Best Pie Pan Reviews 2018

Are you looking to buy your first pie pan or simply want to replace your old baking plate? Since the market is flooded with pie plates from hundreds of brands, all claiming to be the best, choosing a good plate can be a nightmare. That’s why we’ve researched the best pie pan brands on the market, showcasing one from each of our top five, to help you make an informed buying decision.
Overview
PROS
CONS
SPECS
Size
Material
Lid
Care
Pack Size
Our Top Choice
Pyrex Portables Pie Carrier & Plate
Pyrex is a leading manufacturer of high-quality kitchenware such as glassware, mixers and storage solutions, among others.
Non-porous glass. Dishwasher safe. Prevents warping and staining. USA-made and doesn’t absorb bad odors. Versatile and heavy duty. Bakes evenly and has high heat tolerance.
Carrier isn’t deep enough for a heavy-filling pie. One size pie pan.
9 inches
Plastic and glass
Lid with handle
Dishwasher safe
One plate
Best Value
Norpro Nonstick Mini Pie Pans
Norpro is an innovative company founded in 1973 to manufacture high-quality kitchenware such as pots, knives and grills, among others.
Lightweight for easy use. Versatile to prepare various pies. Non-stick surface for effortless release. Easy to clean and care for. Steel construction for durability.
Low pie pan capacity of one cup to make mini pies
5 inches
Steel
No lid
Hand wash only
Pack of four
Nordic Ware High Dome Covered Pie Pan
Founded in 1946, Nordic Ware is a leading manufacturer of premium cookware, kitchenware, bakeware, microwaves and outdoor cooking gear.
Superior heat conductivity. Steel reinforcement. Warp- and rust-free use. Promotes even distribution of heat. Lightweight and durable. Easy to clean and care for.
Preferred for holding pies instead of baking.
10 inches
Natural aluminum
With lid
Hand wash only
One plate
Wilton Whoopie Pie Baking Pan
Founded in 1929, Wilton is a company with a focus on making baking fun and easy by manufacturing innovative bakeware and kitchen products.
Dishwasher safe and easy to clean. Multiple cavities for mini pies.
Ridges on cavities harbor food.
Mini muffins or pies
Steel
No lid
Dishwasher safe
One plate with 24 cavities
Fat Daddio's Aluminum Pie Pan
Fat Daddio’s is a company of professional bakers and home enthusiasts who design and develop premium bakeware and decorating tools.
Straight sides for even cooking. Versatile for different applications. Provides professionals with great results. Anodized aluminum is durable.
Not scratch proof.
10 inches
Anodized aluminum
No lid
Hand wash only
One plate

(Updated )
Related Reviews
Best Cake Decorating Set
Best Cake Knife
Best Au Gratin Pan
Best Bundt Pan
Watch Our Pie Pan Review

How Do I Choose the Best Pie Pan?

If you enjoy baking or own a pastry shop, then you know the importance of investing in pie pans. Just like a cake pan, they ease the process of making delicious pies. A good pan for making pies is essential, as it can make your pies crispy. The plates are made of materials such as steel and aluminum for even heat distribution through the pie to the very bottom. If you want to make a crispy pie, chill it in the freezer first so the butter cools.

The best pie pans can be taken from the freezer and used directly in the oven without them breaking. The materials pie plates are made of allow them to absorb heat evenly and cool quickly. Pie pans are also versatile items in the kitchen and can be used for other purposes, such as baking cakes. The edges of the plates are serrated or fluted so the pies you bake can look fancy and really appetizing.

With a pie pan, you take the guess work off your pie preparation and baking process. They’re constructed with various diameters and depth measurements to ensure the pies you make are of your chosen size. The plates can also allow you to easily follow any given recipe with recommended timing so your pies come out cooked as expected.

Made of non-reactive materials, pie plates ensure your food is always safe and non-toxic. As a bonus, they’re made in different styles and come in multiple finishes to add life and fun to your kitchen and baking experience. This is a review of various pie pan brands and we hope you’ll find the guide resourceful in your decision-making process.
Price
The material used, size and style of a pie pan can influence what you pay for one. For instance, large pans cost more than their smaller counterparts. Although these baking plates are generally not pricey, their addition to your kitchen is absolutely important. Therefore, it’s important to pick a good pan that’s both functional and attractive for the pies you intend to make.

Cheap pie pans are mostly tin foil pans meant for single use only and might not withstand the weight of pie fillings. If you’re a regular baker, you need a plate you can rely on each time you need to bake. Go for quality and consider plates being sold in packs to get good bargains. You’ll find a good pie pan in the price range of $5 to $50, depending on the factors mentioned above.
Features
The most important feature of pie pans is the material used to make them. It determines how well a pan can distribute heat to enable thorough and even cooking of the pie on all sides. Also choose size based on how large or small you want your pies to be. Consider one large plate for a big pie that can serve your entire family or a plate with cavities if you prefer mini pies.

Here are some of the features to look out for in a pie pan:
  • The diameter of the pan to determine the size of your pies
  • The material used, such as steel, anodized aluminum, etc.
  • The depth of the pan, based on how thick your want your pies to be
  • Non-stick surface for quick release and easy cleaning
  • Stain and odor-resistant properties
  • Contoured edges for a good-looking pie
  • Handles for easy carrying
  • Lid for covering the pie while in transit
With the right pie plate, you’ll be able to cook the right size and depth of pie to serve your friends, guests or family whenever you bake your favorite delicacies.
Construction and Design
Shopping for a pie plate? Whether you’re a newbie or professional baker, these factors will help you choose the best pan for your given needs:

Size

Pie pans come in different sizes that determine their diameter, depth and weight. Most pans are 9 to 9.5 inches in diameter. The depth of a pan varies from one plate to another, but most people prefer shallow pans so the pie can cook quickly and evenly at the bottom. The weight of a pan is mostly determined by the material it’s made of. Ceramic, burgundy clay and cast iron plates are usually heavy, while those made of aluminum are light.

Material

There are many materials used to make pie pans, such as ceramic, clay, cast iron, glass and aluminum. For the heavy materials such as clay and ceramics, the pie might take long to cook and not have a crispy, brown crust. This is attributed to the fact that these materials conduct heat slowly. Lightweight materials such as aluminum and glass conduct heat quickly, giving your pie a crispy and well-browned crust.

Glass can allow you to peek at the bottom of your pie if you want to see whether it’s as brown and crispy as you want it. The best material is one that conducts heat evenly and quickly, atop being non-reactive and non-toxic. The materials are usually given a non-stick, stain-resistant and odor-resistant glaze so the pie you make comes out whole and fresh.

Lid

If you want a pan that’ll make it easy for you to store your pie hygienically and carry it around, find one with a lid. A lid allows you to cover your pie so it doesn’t collect dust or become contaminated, for instance, if you want to take it to a picnic.

Care

Just as with any other kitchen utensil, hygiene is important. Find a pie pan with a finish that’s stain and odor resistant, and easy to clean. Also, pie plates are either dishwasher safe or can easily be cleaned by hand so the cleaning is thorough.

Pack Size

Pie pans might also come as packs containing a number of plates. Since tin foil pans are disposable, they mostly come in large packs. On the other hand, durable pans come in packs with one, two or three plates. The more pans you get in a pack, the better value for your money.
Performance and Ease of Use
Pie pans come with contoured edges to ensure the pie you bake looks beautiful, professional and appetizing. Some also come with handles so you can easily carry your pie out of the oven or even outside your house. The finish on the pie pans is non-stick, ensuring you can get your baked pie out of the pan without any portion of the pie sticking to it or breaking the pie open.

You can also easily cut and serve your pie on a shallow plate using a pie server or pie knife. Your pie pan will require thorough cleaning either by hand or using a dishwasher to ensure it’s ready for storage or the next use. Finally, make sure the material your pan is made of isn’t just durable, but supports even heat distribution so your pie cooks evenly.

What is the Best Pie Pan?

Choose a pie pan with non-stick surface for quick release and easy cleaning. Make sure it’s of the right size to bake pies of your desired depth and diameter. Find out if one of our recommended pie plates is what you want.
Our Top Choice
The Pyrex Portables Pie Carrier & 9-Inch Pie Plate are made of BPA-free materials to keep your food safe from harmful chemicals and contaminants. Opt for the Pyrex Watercolor Collection Pie Plate if you’re looking for a dish in a different design and finish, available at a lower cost.
Pyrex Portables Pie Carrier with 9-Inch Pie Plate with a 2 Year Warranty - Available in 2 Pack Options

Pyrex Pie Pan 1087999 – Pack of One


Features
Pyrex is focused on manufacturing durable kitchenware. The company sources high-quality materials from around the world to make innovative and safe products. It invests in R&D to continuously enhance its products for more functionality and aesthetics. It has a large team of employees who aren’t just experienced in their given work areas, but also enjoy what they do. Customer satisfaction and safety are of utmost importance to the company.

