Best Pencil Eraser Reviews 2018

Erasers are lovely for many reasons. Most namely, they offer second chances (and we all deserve that). It’s all fun and games until papers get torn from over-erasing or our work gets smudged all over the page. That’s why we need the best pencil erasers there are. We at Topprodicts have done our research and highlighted our favorite erasers from five top brands. We’re sure you’ll love our picks, but it’s no big deal if you don’t. There are plenty of other erasers offered by each dependable brand. We also have a review on the best erasers for kids, in case you’d like to check that out as well.

Overview

PROS

CONS

SPECS

Shape

Design

Material

Count

Size

Our Top Choice

Prismacolor Scholar Eraser

Artists unequivocally trust Prismacolor to equip them with every material required for full, uninhibited expression.

Latex and PVC free. Smudge-free, clean erasing. Triangular shape. Corners erase fine details while flat surface works well for larger surface areas. Comfortable fit.

Does produce some dust when used.

Triangular

For fine detail or large areas

Latex-free vinyl

One count

Three inches

Best Value

BIC Assorted Erasers with Grip

BIC is a world-famous brand that is renowned for making high-quality everyday essentials that are designed with every unique individual in mind.

Erases cleanly without stray marks. Allergy safe; PVC and Latex free. Does not smudge. Side-grips allow for stronger grip and comfortable handling. Comes in a 4-pack.

We’re not sure how much dust this eraser leaves

Oval-shaped

Contoured and easy to hold

Latex and PVC free plastic

Pack of four

One inch

Dixon Pencil Shaped Erasers

Dixon is a recognized and revered brand specializing in pencils and other writing supplies. They produce more than half-a-billion Ticonderoga pencils worldwide each year.

Shaped like a Ticonderoga pencil. Latex-free and won’t smudge. Non-toxic. Comes in a 3-pack. Large-sized. Doesn’t leave strays or skid marks.

May be too expensive for some.

Pencil-shaped

Novelty eraser

Latex-free vinyl

Pack of three

Two inches

Staedtler Mars Plastic Erasers

Staedtler is a German brand and a clear favorite among many customers. Their innovative products have certainly made great strides in the stationary industry.

Latex-free. Won’t smudge. Minimal crumbling. Made of high-quality vinyl. Comes with a protective cellophane wrapper. Sliding sleeves for improved handling.

May not erase colored pencils.

Block-shaped

Professional standard

Latex and phthalate free plastic

Packs of one, two, three, or four

Three inches

Pentel Clic Eraser Grip

For over fifty years, Pentel has consistently churned out quality writing products that are so reliable, they come with lifetime warranties.

Pen-style case. Retractable. Refillable. Built-in pocket clip. Latex-free. Won’t smudge or tear.

Shape is not ideal for erasing large surface areas.

Retractable pen-shaped case

Refillable with built-in pocket clip

Latex-free vinyl

Pack of one or three

Seven inches

(Updated January 2, 2018)

Skip ahead and go directly to the reviews.

Related Reviews

Best Pencil

in Office and Business

Fun Express Plastic Stacking Point Pencil Assortment – 50 Pieces, Assorted Colors

Best Colored Pencil

in Toys, Games and Hobbies

Staedtler Ergosoft Colored Pencils – Set of 24 Colors in Stand-Up Easel Case

Best Pencil Box

in Office and Business

Disney Best Frozen Tin Pencil Box - Available in Four Designs

Best Pencils For Kids

in Office and Business

Rhode Island Novelty Hockey Pencil – Assorted Colors; Pack of 12

How Do I Choose the Best Pencil Eraser?

Okay, so it’s the D-day for the big test and you’ve got all your supplies ready: your pen, some pencils, and your trusty sharpener. You’re pretty sure all set, but are you?

During the test, you’re whistling away as you answer the questions and accidentally end up skipping question thirteen. You answered question fourteen in the wrong row by mistake, and you don’t realize your answers are entered incorrectly until you’re more than half-way through the test. Frantically, you reach for your pocket and realize you forgot to bring an eraser. What do you do? Best to leave that to the imagination.

Unlike other stationery items like pens or notebooks, erasers are so small that they are often easily forgotten until the moment when they are desperately needed and nowhere to be found. Even if you do remember to bring an eraser, it needs to be one that won’t tear your paper or smudge your answers. You want one that is easy to hold and will thoroughly erase any markings without damaging the work on the page. Sounds easy enough, right? It’ll be much easier with our tips on what to look out for.

Price

Pencil erasers are inexpensive can cost anywhere between $1 and $50, depending on the quantity and style. For a pack of multiple erasers, you’ll technically spend more than you would for a single one but will actually pay less for each individual eraser. There is a reason that cheap erasers aren’t featured in this review, and if you’ve ever used one you should understand why – they often leave dark smudges all over your work because they are made with cheap latex.

