Best Roasting Pan Reviews 2018

Every modern kitchen should have a roasting pan because it’s essential in preparing multiple delicious dishes. We’ve selected five roasters from some of the best roasting pan brands out there. Take a look at our contenders and find out which one you like the most.
Overview
PROS
CONS
SPECS
Type
Size/Weight
Materials
Accessories
Washing
Our Top Choice
Cuisinart 16" Roasting Pan with Rack
Cuisinart is among the largest manufacturers of kitchen appliances. The 7117-16PS roasting pan can last for a lifetime and it is easy to cook with.
Complete package with accessories and tools. Can be bought with electric knife as well. Durable materials. Ideal for turkey.
Isolated complaints regarding shipment. This doesn’t undermine the quality of the product.
Roaster pan
21 x 13 x 6.5 inches/ 6.5 lbs
Stainless steel
Turkey lifters, fork, knife, etc
Dishwasher safe
Best Value
Calphalon Contemporary Nonstick 16-Inch Roaster & Rack
Calphalon manufactures high quality cooking tools and kitchen appliances. The Contemporary 16inch roasting pan is made from aluminum and can hold large turkeys.
Available in different sets with different pieces. Dishwasher safe. Easy to use. Durable construction. Good value for money.
Few complaints regarding reliability. Make sure that you maintain it, according to the instructions in the manual.
Non-stick roasting pan
17.5 x 13.5 x 5.9 inches/ 5.2 lbs
Aluminum, stainless steel
Lifters, injection baster, rack
Dishwasher safe
All-Clad 14-Inch Roaster with Nonstick Rack
All-Clad specializes in stainless steel kitchen appliances and utensils. The 51114 roasting pan is relatively small, but it can help you prepare delicious foods each time.
Durable stainless steel construction. Limited lifetime warranty. Broiler-safe up to 600 degrees F. Easy to clean.
Some customers had issues with rack.
Petite Roti Pan 
16.4 x 12.6 x 5.1 inches/ 6 lbs
Stainless steel
Turkey lifters, rack
Dishwasher safe
VonShef Cast Iron Rectangle Casserole and Roasting Tray
VonShef makes a plethora of practical kitchen appliances and tools. The cast iron roasting tray from VonShef allows even distribution of heat.
2 years warranty. Attractive design. Durable cast iron construction. Retains heat easily. Affordable. Easy to clean.
It is not dishwasher safe. Wash manually only.
Roasting tray
17 x 10.7 x 3.5 inches/ 10 lbs
Enameled cast iron
None
Handwash only
Columbian Home Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster
Columbian House is a prestigious manufacturer of kitchen appliances. The Granite Ware 0509-2 roaster is essential in any modern kitchen.
Amazon Best Seller. Spacious. Can last a lifetime. Good value for money. Exquisite design. No chemicals or toxic substances.
Isolated complaints that it arrived defective. This product can be replaced.
Covered oval roaster
19 x 14 x 6 inches/ 3 lbs
Carbon steel
Dimpled lid
Dishwasher safe

(Updated )
Related Reviews
Best Cookware Set
Best Kitchen Knife Set
Best Electric Carving Knife
Best Gas Oven
Watch Our Roasting Pan Review

How Do I Choose the Best Roasting Pan?

A roasting pan is a piece of cookware designed to suit a modern cook. It’s commonly used for roasting meat in an oven and can accommodate vegetables and other ingredients per your requirements. Your vegetables will be able to absorb fat and juices from the meat, making it more suitable than just using a roasting rack.

As convenient as ready meals, commonly called TV dinners, are, there’s a satisfaction that comes with preparing food in the comfort of your kitchen. A roasting pan will simplify the process and help you save time, as your meat will roast evenly through heat radiation and oven intensification. The presence of lids makes the roasting process faster, as there’s no heat loss.

Unlike a pizza pan, a roasting pan is deep and made of a heavier material. If you’re an adventurous cook, a roasting pan is a must-have cooking tool that allows you to try out various ingredients. Aside from ready-to-eat food being expensive, you are limited to the available flavors. With a roasting pan, you can explore your favorite flavors and mix ingredients to come up with a unique, tasty meal.

Roasting pans available on the market are designed to suit different needs. Whether you’re looking for a roasting pan to use at home or commercially, you’ve got different sizes to suit your cooking needs. Get smaller sizes for home use or for roasting small cuts of meat. Larger pans can be used for commercial purposes or when preparing larger cuts of meat or turkey.

Decide whether you want a commercial or home-use roast pan, one that can be used as a baking tin or a dish to hold smaller baking tins. With the variety available on the market, you can get a versatile pan you can use not just for roasting, but also for other purposes. Irrespective of your application area, you can opt for a pan to use with an oven or stove. We hope this guide can help you find a good roasting pan for you.
Price
Price is also a critical factor when shopping for a roasting pan. It’s affected by a number of factors such as production cost, consumer demand, brand, materials used, size, etc. Prices also vary depending on the type and weight of any given pan. Consider your needs to help you narrow down the various pans available on the market. Depending on your needs, you can get a quality roasting pan in a range between $10 and $50.