The Pyrex Portables Pie Carrier & 9-Inch Pie Plate are available in one and two-pack options. They’re versatile for use in microwaves, pre-heated ovens and fridges. Since they’re made of BPA-free materials, you’re guaranteed to consume safe and healthy pies. What’s more, the pie plate is made of non-porous glass. This makes the pan warp-free, non-absorbent to odors and stain repellent.

Caring for the pie pan is also easy. After use, simply place it on the top rack of your dishwasher for fast and easy cleaning. Made in the USA, this is a pie plate and cover you can trust and rely on each time you need to use it. Furthermore, it’s backed by a two-year warranty to protect you from manufacturing faults. When cooking your pie, you don’t have to worry about it sticking to the glass plate because it’s non-stick. You can also use it to store, transport and serve your pie, as it has a handle for easy carrying.

Here are a few other Pyrex pie pans you might like:
  • Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate - same size, different design
  • Pyrex Bakeware Scalloped Pie Plate - clear, 9.5 inches
  • Pyrex Vintage Pie Plate - with clear, fluted edge handles
Best Value
The Norpro Nonstick 4-Pack Pie Pans are made of steel for durable use and have a non-stick surface for quick food release. If you prefer one large pie plate measuring nine inches instead of the four mini pans, opt for the Norpro Stainless Steel Pie Pan with a shiny mirror finish.
Norpro Nonstick Mini Pie Pans - Available in Steel 4-Pack or Black 8-Pack

Norpro Pie Pans 3911 - Steel, 4-Pack


Features
Norpro is renowned for its quality assurance standards and products made to last. The company has a large selection of kitchen products to choose from. Whether you’re looking for colanders, bakeware, cutting tools or cookware, the company has you covered. The company also offers information on recipes and ideas of how to best take advantage of its products to prepare delicious meals. It also gives information on how to care for each product in its product portfolio for durable use.

The Norpro Nonstick 4-Pack Pie Pans are four similar plates for baking pies and cakes. Each measuring five inches in diameter, the plates are ideal for making mini pies. Made of steel, the pans are strong and durable to support long-term use. They have non-stick surfaces for effortless food release and easy cleaning. It also allows you to use little to no fats when baking for healthy dishes.

The pans are 1.23 inches deep to accommodate high pies with fillings. Caring for your set of plates has never been easier. Use your favorite gentle dish soap with a soft pad to hand wash the plates. It’s not recommended to use a dishwasher, as it can damage the non-stick surface of the pie pans. With the four plates, you won’t just be able to bake various pies or cakes, but also enough for work or school in the right portions.

Here are a few other pie plates by Norpro to consider:
  • Norpro Tin Pie Pan - set of four, made of tin
  • Norpro Mini Nonstick Pie Pans with Pie Top Cutters - black
  • Norpro Stainless Steel Pie Pan - 9 inches
The Nordic Ware High Dome Covered Pie Pan is made of natural and pure aluminum for rust-free use and even cooking. Do you prefer a pie plate in a trend-setting design and made of aluminized steel? Opt for the Nordic Ware Patterned Pie Pan with non-stick surface and no lid.
Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum High Dome Covered Pie Pan with Reinforced Steel Rim

Nordic Ware Pie Pan 44103AMZ


Features
Nordic Ware has been in the industry for decades, serving millions of customers worldwide. The company understands what both commercial and home cooks look for in their cookware and utensils. It then designs innovative and highly functional products with a stylish touch for every kitchen out there. It uses safe and strong materials to manufacture items that can last a lifetime. It also tests its products for safety and quality before releasing them onto the market.

The Nordic Ware High Dome Covered Pie Pan is constructed from natural aluminum for its great properties. The metal doesn’t rust and you can be sure your pie plate will last for a really long time. Since aluminum is a superior heat conductor, your pie or cake will rise and bake evenly. With steel rim reinforcement, the pan doesn’t warp easily, for increased strength and durability.

However, the pan isn’t dishwasher safe due to potential for discoloration. Only hand wash is recommended. Use a soft pad to easily wash it without scratching its surface. Measuring 13 x 11.25 x 4 inches outside and 10 x 10 x 1.75 inches inside, the plate is large enough to accommodate a big pie for the whole family. Made in the USA, this pie pan by Nordic Ware comes with a lifetime warranty to protect you from manufacturing faults.

Here are a few other pie pans by Nordic Ware you might like:
  • Nordic Ware 6-Cavity Pie Baking Pan - mini sizes
  • Nordic Ware Pie Bakers Kit – pan with lid and accessories
The Wilton Mini Whoopie Pie Baking Pan has 24 cavities to accommodate mini pies or cakes. Prefer a deep pie pan made of heavy-duty steel to make one large pie? Opt for the Wilton Excelle Elite Deep Pie Pan with oversized handles for easy use.
Wilton Nonstick 24-Cavity Whoopie Pie Pan with a Recipe Booklet - Available in 3 Sizes

Wilton Pie Pan 2105-0478 - Mini


Features
Wilton manufactures innovative kitchen products and inspires creativity in people worldwide. The company focuses on cookie and candy making, baking, kitchen and seasonal products, cake baking and decorating and party gear. It allows everyone to use stylishly designed products to explore their creativity and create special end products. It also helps people create amazing party desserts and decorate cakes using unique products.

The Wilton Mini Whoopie Pie Baking Pan features 24 cavities to enable you to make mini pies for your small party, kids, friends or the whole family. Whether you want to use all the cavities or just some of them for your whoopie pies, the pan won’t let you down. Made of aluminized steel, the plate has a strong construction to support long-term use. Take advantage of the recipe booklet included for more ideas of the pies you can make using your pan.

After use, simply use your dishwasher to clean the plate. You can also use your hands if you don’t own a dishwasher or just don’t want to use it, but ensure you use a soft pad or sponge for the cleaning. The non-stick coating on the surface allows easy cleaning and quick food release. With ten years warranty, you don’t have to worry about your pan failing to work. The warranty offers protection from manufacturing faults. The pie plate is available in three sizes: mini, standard and jumbo.

Here are a few other Wilton pie plates for your consideration:
  • Wilton Perfect Results Nonstick Pie Pan - 9 inches
  • Wilton Decorative Crust Pie Pan - decorative
  • Wilton Recipe Right Pie Pan - different design, 9 inches
The Fat Daddio’s Anodized Aluminum Pie Pan supports even heat distribution and baking for consistent results. However, you can opt for the Fat Daddio’s Anodized Aluminum Round Cake Pan if you want a plate that’s two inches deeper and available in 45 sizes.
Fat Daddio’s Anodized Aluminum Pie Pan with a Lifetime Warranty - Available in 6 Sizes

Fat Daddio’s Pie Pan PIE-10 - 10 Inches


Features
Fat Daddio’s is a company made up of semi and completely professional bakers and home enthusiasts. This allows it to know what customers with similar interests look for in their products. The company designs products that make every baking moment a time to celebrate and try out various recipes. Customers can enjoy each moment dedicated to baking. It invests in research and development to create commercial products with capacity for high-volume orders. Whether you want anodized bakeware, decorating tools or fondants, the company has you covered.

The Fat Daddio’s Anodized Aluminum Pie Pan is made of a strong metal for durability. It measures 10 x 1.5 inches to accommodate a large pie. Available in six sizes, the other pie plates are also 1.5 inches deep, despite having different diameters. The plate is also versatile for other uses, such as baking cakes and other desserts or delicacies. Aluminum heats fast and evenly to ensure your pie cooks evenly. It also cools quickly.

The plate has a temperature rating of 5500 F, making it safe for use in preheated ovens. What’s more, they neither react to acidic foods and fillings nor rust. With the straight sides, you can bake even pies with professional looks each time, while supporting stack tiers. The plate can also be used to carve cakes meant for decoration. However, only hand washing is recommended for cleaning the pan. You have six sizes to choose from: four, six, nine, ten, eleven and twelve inches.

Get the Best Pie Pan of 2018!

Whether you’re looking for a pie pan for your home baking needs, bakery or restaurant business, or want to give one out as a gift, there’s one out there for you. We hope this guide was helpful and you were able to find a good pie pan. If you need something different, check out our other cake pan reviews.

Our Top Choice
Pyrex Portables Pie Carrier & Plate
Best Value
Norpro Nonstick Mini Pie Pans
Nordic Ware High Dome Covered Pie Pan
Wilton Whoopie Pie Baking Pan
Fat Daddio's Aluminum Pie Pan