Features

It may just be an eraser, but the wrong choice can be extremely frustrating, especially if it ends up tearing important documents. When shopping for a quality eraser, keep in mind that it should be thorough without leaving any residual mess – we’re looking at you, eraser shavings and smudges. Latex-free erasers are the best bet for avoiding these problems, and they are also sensitive to those with allergies. Make sure to also consider durability, colors, and design. Let’s get into the details already!

Construction and Design

It doesn’t feel great when you get an eraser one week, and the next, it’s finito! So, make sure you have a fairly good idea about how long an eraser lasts before you buy it. Ask around and check out customer reviews to make sure you have your facts, and avoid crumbly erasers at all costs.

As for what to look for, some pencils are specifically designed to be easy to hold for children, people with arthritis, and those of us with klutzy hands. A contoured or triangular eraser should be easy to grip, and some easers even come with plastic cases that are easy to manipulate and include pocket clips. If your eraser is easy to hold, you can perform more precise erasing and are less likely to fumble or accidentally rip the page.

Colors and designs are also important to consider, and the best ones really depend on the person. Some may prefer nostalgic novelty pencils, while others may prioritize function over fashion and opt for a sleek, simple rectangle. Whatever catches your fancy, there is a plethora of options that will suit your needs.

Performance and Ease of Use

Before getting caught up in the razzmatazz of color and design, however, you need to make sure you’re investing in an eraser that works. If it doesn’t, it doesn’t matter if it’s shaped like a unicorn and has all the colors of the rainbow, you’ll never use it. A good eraser should absorb every hint of graphite without smearing or smudging, even with the lightest touch. If you want an eraser that will erase colored pencils, do a bit of research before buying. Some high-quality erasers only work well on regular graphite and will not adequately erase colorful pigments. Further, be sure to get an eraser that leaves minimal residue; you want your page to have as little evidence that a mistake ever occurred as possible.

What is the Best Pencil Eraser?

The best erasers are latex-free, easy to hold, and long-lasting. To get some of the neatest erasers on the block, stay tuned while we parade our top five selections.

Our Top Choice

There are regular erasers and then there is the Prismacolor Scholar Eraser, which comes in a lovely triangular shape that allows for a comfortable fit. Since it’s latex-free, it also erases neatly without smudging. Prefer an eraser designed to work on delicate surfaces? Take a look at the Prismacolor Premier Magic Rub Vinyl Erasers.

Prismacolor Scholar Latex-Free Eraser – 1-Count

Prismacolor Pencil Eraser - 1774625

Features

Prismacolor supports artists both young and old by supplying them with every material required for full, uninhibited expression. They continually reinvent their designs and evolve to adapt to the ever-changing needs of modern artists. Over the last 75 years, Prismacolor’s vision has accrued a strong reputation among creatives.

The Prismacolor Scholar Eraser is an excellent example of a pencil eraser that works. First, and most importantly, it is made without latex or PVC, so you can be sure that it will erase every mark neatly without leaving ugly smudges on your work. The triangular shape makes this eraser comfortable to hold and dynamic in purpose. While the triangle’s corners are perfect for working on fine details, the flat surface can easily erase larger surface areas.

Here are a few more products from Prismacolor that you may be interested in:

Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils
Prismacolor Premier Double-Ended Art Markers
Prismacolor Premier Pencil Sharpener
Prismacolor Premier Fine Line Illustration Markers
Prismacolor Premier Colorless Blender Pencils

Not quite sure about this one? Prismacolor has other quality erasers and art supplies to check out!

Best Value

We love BIC Erasers so much because of how accommodating they are. Their super-snug side-grips guarantee a strong, comfortable grip throughout the erasing process, even if you’re a bit klutzy. Want more from BIC? How about the BIC Velocity Max Mechanical Pencil that comes with a large eraser?

BIC Erasers with Grip – 4-Pack, Comes in Assorted Colors

BIC Pencil Eraser – BICERSGP41AST

Features

BIC is a world-famous brand known for their long years of serving the public with amazing everyday products. They are a foremost leader in multiple industries producing lighters, shavers, and, of course, stationery. For more than 60 years, BIC has stayed true to their mission to make products that are simple, innovative, dependable, and of a consistently high quality.

One thing we love about BIC Erasers is that they come in exciting colors. Perhaps their most charming feature, these erasers also come with two side-handles that make them comfortable to hold and easy to handle; a huge advantage for customers with arthritis as well as those who can be a bit klutzy at times. They are non-toxic and latex-free, so they won’t agitate your allergies or irritate sensitive skin. Plus, latex-free erasers are known to keep documents tidier and reduce smudging.

Want more? Here are a few other great products available from BIC:

BIC Multi-Purpose Lighter
BIC Velocity Retractable Ball Pen
BIC Marking Pen Marker
BIC Mark-it Permanent Marker
BIC Gel-ocity Retractable Gel Pen
BIC Wite-Out EZ Correction Tape

With this eraser in hand, give yourself a clean slate any time.

Remember the famous Ticonderoga pencils? Well even if you don’t, the Dixon Pencil Shaped Erasers will remind you. These erasers are latex-free, so you can be sure that they won’t smudge. Check out the Dixon Ticonderoga Office and School Eraser Combination Set for more sturdy erasers in exciting shapes and assorted colors.

Dixon Ticonderoga Pencil Shaped Erasers – 3-Pack

Dixon Pencil Eraser - 38953

Features

A stickler for excellence, Dixon has manufactured top-notch writing supplies for decades. They recognize the critical role of writing and art supplies in everyday excellence and are therefore committed to delivering the best products possible. When it comes to customer care, you can be sure that it hardly gets better than Dixon.

Why do we love the Dixon Pencil Shaped Erasers so much? A more pressing question is: how could we not? They remind us of classic Ticonderoga pencils, which we like so much that we featured them in our pencils review. These erasers are large in size and long lasting -- especially since they come in packs of three. Without a trace of latex or PVC, Dixon erasers are non-toxic and won’t smudge.

Here are some other great products from Dixon. Check them out and thank us later:

The Dixon Reach Deep Hole Permanent Marker
The Dixon Ticonderoga No.2 Pencils
The Dixon Ticonderoga Wood-cased 2HB Pencils
The Dixon Industrial Lumber Crayon
The Dixon Dry Erase Markers

Not sure if this fits the bill? Relax, Dixon came prepared. Check out their other options!

Tired of erasers that keep crumbling and never last? Then say hello to your new best friend: Staedtler’s Mars Plastic Erasers. Made of white vinyl, they thoroughly erase with little to no crumbling. Looking for something else? Why not try out the Staedtler Stick Eraser Set?

Staedtler Mars Plastic Erasers – 4-Pack

Staedtler Pencil Eraser – STD52650BK4

Features

Staedtler has been ahead of the times since their inception; innovation is reflected in their products. While Staedtler originally only manufactured pencils, they have diversified their stock to include all sorts of dependable writing materials for everyday use.

The bane of most erasers is their terribly short life span, but this isn’t the case with Staedtler Mars Plastic Erasers. Since they don’t crumble, each one can last for several months. Since they come in packs of four, they’ll last even longer. Plus, their sliding sleeves make them comfortable to hold and easy to handle. Just to prove that they are some of the best erasers out there, they are also latex-free and won’t smudge. What more can you ask for?

Here are a few more of our favorite products from Staedtler:

Staedtler Mars Lumograph Wooden Pencils
Staedtler Mars Technical Mechanical Pencil
Staedtler Triplus Fineliner Pens
Staedtler Textsurfer Classic Highlighter
Staedtler Math Set

Not sold on this eraser? There are still plenty of other valuable options from Staedtler!

The Pentel Clic Eraser Grip is a retractable eraser that comes in a pen-style case. The eraser is super long lasting and erases thoroughly. Would you prefer something better suited for larger surface areas? Have a look at the Pentel Hi-polymer Block Eraser.

Pentel Clic Retractable Eraser Grip – 3-Pack, Assorted Colors

Pentel Pencil Eraser – ZE21BP3-K6

Features

Pentel’s brand is so solid, they boast a lifetime warranty on every product they make. While they’ve been in business for over 50 years, they have remained up-to-date with current trends and technology. By combining experience with a culture of innovation, they have developed a formula for delivering consistently high-performing products.

The Pentel Clic Eraser Grip combines an attractive style with high-quality craftsmanship. It comes in a case designed to look like a retractable pen, complete with a pocket clip so you can keep it handy wherever you need it. The case improves the ease of grip, and Pentel’s design is totally latex-free, so you don’t have to worry about smudging important papers or irritating anyone’s allergies. Each case is refillable, and the erasers come as a pack of three! Just imagine how long an investment in these quality erasers will serve you.

Here are some other products we recommend from Pentel:

The Pentel RSVP Ballpoint Pen
The Pentel EnerGel Alloy RT Gel Pen
The Pentel Sharp Kerry Automatic Pencil
The Pentel Color Pen Set
The Pentel Arts Color Pencils

If this isn’t quite right, then, by all means, explore the whole world of products from Pentel!

Get the Best Pencil Eraser of 2018!

We made it to the end! Phew! It was fun while it lasted, but we’ve taught you everything you need to know so you can make your purchase.

Our Top Choice

Prismacolor Scholar Eraser

Best Value

BIC Assorted Erasers with Grip

Dixon Pencil Shaped Erasers

Staedtler Mars Plastic Erasers

Pentel Clic Eraser Grip