updated )
Related Reviews
Best Gel Eyeliner
Best Liquid Foundation
Best Powder Foundation

How Do I Choose the Best Liquid Eyeliner?

Eyeliner is a powerful tool. It has the ability to completely change the look of your eyes depending on how you style it. Whether it’s a signature Amy Winehouse flick or a Bridgette Bardot smoky eye, eye liner truly is a girl’s best friend. Getting that perfect eyeliner look is no easy task, however, and may take you several attempts (and a few YouTube tutorials) to get your signature look. Whatever style it is you’re going for, knowing what type of eyeliner you’re after will make this process a lot easier.

There are four main types of liners to choose from:
  • Gel Eyeliners - Gel eyeliners are often seen as the easiest to apply due to their soft texture and intense color. Gel eyeliners are applied with a brush and, once dried, are resistant to smudging, smearing, or fading. Gel liners are also super versatile and can offer the user a range of looks, from sharp lines to a blended smoky eye. The downside to gel liners, however, is that they can take a while to set and aren’t overly portable.
  • Pencil Eyeliners - Pencil eyeliners are made from waxy sticks of colored pigment. These eyeliners are much more affordable than other styles and create longer-lasting lines. Pencil eyeliners are a great idea if you’re looking to experiment with a variety of colors, offering blue, pink, green, and any other color you can imagine!
  • Powder-based / Eyeshadow - Although not technically an ‘eye liner’, eyeshadow pallets offer many of the same characteristics and style options. Powder-based eyeliners are very easy to apply and come in a variety of intense shades, too. Applied with a thin, flat brush, eyeshadows are perfect for a subtle daytime look that’s not too overpowering, or a dramatic smoky eye for a night out on the town.
  • Liquid Eyeliners - Liquid eyeliners are ideal for dramatic evening looks due to their high pigmentation and long-lasting technology. They’re usually applied via a wand or brush that’s attached to the cap of the eyeliner tube, making it portable and easy to apply. Unlike gel, pencil, and powdered liners, liquid liners leave a sharp, defined look that can’t be achieved any other way.
Let’s take a closer look at liquid eyeliners, shall we?

In comparison to other eyeliners, liquid liners are ideal for the fashion savvy amongst you looking to pair their makeup with vintage styles and contemporary looks. Although it can be difficult to apply, the struggle is well worth it once you see the results. Many brands have also made attempts to make their liquid liners easier to apply with quick-drying formulas and simpler applicators. When selecting the best liquid eyeliner for you, there are a few things you’ll want to consider before making a purchase.

Firstly, you’ll want to take a look at the different liquid eyeliner formulas available to you and which one will suit your lifestyle and makeup preferences the best. The majority of liquid eyeliners are black and highly pigmented for a bold and dramatic look. They are, however, available in a variety of other colors and finishes.

If you’re new to the liquid eyeliner game, then you may want to start off with a neutral, matte style that will allow you to practice your technique beforehand and then move on to bolder styles once you’re more familiar with the product. If you’re looking for a subtle daytime look or have fair skin, you may want to opt for a gray, navy blue, or brown color instead, as black may be too harsh. More vibrant colors are also available for the more adventurous, creating impressive looks that are perfect for festivals or fancy dress.

Liquid eyeliners also come in three different finishes: matte, shimmer, and gloss. The most common form of liquid eyeliner is gloss, creating a painted-on look that will remain long after the product has dried. Matte eyeliners are more natural in style and well-suited to daytime use. Shimmer eyeliners, on the other hand, are ideal for nights out or events as they contain a metallic pigment for a bolder, fashion-forward look. Many users also prefer to use a waterproof liquid eyeliner formula due to its staying ability in sweaty and moist conditions (think holidays in the sun or watching the Notebook…).

Finally, you’ll want to have a think about the applicator in your liquid eyeliner that will give you the best results. Originally, all liquid eyeliners came with a small brush that was used to paint on the product. Today, however, technological advances offer greater control and more precision when applying liners. There are three main types to choose from:
  • Pens - Eyeliner pens are very similar to eyeliner pencils in the way they’re applied. The main difference, however, is that eyeliner pens offer sharper and cleaner lines. Their felt-tipped design offers the same look as if you were using a brush, but is much simpler to apply. If you’re just starting out using liquid eyeliners then a pen applicator will probably be the best choice.
  • Felt-Tip Points - This is a more traditional way of applying your liquid liner, with a felt tip point attached to the lid of the liner bottle. As the liner doesn’t flow through the product like it would with a pen application, the liner is much more pigmented, creating a more intense look.
  • Brushes - If you’re a fan of cat-eye styles and flicks in your eye makeup, then a brush is definitely the way to go. Brushes can create very small lines, offering the user precision and ease of use. If you’re looking for versatility in your liner, this is the applicator for you.
Price
The cost of your new liquid eyeliner is going to depend on a variety of factors, including the size of the product and how many features it contains. The size of liquid eyeliners varies from 0.3 ounces to 2.5 ounces, with larger products tending to be more expensive. If a liquid eyeliner has multiple color options, this can also bump the price up as it offers the user more variety.