With a tighter budget, you can still get a roasting pan to serve the purpose for as little as $7 or less. However, such cheap roasting pans might not last, hence, are only ideal for one-time use. High-end pans built for high durability can cost anywhere from $100 and above. Shop around to compare prices and look for deals with offers of at least one extra pan to get good value for your money.
Features
You need to analyze your needs before choosing a pan suitable for you, as each on the market comes with unique features. Varying from small to large and deep pans with accompanying accessories, a roasting pan with more features stands out, as it can be more useful to meet various needs. Choose a pan of the right size, type, weight and finish for your specific needs.

Here are some features to look for in a roasting pan:
  • The right type of roasting pan
  • The right size and weight of pan
  • Premium material such as steel or aluminum for durability
  • Accessories such as lids, handles and roast racks
  • User manual for proper use and care
  • Easy to clean and care for
With a good roasting pan, you won't just roast your meat or poultry, but also use your piece of cookware for a longer period of time.
Construction and Design
When shopping for a roasting pan, look for the following features in its construction and design:

Type – Roasting pans come in two basic shapes: oval and rectangular. Oval-shaped pans have sleek lines and are perfect for whisking sauce or gravy, but not suitable for roasting ham, turkey, chicken or prime rib. Rectangular pans, on the other hand, though difficult to clean, are suitable for cooking more than one food item, as their right angles provide extra space. However, avoid them if you need to make sauce. Opt for a rectangular pan with rounded corners to meet all your needs and get a good bargain.

Size and Weight – The ideal size of a roasting pan depends on your intended use. For roasting large cuts, you need a larger size to comfortably hold your meat and roast it evenly. Choose a smaller pan for home use or when intending to work on small cuts. A lighter roasting pan is easier to carry around and work with on the go, even when fully loaded.

Materials – There are various materials to choose from, each with its advantages and disadvantages. The most common one is enameled carbon steel, which has been in use for ages. Aluminum, cast iron, nonstick, stainless steel, clad stainless steel and copper have also been in use. Although copper is a perfect material due to its good conductivity and durability, it’s expensive and also needs stainless steel coating, as it’s reactive, toxic, and corrodes easily.

Anodized aluminum, electronically treated aluminum with a non-reactive, nonstick surface and aluminum clad in stainless steel are durable and heat fast and evenly. On the other hand, stainless steel roasting pans are durable and non-reactive. However, stainless steel is a bad conductor, making it necessary to coat the base of such pans with aluminum for steady, even heating.

Enamel-coated cast iron roasting pans are ideal for roasting foods that require even and steady cooking temperatures. Iron will retain heat, but there is need for a heavy coat of enamel to prevent it from chipping or cracking. Though nonstick materials have gained popularity due to their nature of being easy to clean and using less oil when cooking, they’re delicate and produce food that is not as browned as we’re used to.

Accessories – The more accessories a roasting pan has, the more effective and easy to use it becomes. Consider a cooking pan that’s complete with a lid, as it’ll cook faster than one without. A roasting pan that’s accompanied by a cooking spoon and spare handles is also more user-friendly.

Washing – A useful and effective roasting pan isn’t just easy to use, but also easy to clean. You don’t want to spend an entire day scrubbing off stuck food particles and oil. Opt for a roasting pan that comes with a user guide to learn how to use and care for your favorite pan.
Performance and Ease of Use
A good roasting pan is designed to meet your needs, whether you’re using an oven or a stove. Opt for a sturdy and strong pan you can use to carry your food around without twisting or bending. The material it’s made of should be conductive and radiate oven heat evenly for fast and even cooking. The size should also be large enough to accommodate all your meat at one go.

Look out for various accessories such as lids, racks and handles to elevate your pan’s functionality. Finally, your safety comes first, and you don’t want to burn yourself while cooking on a stove top or working with oil drippings. Therefore, look for the right depth and weight in your pan for better cooking results.

What is the Best Roasting Pan?

When buying a roasting pan, take into account your budget, how much food you want to cook at once and the material of which the roaster is made. We’ve provided you with roasting pans in a mixture of types. Let's start with the first one.
Our Top Choice
The Cuisinart 7117-16PS Chef's Classic is a roasting pan made from stainless steel which comes with rack and tools included in the package. This bundle is also available with an electric knife as well. However, if your budget is smaller, go for the Cuisinart CSR-1712R Ovenware Classic Collection instead.
Cuisinart Chef's Classic Stainless 16-Inch Rectangular Roaster with Rack and Tools, Dishwasher Safe

Cuisinart Roasting Pan 7117-16PS – Stainless Steel


Features
You definitely have heard about Cuisinart before; this is a prestigious manufacturer of kitchen appliances and tools. The Cuisinart 7117-16PS Chef's Classic roasting pan is excellent for preparing various types of foods and it comes at a reasonable price.

