Best Pizza Peel Reviews 2021

Everyone wants to bake a pizza that will be irresistible, crispy and tasty. To bake the perfect pizza without a charred underside, you need to have some means of popping the pizza into the hot oven or putting it on a pizza stone. This is where the pizza peel comes into the picture. There are many different types and qualities of pizza peels, so picking the right one may prove tedious. To make your choice easier, we searched extensively and identified some of the best pizza peel brands. Though we have only featured one product from each brand, these brands still have a lot of other top quality pizza peels; you can check them out too.

TopProducts may earn commissions when you purchase through links on our site. Learn More.

Overview

PROS

CONS

SPECS

Material

Size(s)

Weight

Convenience

Care

Our Top Choice

Pizzacraft Folding Pizza Peel

Trusted by many cooks, Pizza Craft has been manufacturing high quality products used in making pizzas. Its pizza peels help to bring out the best in every pizza made.

This pizza peel has a removable, foldable wooden handle. So not only can you remove the handle when you wash it, you also get to fold the handle which makes storing a lot easier.

It can’t be used for really large pizzas as it is a moderately sized peel.

Stainless Steel&Hardwood Handle

2.4 x 9.8 x 27.3 inches

1.8lbs

Folding wooden handle

Hand wash; NOT dishwasher safe

Best Value

American Metalcraft Aluminum Pizza Peel

For more than 50 years, American Metalcraft has been producing products that are ranked very highly worldwide.

It is easy to care for and you never have to worry about it warping or cracking. The handle length makes it easy for the pizza to be put in or removed from the oven.

It has sharp corners which could be dangerous for users.

Stainless Steel

39 x 10 x 10 inches

1.0lbs

Tapered edges

Info NOT provided

EXO Super Peel Pizza Peel

Exo is a very successful and innovative brand and its creations, like its pizza peels, are always unique and functional.

It is coated with a food-safe polymer seal for better function and care. The sliding cloth is a really good innovation that prevents the pizza from sticking to the peel.

It is too thick, therefore it can make a mess of the pizza when picking it up.

Wood

24 x 14 x 0.5 inches

2.5lbs

Conveyor belt

Food safe polymer reduces care

New Star Foodservice Wooden Pizza Peel

New Star Foodservice is a brand that ensures class and creativity in all its products.

It has a long handle for easy handling with a tapered edge design which makes it easier for the pizza to slide onto it.

It is NOT suitable for large pizzas.

Birchwood

44 x 24 x 1 inches

2.9lbs

Tapered edge

Info NOT provided

Mountain Woods Hardwood Pizza Peel

Mountain woods is known for products which are cost effective and combine beauty and efficiency.

It is easy to use and can also be used for decorating kitchen counter tops when not in use.

Its handle is a bit short.

Acacia hardwood

21.5 x 16 x 1 inches

3lbs

Beveled leading edge

Wash in soapy water & towel dry

Want to read buying guide first? Click Here

Related Reviews

Best Wood Fired Pizza Oven

in Home Products and Decor

Authentic Pizza Ovens Maximus Portable Outdoor Wood Fired Pizza Oven

Best Pizza Oven

in Home Products and Decor

Blackstone Outdoor Pizza Oven - 60,000 BTU Burner, Electric Ignition and Even Heat Distribution

Best Pizza Stone

in Home Products and Decor

Pizzacraft Perfect Pizza Grilling Stone With No Need For Seasoning Or Conditioning

Best Wine Glass Set

in Home Products and Decor

Schott Zwiesel Tritan Crystal Glass Forte Stemware Collection White Wine – Set of 6

What is the Best Pizza Peel?

The type of pizza peel you use determines how your pizza will turn out. Our buying guide highlights the factors you would need to consider before choosing a pizza peel. Since you’ve already gone through it, we trust that you know exactly what you want from a pizza peel. Come along with us to our review, which contains details of the best pizza peels in the market.

