Best Pencil Eyeliner Reviews 2018

They say that the eyes are the window to the soul – what do your eyes say about you? If you want to shed years, perk up after a night out, or add a touch of definition that will make you irresistible, all you need is a little pencil eyeliner. The market has some of the best pencil eyeliner brands, but it is also flooded with numerous cheap offers too so finding the best one can prove to be tough. Not to worry, the options are endless with the five eyeliner pencils included in this review!
Overview
PROS
CONS
SPECS
Style
Colors
Good for
Size
Extras
Our Top Choice
Italia Eyeliners Set of 12
Italia Deluxe is an up-and-coming makeup brand known for their eye and lip products, such as this Italia Eyeliners Set of 12.
Includes 12 colors. Bright, metallic shades. Pencil style. Easy to apply. Smudge for a smoky look. Long lasting.
Bleeds easily.
Pencil eyeliner
12 metallic shades
Good for lining eyes
7 inches
Ultra fine tip
Best Value
Maybelline Unstoppable Eye Pencil
Maybelline New York, a division of L’Oreal, was founded in 1915. They’ve launched several renowned products since, including this Maybelline New York Unstoppable Eyeliner Pencil.
Comes in 5 colors. Waterproof. Smudge-resistant. Mechanical style. Easy to use. Ideal for thick or thin lines. Long lasting.
Isolated issues with bleeding. Tip can be fragile.
Mechanical eyeliner
5 shades
Upper and lower lash lines
5.6 inches
Waterproof
NYX Slim Eye Pencil
NYX Cosmetics is a favorite among industry experts! Their products are affordable, available in most drugstores and are very fine quality, including this NYX Slim Eye Pencil set.
Pencil-style eyeliner. Includes 40 colors, 9 of which are glitter pencils. Comes with 2 free eyeliners and sharpener. Perfect color for any outfit or mood.
Some colors are only slightly pigmented.
Pencil eyeliner
40 shades
Good for lining eyes
5 inches
Includes pencil sharpener
L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Liner
L'Oreal Paris is a popular American drugstore makeup brand that produces a variety of beauty products, such as the L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Liner.
3 colors. Rich, intense lines. Kajal-inspired. Steep, conal shape is perfect for striking looks. Sharpener included. Easy to blend. Perfect for smoky eye styles.
Smudges easily.
Pencil eyeliner
Black, brown, grey
Good for lining eyes
3 inches
Includes pencil sharpener
Almay Intense I-Color Defining Liner
Almay is an iconic American brand known for its hypoallergenic products that enhance a woman’s natural beauty, like the Almay Intense I-Color Defining Liner.
4 shades. Dual-ended pencil eyeliner. Built-in sponge for smudging. Formula features iridescent shimmer for added beauty.
Some women dislike the pearl finish.
Pencil eyeliner
4 shades
Good for lining eyes
5.8 inches
Built-in smudger

(Updated )
Related Reviews
Best Gel Eyeliner
Best Liquid Eyeliner
Best Bronzer
Best Tinted Moisturizer

How Do I Choose the Best Pencil Eyeliner?

If you want to stand out, you need to have something to bring that uniqueness home. Well, forget the adventurous clothes or exaggerated colognes, adding a little eye contour for an aesthetic effect is all you have to do. Whether you want to change the natural shape of your eyes, thicken your eyelashes, or merely attain smaller or wider looking eyes, all you need is this little magic. This can be easier than you think; just keep an eye on several factors.

Eyeliners come in a wide range of colors and forms. This diversity can be confusing if you are new to the world of makeup. You need to understand the three distinct types, which include liquid, pencil and gel. Eyeliner pencils can come in two forms, the mechanical twist pencil or the hard pencil. If you are only starting out, pencil eyeliner makes a good option as it is easy to apply and not as costly too.

Besides, this eyeliner is usually easy to control, which makes it the right tool for novice users who have a lot to learn, and you can still get that natural look. What’s more, you don’t have to struggle to match it with your eyeshadow or any other makeup. It is also important to consider going for the one with an inbuilt smudger for efficiency, but getting a smudge-resistant or waterproof one could go a long way too.

Also, remember that you will need to have a sharp eyeliner for ease of use. This means if you can find the one that comes with a sharpener, then you need to make the most of it to attain the best results possible. After all, what will be the point of having useless eyeliner in your cosmetic bag?

The other thing you cannot miss is the fact that this eyeliner is easy to remove. If you do not like the result, you can always do it all over for more precision. However, remember to have your makeup magnification mirror handy to ensure things do not get messy when applying your makeup.