These days, it’s becoming more and more popular to use products that are more natural as well, meaning the product uses less harsh ingredients, making them suitable for those with sensitive eyes and those who are concerned about animal testing.

If you’re after a high-end product, then you can expect to pay anywhere from $15 to $25 for a liquid eyeliner. Less expensive models ($5 – $15) are still just as good, but may not offer the user handy features like waterproofing, sensitivity, and color variety. There are cheaper liquid eyeliners available on the market ($3 or less) too, but be aware that these liners may not look as good, last as long, or be as kind to your eyes.
Features
When it comes to the features included in your new liquid eyeliner, this depends on your personal preferences as well as the look and style you’re after. To help you choose the best liquid eyeliner for you, we’ve created a list of handy features to look out for to ensure you select a high-quality product.

Here are some important features to look out for…
  • Sensitivity
  • Waterproof
  • Color Variety
  • Smudge Resistant
Construction and Design
When attempting to select a high-quality liquid eyeliner, we recommend selecting a product that’s designed with sensitivity in mind. A sensitive eyeliner usually contains no fragrances or harmful ingredients that could irritate the user’s eyes. This is particularly useful if you use contact lenses and want to prevent the likelihood of smearing and smudging.

Another handy feature to have included in your new liquid eyeliner is waterproofing. Most liquid eyeliners contain oils or waxes that will make the eyeliner naturally water-resistant anyway. There are some new designs, however, that are resistant to water and sweat. This makes them perfect for holidays or music festivals, where you may be sweating a bit more than usual.

As we mentioned previously, getting the right color of liquid eyeliner is crucial to the look you’re after. By choosing a brand with multiple color options, you can choose a product that’s perfectly catered to you, your skin tone, and your eye color. If you have green eyes, then purple and violet tones will really make your eyes pop; blue eyes suit bronze and brown tones; light brown eyes go best with dark blues and greens; and dark eyes go well with black and grey tones.

Finally, we recommend selecting a product that’s advertised as smudge-resistant. Although liquid eyeliners are naturally more smudge-resistant than gel and pencil liners, they’re still prone to smudging after long-term use. Look out for products that are described as ‘all-day-wear’ for maximum staying power and preventing the dreaded ‘panda eye’ look.
Performance and Ease of Use
Caring for your liquid eyeliner couldn’t be simpler. Like any makeup, you’ll want to make sure the lid is always screwed on tight to prevent annoying leakages and damage to the product. Liquid eyeliners are prone to drying out if left open too long, so ensure you always fasten the product properly after you’re finished using it. Liquid liners are also prone to melting if left in the heat too long, so ensure you store your product in a cool, dry area.

If you’re after a particularly high-end product, we suggest using a product that isn’t tested on animals. Firstly, it’s better for our environment, and better for your little eyes too! Products not tested on animals tend to be more sensitive in design, using natural, good-for-you products that nourish and moisturize your eyes at the same time.

Keep an eye out for products that contain a ‘clicky’ pen top, as well, that allows the user to pump more liner through the product to ensure an intense, dramatic look every time.

What is the Best Liquid Eyeliner?

We hope that after reading through our buying guide, you’ve figured out what type of liquid eyeliner is most suitable to your needs and what you most want out of it. This will make it a lot easier to narrow down your options and select the ideal liquid eyeliner for you and your next big night out! So, let’s go ahead and look at our top 5 picks!
Our Top Choice
We loved L’Oréal’s Infallible Liquid Eye Liner due to its stunning precision and 12-hour stay. We also recommend checking out L'Oreal’s Telescopic Precision Liquid Eyeliner which features a Slanted Precision Felt Tip and comes in black, carbon black, charcoal, and dark brown.
L’Oreal Paris The Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner by Infallible – Ophthalmologist and Allergy-Tested

L’Oreal Liquid Eyeliner 071249238912 – Black, 0.034 oz


Features
L’Oréal Paris is a beauty care brand that creates luxury beauty items by combining the latest technologies with incredible quality. The brand is internationally recognized as one of the biggest beauty brands in the world with a serious commitment to research, innovation, and providing groundbreaking products for women, men, and children everywhere. L’Oréal not only provides cosmetics, but hair color, haircare, and skincare too.

We wanted to feature L’Oréal’s Super Slim Infallible Liquid Eye-Liner due to the notoriety of the brand and because it’s one of the best eyeliners available on the market today. With its ultra-fine 0.4mm tip, this super-slim liquid liner will never let you down, giving you total control of your eyeliner and allowing you to create the exact look you desire. Its quick-dry formula means this liner is skip-proof as well as drag-proof, and goes on smoothly with an even flow. Ophthalmologist-tested, this liner is suitable for the most sensitive of eyes and even contact wearers!
Best Value
We loved Maybelline’s EyeStudio Precise Liquid Eye Liner due to its waterproof design and striking look. If you’re in search of a waterproof liner, you may want to check out Maybelline’s Ultra Liner Liquid Eyeliner, which comes in both black and brown.
Maybelline New York Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Eyeliner - Best of Beauty Award Winner 2013

Maybelline Liquid Eyeliner Eye Studio No.110 – Black - 0.037 Fluid Ounces


Features
Maybelline is a New York-based brand that’s available in over 129 countries worldwide. Offering a variety of over 200 products, Maybelline is the number-one cosmetics brand in the world. By combining advanced technological formulas with on-trend expertise, Maybelline creates products with a modern edge that women everywhere seem to adore.