Our Top Choice

Made from stainless steel, the 10" Folding Stainless Steel Pizza Peel is very durable and can easily get under the pizza. Its wooden handle allows you to hold it firmly. If you want a pizza peel that is just as durable but is made of aluminum, you should check out the Pizzacraft Pizza Peel.

Pizzacraft Folding Pizza Peel with Folding Handle for Easy Storage – Available in 3 Styles

Features

Pizzacraft prides itself as the world standard in the manufacture of pizza-making products. For many years, its products have been made to be highly-efficient, cost-effective and durable. Its goal is to achieve superior customer satisfaction and promote growth for both itself and its customers.

The 10" Folding Stainless Steel Pizza Peel is an affordable peel that easily transfers pizza, bread, and other food in and out of an oven or grill. It is much easier to store than a lot of pizza peels since its locking handle can be turned down to save space. It is highly durable since it is made with stainless steel and quite easy to maintain since its handle can be removed when washing.

If this is not the exact pizza peel you want, Pizzacraft has many more types of pizza peels for you to check out.

Best Value

Designed to be highly durable, the American Metalcraft 3714 Pizza Peel is made of thick aluminum and has a long wooden handle which makes the peel easy to use. If you don’t want an aluminum peel and prefer a wooden peel, you should check out the American Metalcraft Wood Pizza Peel.which is also efficient.

American Metalcraft USA Aluminum Pizza Peel – Available in 2 Sizes or as a Bundle

Features

Founded in 1947, American Metalcraft ranks among the topmost tabletop supply manufacturers in the food service industry. In the years since its founding, it has expanded and has added many other premier product lines. It is now a go-to brand for most kitchen supplies. Its products are highly affordable but this does not compromise their pure quality.

The American Metalcraft Aluminum Pizza Peel is a pizza peel that is durable and affordable. Its metal peel is thick enough and the wooden handle is a good length and, being removable, it can be replaced if needed. In most peels that have wooden handles, the point where the metal meets the wood is usually a weak point but this is not a problem with the American Metalcraft Aluminum Pizza Peel which is made with a technique that avoids this problem completely.

Not yet sure? That’s okay, as American Metalcraft still has many other pizza peels for you to check out.

The EXO Super Peel Pizza Peel is a peel that is very easy to use. It is finished with high-grade cutting board oil to beautify and protect the wood. Do you want a bigger or an aluminum peel? Then you should check out the EXO BIG Super Peel Pizza Peel with Aluminum Blade and Black Cherry Handle.

EXO Wooden Polymer Sealed Super Peel Pizza Peel

Features

Exo is a brand whose main goal has been to provide high quality products to its customers. Exo looks for the best materials for the manufacturing of its products and for new ways to make its products more efficient. Today, Exo is a widely used and celebrated brand in many places all over the world.

The EXO Super Peel Pizza Peel is a unique pizza peel that is made from high quality wood. Sometimes ash, sometimes maple, its handle edges are contoured for a comfortable grip and it has a very low angle tip for easy sliding under thin dough. Its working surface is 14 inches by 14 inches which allows it to be used even for large pizza sizes.

If this is not the peel for you, Exo has other great ones you can check out.

The New Star Foodservice Wooden Pizza Peel is a peel that is slim and made from durable birchwood. Its half inch blade easily slides under the pizza. If you need a peel that is just as durable but of a smaller size, we recommend the New Star Foodservice Wooden Pizza Peeler with 14-Inch by 16-Inch Blade.

New Star Foodservice 42-Inch Wooden Pizza Peeler with 20-Inch by 22-Inch Blade

Features

New Star Foodservice is an emerging leader in the commercial kitchen supply industry. Its quality products, extensive experience with top manufacturers and professional support team give it the ability to readily meet all its customer’s needs.

The New Star Foodservice Wooden Pizza Peel is an affordable, durable peel that is perfect for lifting pizzas and cake sheets out of the oven. Its half-inch blade easily slides under the pizza. Since it is made very slim, the wood does not mess up thick pizzas. It also has a tapered edge design for ease of use.

In case you are not satisfied with this one, New Star Foodservice has other peels for you to check out.

The Mountain Woods Hardwood Pizza Peel is made of plantation-grown acacia hardwood, which is one of the best woods that can be used due to its versatility, beauty and sustainability. If this is not what you are looking for, then you should also check out the Mountain Woods 13.5" X 18" Gourmet Hardwood Pizza Peel.which is smaller in size.

Mountain Woods 13.5" X 18" Gourmet Hardwood Pizza Peel / Cutting Board / Serving Tray

Features

Mountain Woods has a 40-year long history of hand crafting home and kitchen accessories. Its dedication to the highest quality and design (with an eye on affordability) has given it wide acclaim. Mountain Woods works to do its share in keeping the environment beautiful and safe; this is why its raw materials are sourced from environmentally responsible suppliers that adhere to a sustained yield principal. Its commitment to the environment goes hand-in-hand with its commitment to its customers.

The Mountain Woods Hardwood Pizza Peel is an affordable pizza peel that has high aesthetic value. It can be used for almost all sizes of pizzas as it measures 21.25" x 16" x 0.625". It is paddle shaped, which makes it easy for pizza to balance on it. It is also durable since it is made of plantation-grown acacia hardwood.

If you are not okay with this peel, Mountain Woods has many other pizza peels which come in different colors and sizes.

How Do I Choose the Best Pizza Peel?

Preparing dishes with different recipes could prove tasking, but hey, there is such a thing as adequate planning which makes meal preparation a breeze! As a homemaker or professional, you should have fun whilst doing this, especially when the desired utensils are available. Pizza-making is one such cooking activity that is not quite complete without the pizza peel. The pizza peel is a simple, handy tool that often goes with a pizza stone and is used to scoop piping hot pizza from the oven.

Getting your pizza to be as delicious and attractive as the ones seen on TV is quite simple. It requires the right equipment to accomplish this. Pizza is made with fresh vegetables, meats, and cheeses. The pizza peel ensures that the pizza does not overcook, but comes out cooked just the way you want it. A pizza peel is built to protect your hands. It comes with a long handle and a flat base shaped like a paddle, onto which the pizza is deposited. The peel is long enough to allow the base to get to the back of the oven, leaving ample room for the handle to extend outside the interior of the oven. It is a multipurpose tool that doubles as a surface for cooling the pizza and can also be used in place of a pan. You are not set to serve you pizza or eat it immediately? No problem. The pizza peel is just the right surface to place your pies until they are ready to be consumed. Convenient? Check.

When selecting a pizza peel, some factors like the shape, blade and handle length ought to be considered. These would determine to a large extent how much enjoyment you get from your cooking. Pizza peels are crafted from different materials and you ought to know the one that suits your purpose and culinary task to make the right decision. Some are ideal for home use, whereas others are more suitable for outdoor and professional catering.

Pizza peels are portable and can be carried easily wherever you want. They are well suited for grills and outdoor ovens and come in handy when you and your friends decide to have a barbecue party. They are non-electrical appliances, so there is no chance that an explosion or power surge problem could arise from their usage. Safe? Check. It’s time to take a more detailed look at what features to look out for when choosing a pizza peel.

Price

Pizza peels come in various types and shapes. They are also categorized according to the materials they are made from, their ease of use and their versatility.

During our detailed research, we observed the price of pizza peels to be within a range of $20 to $55. With this pricing, you can easily choose a pizza peel that best suits your budget and one that fits into your cooking plans.

While there are some cheap pizza peels in the market, we chose not to consider these for the sake of this review. We discovered that most of them don’t have the desired features and durability we want to see in a pizza peel. The pizza peels we have reviewed were carefully selected from trusted brands, and any one you choose would serve you so well and leave you wondering what you could have done without it.

Features

Most pizza peels come in relatively simple designs, but some details have to be well thought out before choosing one. These features are important since they can improve or hinder your pizza-making experience, therefore should not be taken for granted. These factors include:

Shape
Material
Blade Type
Handle Length
Cleaning and Maintenance

Construction and Design

Pizza peels are of three main types: wooden, metal and composite. Here’s what they entail:

Wooden pizza peels - These are great because they prevent the pie from sticking. The material is the same as that used for some chopping boards, so it is safe to cut the pizza into desired pieces on it. The pizza can be placed in the oven without losing toppings. These peels are appealing to look at, but they are not fireproof and would show burn marks after use in a fire oven or on a grill. They are also thick and not the simplest to slide beneath the pizza crust.
Metals - As we know, metals have made cooking a lot easier since they were discovered and used for fabricating cooking utensils. Metal pizza peels are a delight to use. They are much thinner and come in a flattened design different from their wooden counterpart. They are durable and stand the test of time. Depending on your preference, these peels are available in various types. If you want a simple lifting of pizza from the oven, this type of pizza peel could be the one for you. On the flip side though, uncooked dough may get stuck to the metal pizza peel, so it is advised that some flour be sprinkled or a piece of serviette placed on it prior to use.
Composite pizza peels - These are simple to maintain, thinner than the wooden but thicker than the metal type. Their handles, however are shorter than average and could cause injury

A pizza peel should have a blade that is effective in removing and placing pizza into an oven. The thinner the peel blade, the easier it is for you to slip it beneath the pizza and pull it out.

Performance and Ease of Use

Are you a home cook or small-scale caterer who works with a small sized oven or grill and has to attend to pizza being baked just from one angle? If yes, then a pizza peel with a square head would be best for you to place and remove the pizza during baking. The square-headed peel works the pizza directly without the need for any angular maneuvering.

Professional cooks and chefs, on the other hand, can work around pizzas from different angles in a large oven, from just one door or carved opening. The square peels are not convenient for this scale of baking, hence the need for a round-headed pizza peel. This type of pizza peel easily aligns with the shape of the pizza no matter the direction from which it is inserted.

The handle length of a pizza peel is important for you to avoid injury. Ideally, it has to be long enough so that hands are 4 to 5 centimeters from the door. The length of the peel, together with the handle, should be between 26 and 40 inches approximately. Adaptable handle lengths can be seen in one of our featured products: the American MetalCraft Aluminum Pizza Peel that is available in different lengths to fit various oven types. A short handle would mean undue closeness to the pizza stone, especially when you are using a really hot oven. This may be rather clumsy especially as you check the underside, turn the dough while grilling or transfer pizza to the oven. You just may need another pizza peel to help with this.

Finding the best way and place to preserve and store your pizza peel would determine how well it would serve you for subsequent uses. Wooden pizza peels, even though they don’t get rusted, have to be washed carefully, dried and oiled to avoid smelling and to prevent mildew formation. They are not to be used in a dishwasher or soaked in detergent-infused water for any length of time, which could lead to moisture retention and rotting from within. A metal pizza peel is simple to clean -- a dry or slightly damp cloth with mild soap would do the trick! For your long-handled pizza peel, hanging on the wall may be the right option, as it may be awkward finding a place to keep it. Some peels come with foldable handles and you can keep them in a drawer or utensil rack just as you want.

Go back to the start of the reviews

Get the Best Pizza Peel of 2021!

You have gone through our reviews and now you should be able to pick the best pizza peel for your needs. Go ahead and place your order so you can start making delicious pizzas.

Our Top Choice

Pizzacraft Folding Pizza Peel

Best Value

American Metalcraft Aluminum Pizza Peel

EXO Super Peel Pizza Peel

New Star Foodservice Wooden Pizza Peel

Mountain Woods Hardwood Pizza Peel

Go back to the start of the reviews

Get exclusive content, advice, and tips from TopProducts delivered to your inbox.

About Us Scholarship Blog Categories Sitemap

TopProducts.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com