Best Sandwich Maker – Electric Sandwich Presses for Making Grilled Cheese, Paninis, Hot Pressed Sandwiches and More

Although making sandwiches or panini is one of the easiest things to do maybe second only to sleeping, we still believe that there is a lot to consider when choosing a panini press. This might be a daunting task considering the many different brands and presses out there. But don’t worry: we have done the research for you and have picked what we consider to be five of the best brands when it comes to sandwich makers.

We have only presented a sampling of what each brand has to offer. Therefore, feel free to check other models from these brands in the unlikely event that your most important features aren’t covered in any of the products featured below. If you are cooking for one, we’d like to give a special shout out to the Dash Compact Panini Press and Electric Sandwich Maker which is also perfect for toasting, grilling, waffles, and omelets. Additionally, we have another review with more Panini presses and one that's all about breakfast sandwich makers.
TopProducts may earn commissions when you purchase through links on our site. Learn More.
Overview
PROS
CONS
SPECS
Surface
Settings
Care
Extras
Warranty
Our Top Choice
Cuisinart GR-4N Griddler Sandwich Maker
Cuisinart makes high quality food processing equipment. This 5-in-1 Griddler gives you the flexibility of a multi-functional grill, griddle, dishwasher and Panini press.
5 separate cooking functions. Dual temperature control ensures adequate cooking. Integrated grease catcher for easier cleaning. Plates are dishwasher safe.
Thermostat controls cool off for too long. Non-stick surface peels off with time.
Anodized nonstick cooking surface
Dual temperature control
Dishwasher safe plates
Selector knob for grill or griddle
Info NOT provided
Best Value
George Foreman Evolve Grill & Sandwich Maker
George Foreman commits itself to making cooking convenient for you. This Multi-Plate Evolve Grill comes with features that reduce the need for excess butter and oil.
500˚F blazing burst for 90 seconds gives thorough cooking. Digital control displays cooking time and temperature. Removable cooking plates and ceramic grill.
Difficult handling when the temperature is high.
Nonstick cooking surface
Digital temperature control
Dishwasher-safe plates
Advanced ceramic coating
3-year limited
Breville BREBGR200XL Nonstick Panini Grill
When you want quality without compromise, you get a Breville Panini press. This classy panini press helps you make great sandwiches and is convenient and safe.
Flat bottom plate for fast cooking. Sturdy and stainless steel construction. Non-slip feet to keep it steady and in place
No negative issues reported as at the time of this review.
Scratch-resistant quantanium
On/ready lights
Non-removable plates
Floating hinge; 7 height settings
Info NOT provided
IMUSA Large Electric Panini Press
Imusa has built a reputation as a leader in kitchen products. The Electric Panini Press and Sandwich Maker is multifunctional and delivers panini within few minutes.
Flat grill plate makes for even heating. Grill is easy to clean. Heavy and sturdy construction prevents sliding.
Not suitable for burgers.
Nonstick cooking surface
On & heat-ready indicator lights
Large easy-to-clean plates
Stainless steel exterior
90 days
Hamilton Beach 25460A Gourmet Panini Grill
Hamilton Beach doesn’t need any introduction when it comes to kitchen appliances. With the Gourmet Panini, cooking is a lot easier, more creative and flavorful.
Lid lock makes for constant pressure. Works well with very thick sandwiches. Heats up sufficiently fast.
Heating time differs.
Nonstick cooking surface
Power & preheat light
Non-removable plates
Upright storage
1-year limited

Related Reviews
Best Breakfast Sandwich Maker
Best Stovetop Griddle
Best Quesadilla Maker
Best Pizza Maker

What Is the Best Sandwich Press? Read Our Sandwich Maker Reviews to Find Your Favorite!

Different people will consider different things when it comes to choosing a sandwich maker. A chef may consider the surface while a mother may consider the settings. We understand and have taken the time to bring these factors into consideration in the following individual product/brand reviews to help you make your purchase in good time and get on with your sandwich making.

Related: All-Day Menu for National Sandwich Day – Recipes Plus 3 of the BEST Sandwich Deals!
Our Top Choice
There are companies that make concerted efforts to meet customer’s needs. Cuisinart is one of such companies. The GR-4NR 5-in-1 Griddler gives you 5 different cooking options with dual temperature control. If you want adjustable hinges, a grease draining spout and other features, Cuisinart offers the Cuisinart GR-1 Griddler Panini and Sandwich Press.

Cuisinart 5-in-1 Griddler Countetop Sandwich Maker - Contact Grill, Panini Press, Full Grill, Full Griddle and Half Grill/Half Griddle


Features

“Nobody covers the kitchen like Cuisinart”. It has designed and developed different kitchenware over the years, from blenders to food processors, hand mixers and sandwich makers. It has also earned numerous culinary awards. It is a brand to be trusted when it comes to kitchenware.

With the Cuisinart Griddler, your food comes out just the way you like it. It comes with removable and reversible 11" x 9" dishwasher-safe nonstick cooking plates. And no, that is not all it offers; it also features the following:

  • Integrated drip tray to collect grease
  • Hinged floating cover that adjusts to thickness of food
  • Sturdy panini-style handle
  • Selector knob to choose grill or griddle function
  • Adjustable temperature controls for grill or griddle
  • Red/green indicator lights for easy operation
  • Brushed stainless steel housing
  • Dishwasher-safe scraping tool for easy cleanup
  • Instruction manual with gourmet recipes
  • Limited 3-year warranty
  • BPA-free
Best Value
George Foreman makes innovative cooking products with digital controls that allow minimal supervision. The Perfect GRP4842MB 3-in-1 Multi-Plate grill allows you to time your cooking correctly, from burgers to steak and beyond. Don't need something this big? Check out the George Foreman 2-Serving Classic Indoor Grill and Panini Press Sandwich Maker.

George Foreman 3-in-1 Multi-Plate Evolve Grill and Sandwich Press - Electric Grill, Panini Press & Waffle Maker, Multiple Color Options


Features

George Foreman, named after and promoted by former American professional boxer, is an authority to reckon with when it comes to grills and presses. It has sold over 100 million grills since its launch in 1994. It has proven over the years that it understands what the customer expects from grills and has delivered it.

The George Foreman Evolve Grill is a good fit for you whether it is for grilling, panini or waffles. It gives you a 3-in-1 cooking option and a 500˚F searing burst to give restaurant-quality results at home. Its other features are…

  • Digital control panel
  • Advanced ceramic coating
  • Removable plates
  • Adjustable grilling angle
  • 42% fat removal
  • Floating hinge to allow for foods of different sizes
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Non-stick surface
  • 3-year limited warranty
Others may cut corners for profit; Breville won’t. You can see and feel this brand’s commitment to quality and durability in the Nonstick Surface Panini Press. Want to do more than just make sandwiches with your appliance? Check out the Breville BGR820XL Smart Grill. It's a smokeless indoor grill that can also be used as a sandwich press.

Breville Sandwich Maker and Panini Grill - Non Stick Surface, 7 Adjustable Height Control Settings


Features

Breville, a brand known for its innovations and high standards, has grown into a global market leader in the manufacture of kitchenware. It leads in the field by working with top chefs to ensure that it develops kitchenware that both pros and amateurs enjoy.

The Breville Panini Grill is a 1500-watt panini press with a scratch-resistant quantanium cooking surface. It is non-stick and also comes with...

  • Flat bottom plate for fast, thorough cooking
  • Brushed stainless-steel housing
  • Ribbed top plate to create grill marks
  • Floating hinge; 7 height settings
  • On/ready lights
  • Nonslip feet for firmness
  • Locking storage clip
  • Cord wrap
  • User manual with recipes
Imusa makes novel household products for easy cooking while keeping your kitchen clean. The Electric Panini Press and Sandwich Maker gives you all you need for large and small sandwiches. If you are looking for a cheap sandwich maker with good ratings, consider the IMUSA USA Electric 2 Slot Sandwich Maker with Indicator Lights.

IMUSA Electric Panini Grill and Sandwich Maker - Nonstick Plates, Good for Sandwiches, Meats, Vegetables, & More!


Features

Imusa prides itself as the No. 1 Hispanic international cookware brand. It was created with the mindset of innovation, authenticity and affordability in cookware, and has gone ahead to establish itself as a great culinary brand.

The Electric Panini And Sandwich Maker helps you make your perfect sandwich. It shows Imusa’s high innovation in its design, comes with a sleek touch handle for easy lifting of lid, and also features:

  • Stainless steel exterior
  • 12” x 10” nonstick cooking surface
  • Adjustable height on top plate to accommodate both large and small sandwiches
  • Preset temperature heats up in 4 minutes
  • Ease of cleaning
Hamilton Beach makes quality panini presses, and many positive reviews from customers show you can count on the quality it delivers. Get yourself a gift for a convenient and quality cooking experience with the Panini Press Gourmet Sandwich Maker. Looking for a press to make breakfast ? We think you'll love the Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker with Timer.

Hamilton Beach Electric Panini Press Grill with Locking Lid - Opens 180 Degrees for any Sandwich Thickness


Features

With over a century in the manufacture of household appliances, Hamilton Beach has made a name for itself. With its highly dedicated and innovative team, it launches unique products that solve customers’ needs. Hamilton Beach is a name synonymous with quality and innovation in kitchenware.

The Hamilton Beach Gourmet Sandwich Maker follows in the tradition of quality that Hamilton Beach is known for. It has an adjustable hinge that allows you to make sandwiches of any thickness. It also has a café style floating lid, which presses any size of sandwich. This sandwich maker comes with other features…

  • 10 x 8 inch nonstick grids
  • Power and preheat lights
  • Can be stored in an upright position since the plates are not removable
  • Cord that can be wound around pegs under bottom plate
  • Clip to lock machine in closed position
  • Instruction book with a few recipes using tortillas, pizza crust, refrigerator crescent rolls
  • Top plate that can be locked in any position between fully opened & closed
  • Easy to clean surface
  • Non complicated settings
  • 1-year limited warranty

Electric Sandwich Maker Buying Guide – What to Look for in a Hot Sandwich Press

Food is something many people adore. And why not? There are so many delicious cuisines around the world; Italian, Indian, Chinese, Mexican, Thai, the list could go on and on! But, with that being said, there’s something comforting about food from our home country and we think you will all agree. We don’t know about you, but for us, nothing can beat a home-made toasted sandwich made in a sandwich maker. Our personal favorite; cheese and beans! Yup, it’s a bit messy but so worth it.

Whatever your favorite toasted sandwich is, it’s obvious that your kitchen would not be complete without a sandwich maker. It simplifies preparing your toast and sandwiches as it saves you the time and energy of firing up your oven and baking or grilling anything. Imagine putting just two slices of bread in an average-sized oven; the thought of all that effort might just make you forget about the meal or snack altogether.

Some sandwich makers have removable plates that allow them to double as a waffle maker and this is a versatile design that affords you the freedom of having a variety of options for any meal of the day. It’s amazing just what kitchen appliances can do nowadays!

 

Video: How to Make a Sandwich at Home

Sandwich Making Tips. | Courtesy of Cheerful Syanu
Price

Sandwich makers come in varying designs and sizes and have different features; all these and more influence the price. The simple single slice design would definitely be in the lower price range while the professional multi slice designs would be in the upper price range. The brand and material that it’s made of would also be a factor in the pricing. As you shop for a sandwich maker, you should prepare your mind to spend between about $25 and $140 depending on the previously mentioned variables. Note that this price is not a peg on both lower and upper price limits, there are products that are more costly, and there are some that are cheaper.

There are some cheap sandwich makers that we saw during our research, but the reason they are not featured in this review is due to the lack of quality and durability; thus making it unworthy of being on your shopping list. We assure you that any product /brand you choose based on this review will not disappoint you because we made sure to select only brands with a proven track record for high performance and satisfaction.

Features

Sandwich makers come in a variety of sizes and types; there are different features that produce different results. Before you make a choice, it is important that you check out features that would make your purchase worthwhile. Some of these features include:

  • Type of Handle - This would determine how long the handle would last and how convenient it would be to use
  • Ease of Use and Cleaning - Ensure that it's easy to use and clean
  • Size and Shape - This determines the number of slices you can make at once and the shape it can be cut into
  • Removable Grill Plates - They make the sandwich press versatile
  • Material of Construction - This affects the quality and durability
  • Indicator Lights – This would help you to use it properly
  • Type of Surface of the Plates – This contributes to the overall convenience and durability
Construction and Design

When shopping for a sandwich maker, you need to consider, the quantity of sandwich you would make per time, the number of people you will be catering for, and what types of sandwiches you like to make. All these would determine the type of sandwich maker you need. If you are going to be preparing lunch for a family of four or more, it wouldn’t be time and cost-efficient for you to get a single slice sandwich maker. You’ll need the larger ones that can make up to two or more slices at once.

The single slice sandwich maker is ideal for the single person or the college student who lives in a dorm and just needs to make sandwiches once in a while. There are sandwich makers that cut bread into interesting shapes and others that can handle bread slices that are thicker than the regular-sized slices, so considering the type of bread that you like using for your toast is also important before making a purchase. Some sandwich makers have removable grill plates that enable you to clean it and also leave room for you to use other types of plates with it.

The handle of this apparatus is also important, a handle that's made of stainless steel would be stronger and therefore more durable than the ones made of plastic which may break with use.

 

Video: How to Make Waffles in a Sandwich Maker

Making Waffles Using a Sandwich Maker. | Courtesy of Nefis TV
Performance and Ease of Use

The surface that the plates are made of is an important factor in the performance of any sandwich maker. The ones with a nonstick surface are easier to clean and maintain. It ensures that your bread or the fillings don't get stuck on the surface. If you have to keep scraping the surface every time you use it, you are guaranteed that it won't last long and not only that; it won't be convenient to use. Though the ones made with a cast iron surface (material that isn’t non-stick) are a little cheaper than the ones made with materials like Teflon, you would probably spend more in the long run. You’d have to purchase a new sandwich maker before long due to all the stuck-on food parts.

Sandwich makers that have indicator lights that are labeled are easier to use as they show when they are on or when they are ready to be used and also when the time set for the toast is up. Those that do not have labeled lights may be more difficult to use especially if the owner doesn’t use it too often.

Most sandwich makers are made with stainless steel which gives it a glossy finish and also makes it easy to clean, but the one with tops made of glass or surfaces that are painted are by far easier to clean than their counterparts.


Get the Best Sandwich Maker of 2020!

Did you see a panini press that made you salivate and long for a sandwich? Were you able to find a panini press that met your expectations? We really hope this review has given you enough information to help you make the right purchase. Enjoy your sandwiches! Bon appétit!
.

Our Top Choice
Cuisinart GR-4N Griddler Sandwich Maker
Best Value
George Foreman Evolve Grill & Sandwich Maker
Breville BREBGR200XL Nonstick Panini Grill
IMUSA Large Electric Panini Press
Hamilton Beach 25460A Gourmet Panini Grill

Sandwich Maker FAQs

How to use a sandwich maker?
When using a sandwich maker, it is important to start by lightly brushing the surface of its plates with some cooking oil. Avoid using low fat spreads. They might cause burns to the nonstick surface. Turn on your machine and, with its lid open, allow it to heat up for around 5 minutes. Apply some butter on your two slices of bread and place them in the sandwich maker. Finally, close the sandwich maker and let it toast your bread until it’s golden and crisp. Most models automatically turn off once the process is complete.
How to make waffles in sandwich maker?
Making waffles in a sandwich maker can be a simpler and quicker alternative to a waffle iron. Start by picking your ingredients and making the batter. Once done, grease up your sandwich maker with some oil, let it preheat, and then add a thin layer of the batter. Let it toast for around 10 minutes, or until it turns golden brown on both sides. Once done, take out and enjoy your waffles.
How to clean sandwich maker?
How you clean your sandwich maker will determine just how long the device will last. Therefore, before cleaning, you want first to unplug it and let it cool down a little. Let it remain a bit warm so you can get the grease and oily residue out more quickly. Take up a cloth or sponge and use warm, soapy water to wipe through the surface. Then rub gently at any stubborn residues, paying attention to any grooves that oil can get in. Finish by taking a fresh damp cloth and wipe away any soap suds. It is important not to soak the plates as this could damage their nonstick surface.