We wanted to feature Maybelline’s EyeStudio Master Precise Liquid Eyeliner due to it being the best choice in the long-lasting liquid eyeliner category with a stay of up to 12 hours! This liner offers laser-sharp precision with a defined line that’s both striking and elegant. This smudge-proof product is long wearing and waterproof, with a spring cap that keeps the liner fresh. It was even the winner of Allure’s Best of Beauty Award 2013. Ophthalmologist and dermatologist-tested, this product is fragrant-free and suitable for those with sensitive eyes and contact wearers.
We loved Stila’s Stay All Day Liquid liner due to its lasting technology and the fact that it’s available in so many fun colors! Looking for a bit of versatility? Stila’s Morning to Moonlight Waterproof Eye Liner Trio includes three different color liners in the same package.
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Smudgeproof Liquid Luxury Eye Liner– Available in 14 Colors

Stila Liquid Eyeliner S389070001 – White


Features
Stila has been creating innovative, long-lasting products for over twenty years and shows no sign of slowing down now! Stila prides itself in its long-lasting, catwalk-inspired products that last from morning to night. It believes that the right makeup can transform any look and hopes to give women around the world the best of makeup – making them beautiful inside and out!

We wanted to feature Stila’s Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Liner due to it being a #1 bestseller on Amazon and because it’s a more high-end style of liquid liner! Easy to apply, this waterproof liner will stay on all day and night with no feathering, smudging, or running! This liner also glides on easily with its thin marker tip and dries instantly, as well! This liner allows you to create a variety of looks from thick, 60s-style wings or thin understated and chic—the choice is up to you!
We loved Physicians Formula’s 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Liner due to its eco-friendly design and lash-boosting technology. Want to line your eyes for a more natural look? Check out the Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Eyeliner Trio for Nude Eyes.
Physicians Formula Booster™ 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner Plus Serum – Available in Deep Brown, Black and Ultra Black

Physicians Formula Liquid Eyeliner 7366 – Deep Brown


Features
Physicians Formula started out when Dr. Frank Crandall wanted to make a line of cosmetic products for his wife, who suffered from sensitive skin. Since then, the Physicians Formula brand has grown enormously and now brings color correction cosmetic products to the masses. By working with makeup artists from around the world, Physicians Formula was able to bring catwalk style directly to women at home by creating unique, easy-to-use products that make women feel incredible.

We wanted to feature Physicians Formula’s 2-In-1 Lash Boosting Liquid Eyeliner due to the product’s great reviews online and the fact that there are very few liquid liners on the market that emphasize lashes and define the eye. The high-tech formula in this product targets the base of the lashes, and therefore boosts the look of your eyes for a real ‘wow factor’. Easy to use, this liner creates effortless definition with its innovative Japanese formula that’s long-lasting and waterproof! Our favorite feature of this product, however, has to be its eco-friendly, and fragrance and cruelty-free design.
We loved Golden Rose’s Extreme Sparkle Eyeliner due to its dramatic statement style and the fact that it’s available in such a wide variety of colors. Prefer a metallic shimmer over sparkle? Golden Rose’s Metallic Eyeliner comes in 17 ultra-shiny metallic colors that will let you really make a statement with your eyes.
Golden Rose Extreme Sparkle Liquid Eyeliner - Available in 9 Hot, Fashionable Colors

Golden Rose Liquid Eyeliner 794168078369 – 09 Gold


Features
Golden Rose is part of the bigger brand name Erkul, a high-quality manufacturer that’s been producing cosmetics since 1983. With over 30 years’ experience, Erkul creates an astonishing amount of products that range from foundations, powders, eye shadows, lipsticks, and more! Now exporting its products to over 90 countries worldwide, Erkul and Golden Rose are one of the most popular cosmetic brand names today, creating fun, beautiful products that people everywhere love to wear!

We wanted to feature Golden Rose’s Extreme Sparkle Eyeliner due to its multiple color choices and because it’s glittery! This product creates a stunning, glamorous effect that makes your eyes truly pop. With a huge range of colors, you can wear a different shade every day of the week—we really wouldn’t blame you! This long-lasting liner is perfect for day and night makeup, and is a liner design you’ll struggle to find anywhere else.

Get the Best Liquid Eyeliner of 2018!

By now you should have a better idea of what type of liquid eyeliners are available and what it is you’re looking for in your new product. If, however, you aren’t a fan of those we featured, don’t panic! All the brands we’ve chosen have a wide selection of liquid liners to choose from, so you can simply scroll through their other products to find the best liquid eyeliner for you. All that’s left to do now is select your favorite and start practicing those flicks. Good luck!

Our Top Choice
L’Oreal Paris Infallible Super Slim Eyeliner
Best Value
Maybelline EyeStudio Precise Liquid Liner
Stila Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Liner
Physicians Formula 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner
Golden Rose Extreme Sparkle Eyeliner