You should check our review to decide the best eyeliner for your needs, but make sure to look through the features first.
Price
When you factor in the efficiency that you can enjoy with eyeliner, you will notice that most of these products are reasonably priced. Anywhere from $5 to $100 is what it will cost you to get a decent eyeliner. This is most likely within your budget. But if you are ready to spend more, you can get a higher quality one for more.

The one crucial thing you need to keep in mind is the fact that most eyeliner prices will come down to the features that it comes with and what it is made from. If you want eyeliner with waterproof and smudge-resistant properties, then you will need to spend more for it. Similarly, when you set out to get one that comes with a sharpener or inbuilt smudger, then the price will shoot higher too.

Above all, the brand that you want to go for could mean all the difference in the price. For instance, if you have your eyes on the brand that everyone in the market is going for, quality will be a guarantee, but at a higher cost.

The other essential thing to consider is keeping away from most cheap pencil eyeliner offers in the market. These can be enticing with low-cost offers, but such products are not ideal for you. If you don’t want to waste your money on junk that does not have essential features like waterproof and smudge-resistance properties, then avoid such eyeliners.
Features
If you want to find the right eyeliner out there, you need to be keen on the features. Getting the features may make the difference between wasting your money on a cheap product and walking away with the one everybody will want to own.

If you are looking for the best eyeliner out there, you need to look at several factors:
  • Type – Eyeliners can come in either mechanical kind or the hard pencil option. The best part is that both options are a great deal to go for; it all comes down to your preference.
  • Color Shades – When it comes to this feature, you will have a broad range of options for your choice. Some eyeliners have three shades, others come in four shades, but you can also find others with more shades, from 5, 12, even up to 40 shades. If you are looking into a frequent change of the tone, you can always go for the eyeliner that works best for your needs.
  • Uses – Eyeliners can suffice for different purposes depending on the one you want. Some are ideal for lining eyes, others work best with upper or lower lash lines, and the market has all you need for these uses. The type of eyeliner you need depends on the kind of application you have for it.
  • Size – Most eyeliners come in different features, especially the several specs that these products offer. Some are three inches, others four or five inches, and some come in at seven inches. The best choice to go for here comes down to the size of the eyeliner that will be sufficient for your needs.
  • Additional Features – Other features you will find in most eyeliners are ultra-excellent tips, waterproof capabilities, and pencil sharpeners. What’s more, others have built-in smudgers that offer additional convenience of using your eyeliner. You can always get more with your eyeliner if you know where to look to get the right one for your needs.
Construction and Design
When choosing your eyeliner, one of the things you need to check out is the way it is tailored. This aspect goes a long way in ensuring you get the right one to cater to your needs. Well, virtually any eyeliner will have something to capture your attention, but there are several important things.

Pencil vs. Mechanical

The first thing you will notice about these products is that there can be two significant variations. Some are designed as pencils, while others are mechanical, but both offer the much-needed reliability you would look for in an eyeliner. Perhaps the best part is that this type of eyeliner outsmarts the other models by far, with advantages that favor both seasoned users and beginners alike.

Colors

This feature could differ significantly in different eyeliner types. Some of these products can come with only a few color shades, while others could include as many as up to 40 shades of color. Make sure to select your preferred eyeliner depending on your skin tone and the color of your eyes as well. The black one is mostly the standard option, but you can look for the colors that will work better for you.

Waterproof

The other thing you cannot afford to miss when selecting the right eyeliner is the issue of durability. If this is what you are looking for, going for a waterproof one will help you find an option that will last you for long enough to get a good return on your money. Not all eyeliners out there are waterproof, so make sure to check well to get the real deal. The good news is that most of these products on the market come with this feature, so you will most likely find the best one for your preference.

Smudge-resistant

Making the perfect choice for your eyeliner may turn out to be quite tricky, but locating a smudge-resistant eyeliner shouldn’t be too difficult. Many types of eyeliner come with this feature, and others even have an inbuilt smudger. All you need to do is be keen to locate the right one with this crucial feature. This could be far-reaching when it comes to getting the best out of your eyeliner.
Performance and Ease of Use
As much as any eyeliner may look like the best option to go for, you need to make sure you find just the right one that can get the job done. Eyeliners are hands down one of the best decisions to make when seeking to venture into the makeup world, and this is all thanks to several factors.

Ease-of-use

The first thing to be reckoned with about this type of eyeliner is the fact that it is super easy to use. Applying this makeup will take you no time, whether you are a novice or pro in using eyeliners. Most eyeliners are easy to erase as well. This aspect makes the pencil eyeliner one of the best options for starters, and some seasoned users cannot get over it.

Long Lasting

When you apply your eyeliner as you leave home, you need to have one that can hold up until the time you will be back. With today’s busy life, you might not get the time to apply makeup amid meetings and tight assignments. Well, pencil eyeliner is built to last long, so you can go about your daily business without worrying about your eyeliner becoming distorted in the middle of the day.

Sharpeners

When it comes to using your eyeliner, you need to have a well-sharpened one handy. There is a catch; most eyeliner types are as easy to sharpen as they are to use. Better yet, some of these products come with sharpeners, so you do not have to spend more in purchasing a sharpener separately. All you need to do is some keen research when shopping for your eyeliner to get the right one. You’re very lucky because the market has many ideal options for you.

Versatility

Drawing eye lines can be different depending on one’s preference or face. Some people consider thin lines while others like the thick ones. Well, most eyeliner types are built to cater to this kind of use. Whether you like the small or thick lines, these liners will always have something for your needs. Besides, eyeliners work pretty well with different facial colors. Eyeliners have something for people with dark skin and something for people with fair skin. Options are available for everyone.

What is the Best Pencil Eyeliner?

The biggest decision to consider when purchasing an eyeliner pencil is whether you prefer a mechanical or pencil style. The pencil type, on one hand, requires regular sharpening, but the trade-off is that it’s easier to achieve a super sharp point – perfect for winged or very thin eyeliner styles. Mechanical pencil eyeliners, meanwhile, are less likely to dry out and are easy to use. Now that you are well-informed on the features to look out for, let’s jump into our review.
Our Top Choice
This Italia Eyeliners Set of 12 is a great all-in-one pencil eyeliner kit featuring a dozen beautiful, vivid shades. However, if you prefer the classic black eyeliner, why not take a look at Italia’s 5 Piece Black Eye and Lip Liner Set?
Italia 12 Pack Eyeliners – Includes 12 Metallic, Vivid Colors

Italia Pencil Eyeliner Set of 12


Features
Italia Deluxe may not be a widely known brand, but it’s a favorite among professional makeup artists. Their products are competitively priced, good quality and they offer a lot of really unique items in hard-to-find colors, especially neons, pastels and shades with glitter.

The Italia Eyeliners Set of 12 was an obvious choice for our Top Product category because, for about $13.00, you receive one dozen beautiful eyeliner pencils. Each pack includes one of the following colors: Neon Blue, Violet, Light Brown, Gold, Sky Teal, Lavender, Royal Blue, Roba, Black, Green, Forest Green and White.

Italia markets this set as “ultra fine eye liners.” We found truth in this statement – each pencil arrives with a super sharp point and ready for use. They are easy to sharpen with a regular pencil sharpener, so you can always count on that great point that is integral to flawless eyeliner application.

Since the Italia Eyeliners Set of 12 includes so many different colors, this would be a great product for a professional makeup artist or someone that enjoys trying new styles.
Best Value
The Maybelline New York Unstoppable Eyeliner Pencil comes in 5 dazzling shades that will make your eyes pop. Now, we all know those brows need some attention too, so why not kill two birds with one stone and get the Expert Wear Twin Brow and Eye Pencil? There’s 5 colors to choose from, so you can match your eyebrows perfectly.
Maybelline New York Unstoppable Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil – Available in 7 Colors

Maybelline New York Pencil Eyeliner 041554513493 - Onyx


Features
Maybelline New York offers a comprehensive line of beauty products ranging from mascara and eyeliner to foundation, concealer, brow pencils and much more. Maybelline New York’s eyeliner line is a favorite among beauty aficionados due to their low prices, professional quality and huge selection of products. Since their products are as unique and varied as the people who wear them, it’s really easy to find the exact style and color you’re looking for.

We chose the Maybelline New York Unstoppable Eyeliner Pencil as our Best Value Choice because it is a great, straight-forward mechanical eyeliner pencil. It retails for about $7.25, though we saw it for less on Amazon. This product is available in 5 shades: Sapphire, Onyx, Pewter, Espresso and Batiste Black.

This is also our Top Choice for mechanical pencil eyeliners. It is super easy to apply since you can just turn the base to push up more product. Plus, it stays put for hours and is water-resistant. This is the perfect eyeliner pencil to apply in the morning and toss in your purse for touch-ups throughout the day.
This NYX Slim Eye Pencil set features more than 40 different products, making it the motherlode of all eyeliner pencils! If you’re a bit overwhelmed by the thought of owner 40 eye liner pencils, don’t worry. Why not try the Mechanical Eye Pencil, which has 16 Colors to choose from!
NYX Cosmetics Slim Pencil Eyeliner 40Pc – Includes 9 Glitter Eyeliners & 2 in 1 Pencil Sharpener

NYX Pencil Eyeliner Slim – 40Pc


Features
NYX Cosmetics, which earned its name for the Greek goddess of night, is one of the beauty industry’s hidden gems. They design and sell a full range of beauty products that are suitable for professional use yet available for drugstore prices. Based in Los Angeles, NYC is a global company that distributes its products in more than 70 countries.

This NYX Slim Eye Pencil set is the ultimate haul for any beauty maven! At $110, it is a little costlier than some other products in this category – but NYX makes it well worth the extra cash! This incredible line comes with 40 eyeliner pencils, each in a different enchanting shade. As a bonus, they also throw in a free eyeliner pencil sharpener and 2 free pencils! This is an amazing value and would give you literally every color under the sun for your collection.

The set includes 31 regular eyeliner pencils plus 9 glitter pencils. They are as follows: 24 Karat, Acid Green, Aqua Glitter, Auburn, Baby Blue, Baby Pink, Black, Black Brown, Black Glitter, Brown, Café, Charcoal, Copper, Crystal Glitter, Dark Brown, Electric Blue, Emerald City, Gold, Gold Glitter, Gray, Green Glitter, Lavender Glitter, Light Brown, Lime Green, Medium Brown, Moss, Purple, Sapphire, Satin Blue, Seafoam Green, Silver, Silver Glitter, Sky Glitter, Taupe, Teal, Velvet, White, White Pearl and Yellow.
Love smoky eyes? The L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Liner is a great kajal-inspired pencil liner. However, if you prefer the mechanical eyeliners, take a look at the L'Oreal Paris Infallible Never Fail Eyeliner instead. Never worry about a broken eye pencil, sharpening or when they always get just that bit too pointy after sharpening and end up poking your eye out! Win-win!
L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner – Available in 3 Colors

L’Oreal Paris Pencil Eyeliner 071249207048 - Grey


Features
L'Oreal Paris is known worldwide for its affordable beauty and hair care products. Widely considered to one of the best drugstore makeup brands in the US, L’Oreal Paris is renowned for its huge selection of highly pigmented, luxurious makeup products.

L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Liner is a fan favorite. For about $7.15, you receive one pencil eyeliner and a custom sharpener. It is available in Grey, Brown and Black. The L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Liner is inspired by kajal – also known as kohl – which has been a staple beauty product for women in India, Egypt and the Middle East for hundreds, if not thousands, of years.

This liner is shorter and stockier than the other products included in this review. Another differentiating feature is its conal tip. These factors combined create a unique pencil eyeliner that is easy to hold and apply in virtually any style you can think of. We were also impressed with its rich, creamy formula, which lends itself to sultry smudges and protects the delicate eye area during application.
The Almay Intense I-Color Defining Liner is an all-in-one pencil eyeliner and smudging tool designed for brown, blue, hazel or green eyes. If you’re looking for more color options, and a mechanical eye pencil, why not try the Almay Intense I-Color Eyeliner and choose from their 7 color options.
Almay Intense I-Color Defining Liner – Available in 4 Scents

Almay Pencil Eyeliner 4075-03 – For Hazel Eyes


Features
Almay is a top drugstore makeup brand that has built a reputation for its hypoallergenic products and emphasis on American manufacturing. 100% of its products are designed, tested and produced in the USA. One of the brand’s pillars is natural beauty, meaning that many of their products are designed to enhance the natural beauty of a person.

Almay transformed the beauty industry with the launch of its Intense I-Color line. Designed with the consumer in mind, this line is marketed by the eye color it is designed for rather than the shades it comes in. The idea is that some colors are better suited for one eye color than another. Greens, for example, may enhance hazel eyes better than brown eyes.

The Almay Intense I-Color Defining Liner retails for about $8.35. It features a convenient double-ended design, one end with a pencil eyeliner and the other with a small smudging sponge. It is available in four different colors based on the following eye colors: blue, brown, hazel and green. You can, of course, choose to purchase any color that your heart desires regardless of your eye color. We, however, think that this is a great feature because it takes the guesswork out of picking the right beauty product for your coloring.

In line with Almay’s core methodology, this product is hypoallergenic, tested by an ophthalmologist and designed for sensitive skin and eyes.

Get the Best Pencil Eyeliner of 2018!

Ready to hit the town? Pick up any of the five pencil eyeliners included in this review to complete your look! But if you were unable to find the one eyeliner you want the most, all you need to do is just browse our recommended brands for more options. Finding the best pencil eyeliner does not have to be difficult now that you know where to look. Enjoy your new look!

Our Top Choice
Italia Eyeliners Set of 12
Best Value
Maybelline Unstoppable Eye Pencil
NYX Slim Eye Pencil
L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Liner
Almay Intense I-Color Defining Liner