Here are the highlights of this product.
  • You can buy it in 2 packages: roaster with rack and tools or roaster with rack, tools and electric knife.
  • The set includes a meat thermometer, fork and knife, turkey lifters and turkey baster.
  • The roaster fits in all standard size ovens.
  • All these cooking utensils are dishwasher safe.
Cusinart also makes high quality knife sets as well as multi-cookers and food grinders if you are looking for more kitchen accessories.
Best Value
The Calphalon Contemporary Hard Anodized Nonstick 16-Inch Roasting Pan is ideal for preparing different types of foods and it features a high-gauge aluminum construction. If you want one made from stainless steel then go for the Calphalon Contemporary 16-Inch Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Rack.
Calphalon Contemporary Hard Anodized Nonstick 16-Inch Roasting Pan and Rack, Available in Different Sets

Calphalon Roasting Pan 1876985 – 5-Piece


Features
Calphalon specializes in kitchen appliances and essential cooking devices such as cookware sets, bakeware sets, cutlery and other accessories. The Calphalon Contemporary Hard Anodized Nonstick 16-Inch Roasting Pan is a great addition to your kitchen and it will hold a turkey up to 25 pounds.

Here are more details about this product.
  • Can be purchased alone or with tools and accessories.
  • It can be bought in sets with various pieces, from 2 pieces up to 12 pieces.
  • It comes with handles made from stainless steel.
  • The package also includes 2 stainless steel lid lifters.
It is worth checking out the other kitchen accessories made by Calphalon such as the 7 quarts Dutch Oven or the 13inch flatbottom wok with lid.
The All-Clad 51114 Stainless Steel Petite Roti Pan is a small roasting pan that comes with a V-shaped roasting rack. This kitchen appliance comes with a lifetime warranty. If you prefer a non-scratch, aluminum roasting pan then go for the All-Clad E87599 large roasting pan instead.
All-Clad Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Nonstick V-Shaped Roasting Rack, Dishwasher Safe, Lifetime Warranty

All-Clad Roasting Pan 8400000029 – Stainless Steel


Features
All-Clad features numerous top-selling kitchen appliances and cooking devices which can help you prepare delicious and flavorful foods. For example, the All-Clad 51114 Stainless Steel roasting pan is relatively small in size, but it is easy to use and comes with a lifetime warranty.

Let's explore the other benefits of this pan.
  • It features a warp-resistant base.
  • It is made from durable stainless steel, hence the lifetime warranty.
  • The roasting pan and rack are dishwasher safe.
  • The stainless steel surface doesn’t react with foods and it is hygienic.
If you ever need a sauté pan, spoons set or a sauce pan – all made from stainless steel – then make sure that you check out the products made by All-Clad.
The VonShef Cast Iron roasting tray is excellent for preparing different types of foods, particularly turkey. This tray features an enamelled cast iron design and can accommodate large turkeys. To make your turkey even more delicious, use the VonShef Solid Granite Mortar and Pestle to crush herbs and spices.
VonShef Cast Iron Cooking, Oven To Table Dish, Roasting Tray, Pan, 2 Years Warranty

VonShef Roasting Pan 07/275 - Red


Features
VonShef is another brand that manufactures high-quality kitchen equipments and appliances. If you need a roasting tray then we think that the cast iron roasting tray from VonShef is an excellent cooking device that shouldn’t be missed out from any kitchen.

Let's find out the advantages of this product.
  • The tray's construction allows excellent heat retention and distribution.
  • It can be used to cook at high as well as low temperatures.
  • It is made entirely from cast iron, making it safer and more hygienic than other types of nonstick trays.
  • It can be washed by hand only.
VonShef also makes excellent air fryers as well as food blenders if you want to explore more cooking options and expand your gastronomic skills.
The Granite Ware 0509-2 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster is an Amazon Best Seller and it is made entirely in the USA from carbon steel which is more energy efficient in comparison with other types of materials. This is an oval roaster; if you prefer a rectangular one then go for the Granite Ware 0511-3 Covered Rectangular Roaster from the same brand.
Columbian Home Granite Ware 18" Covered Oval Roaster, Available in 15 or 18 Inches, Carbon Steel Core

Columbian Home Roasting Pan 0509-2 – 18 Inch


Features
Columbian Home is a company that makes a wide array of kitchen appliances and dining accessories, mainly from granite. We liked the Granite Ware 0509-2 roaster because it features a unique design and it comes at a ridiculously low price.

Here are the highlights of this product.
  • It is available in 2 sizes: 15 inches or 18 inches.
  • It features a porcelain enameled surface.
  • It doesn’t contain harmful chemicals or toxic additives.
  • It comes with a lid.
  • The roaster is entirely dishwasher safe.
Feel free to check out the other kitchen appliances made by Columbian Home such as the enamel-on-steal steamer with faucet or the preserving canner with rack.

Get the Best Roasting Pan of 2018!

There’s a roasting pan out there for you that meets your needs. We hope this review was helpful and you found an ideal pan. If you’d rather cook outdoors, check out our grill reviews.

Our Top Choice
Cuisinart 16" Roasting Pan with Rack
Best Value
Calphalon Contemporary Nonstick 16-Inch Roaster & Rack
All-Clad 14-Inch Roaster with Nonstick Rack
VonShef Cast Iron Rectangle Casserole and Roasting Tray
Columbian Home Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster