Best Shea Butter Reviews 2019

Shea butter is one of nature’s finest gifts to mankind because it has so many skin-nourishing benefits that come straight from Mother Nature. There are many products on the market that lay claim to being organic, unrefined Shea butter, but not all really are. Some just use it as an ingredient in their beauty-product recipes while other brands use it in its refined and processed form (adding fragrance and dyes). To save you the hassle of figuring out which claims are authentic, we’ve carried out extensive research on the subject and have come up with our list of five top brands that sell the best Shea butter products. Although our brands have more than one product, we’ve chosen only one product from each for the purpose of this review. If the products we’ve featured don’t fit your needs, check out our top brands’ other products!
Overview
PROS
CONS
SPECS
Certification
Size(s)
Source
Return Policy
Container
Our Top Choice
Molivera Organics Ivory Shea Butter
Molivera Organics consistently takes pride in bringing top-quality, organic skin and hair care products to its customers, using unadulterated, natural ingredients from Mother Nature.
Smooth; high level of antioxidants and essentially fatty acids; great for dry, damaged skin; comes in UV bottle.
Light nutty aroma may be unpleasant.
Organic, but not certified
16 ounces
Ghana: Manufactured & imported
100% satisfaction: within 30 days
BPA-free, UV-protective plastic
Best Value
Better Shea Butter Unrefined Shea Butter
Better Shea Butter makes products with raw ingredients to help people solve their skin issues without harsh chemicals.
High-level of vitamin A; helps with swelling, itching, eczema and more; Vegan-friendly; organic.
Paper packaging not ideal for storage.
Organic, but not certified
8 or 16 ounces
Partners w/ Ghana women’s co-op
“Love it or return it” refund
Paper packaging; plastic interior
Key West Health and Beauty Shea Butter
Key West Health & Beauty produces quality skincare products. Because they care about how their customers perceive them, they offer a combination of low-priced items that are also high quality.
FDA-approved packaging; BPA-free plastic; USDA certified organic; 100% money-back guarantee
Thick butter may be hard to spread on skin.
Certified Organic by USDA
16 ounces
Women’s co-op in Africa
30 days with no questions asked
BPA-free, non-toxic plastic
Perfect Body Harmony Shea Nut Butter
Perfect Body Harmony receives their high-quality, organic ingredients from all over the world, packaging it all in the USA. They’re continually looking for ways for people to have the best that nature has to offer.
Packaged in BPA free jar, certified by Oregon Tilth, it reliefs and reduces the occurrence of skin diseases, scars, and stretch marks and it doesn’t block skin pores.
Isolated complaints of an off-putting odor.
Certified Organic by Oregon Tilth
3.75 or 17.5 ounces; or 7 pounds
Made and imported from Ghana
100% satisfaction: within 30 days
BPA-free, UV-protective amber jar
Cleopatra’s Choice Organic Shea Butter
The mission of Cleopatra's Choice is to search everywhere for unique, high-quality skin care products to offer the best in natural skincare. They also have an unconditional 100% money back guarantee!
Absorbs quickly into skin; natural ingredients; contains essential fatty acids; use by itself or DIY
Reports of unpleasant smell.
Organic, but not certified
16 or 32 ounces
Fair Trade - Ghana, West Africa
90 days with no questions asked
Re-sealable, recyclable jar

(Updated )
Related Reviews
Best Sunscreen
Best Cosmetic Beeswax
Best Anti Aging Cream
Best Chemical Peel
Watch Our Shea Butter Review

How Do I Choose the Best Shea Butter?

Africans have been using Shea butter for years to keep their skin luxuriously soft, but the rest of the world is just catching on. Traditionally, unrefined, raw Shea butter takes a very long time to go bad, but exposure to heat and direct sunlight may cause it to deteriorate faster. If your butter gets too hot or seems to be going bad, it may have lost some of its healing properties. However, before throwing away that unused butter, we recommend pairing it with another moisturizer.

The color of Shea butter depends on the species of nut that it was extracted from. As it ages, the color deepens, but the smell remains natural (nutty and smoky because the nuts are roasted). Any shea butter that doesn’t have an aroma and is totally white has been bleached and processed.

There are so many benefits from incorporating natural, raw, unrefined Shea butter into your beauty regimen, which is why it’s important to ensure that you get one that’s truly organic. Some brands may claim that their products are organic when they actually contain processed Shea butter as the main ingredient. You can combine Shea butter with some essential oils to whip up your own homemade body lotion. That’s another reason to look out for the 100% organic ones—you can’t go wrong when your ingredients are straight from Mother Nature!

If you’re looking for Shea butter soap, or you’re looking to make soap with Shea butter at home, keep in mind that soap requires other ingredients in order to retain its shape, consistency and texture. However, if you use Shea butter in your soap, it still has a lot of moisturizing benefits and nutrients that are super healthy for your skin.
Price
Shea butter is a relatively affordable beauty/skincare product. If you come across any high-end, expensive Shea products, you may want to take a second look to be sure that it’s natural, raw and unrefined, and perhaps even question why it’s expensive.

As with other products, the quality and the way the butter is manufactured will determine its price tag. But because it’s a natural product with no additives, it’s fairly inexpensive to make. Quality butter can be purchased for as low as $9.95 to as high as $19.95, depending on size and packaging.

When we conducted our research, we came across some lower priced products that seemed like Shea butter, but had artificial ingredients or were no longer natural or raw. With our chosen brands, you’ll only find items that are 100% organic with no additives.
Features
Shea Butter is an organic oil made from Shea nuts that provides nutrients to help your skin fight age-related conditions, such as fine lines, pregnancy stretch marks and calluses. Its best use is for softening and repairing dry skin, and for relieving medical conditions like eczema or psoriasis. There are so many positives with Shea, we wanted to highlight our favorite ones so you can get an idea of the type of features you may want your own butter to have. We really like its…
  • Light, nutty aroma
  • Non-grainy texture
  • Protects skin from damaging UV rays
  • Some are packaged in UV-protective bottles to keep butter from deteriorating
  • High content of vitamin A is great for skin’s elasticity
  • Moisturizes and softens dry skin
  • Glossy and oily, but easily absorbed into the skin
  • A small amount goes a long way
  • Free of artificial substances
  • Won’t clog skin pores
  • Natural ingredient for Do-It-Yourself skincare products
  • Has healing properties that ease redness, swelling, itchiness and other skin conditions
  • Some are certified organic (but all are naturally organic)
  • Safe for all skin types
  • Some are packaged in BPA-free, FDA-approved containers (great for storing your homemade lotions/creams)
  • Use on scars, burns and stretch marks to visibly reduce their appearance
Construction and Design
Shea butter is harvested from nuts from African Shea trees. The best type is organic and unrefined, which is great for using on your skin and in your hair. The natural high levels of antioxidants and vitamins present in Shea makes them ideal for skin because your skin absorbs 60% of what you put on it.

Before you buy any Shea butter product, check the label to be sure that it doesn’t contain artificial colors or other chemical substances. When you buy your butter, smell it to see if it has a nutty aroma (this scent will vary some due to different qualities and types of shea nuts, and differences in manufacturing/shipping processes), but it shouldn’t smell rancid or have a petroleum jelly-type scent.

Color will also vary some, but, in general, it should be ivory white or ivory tan, light butter yellow, beige or yellowish gray. Check both the scent and the color of your butter before using it, and if you believe that it’s off, request a refund! Most of our chosen brands want you to be happy with your purchase, so they offer a monetary refund if you don’t like the way your butter looks or smells.

Buying butter that’s USDA certified organic—or any butter that has an organic certification—doesn’t necessarily mean it’s more protected from exposure to errors in manufacturing, shipping, or packaging. An organic certification (for USDA standards) just means that the product contains less than 10% of artificial or non-organic ingredients. All of the products we reviewed are indeed organic, but they don’t all have the certification.
Performance and Ease of Use
If you’ve had a bad experience with store-bought cosmetics, you’ll appreciate the freedom of being able to make your own skincare and beauty products at home! Because you know exactly what’s being applied to your body, you have more control over your skin and how it looks (meaning you can avoid trying chemical-filled products that could lead to breakouts).

Shea butter provides you with a natural ingredient that you can use to make products that’ll nourish your skin without serious side effects. It’s easy to apply, quickly absorbed, and, for the majority of people, it doesn’t clog their pores. If you find that Shea has a positive effect on your skin, we recommend whipping up your own special night cream to apply all over before bed (when your skin and body has time to relax).

We love Shea butter because it feels so luxuriously smooth, it’s natural, and it has a super long shelf life. If you make your own beauty products with Shea, just remember to store them in dark colored jars (or somewhere dark, away from the sun) and keep them away from direct heat. If you do protect your homemade goodies from sun and heat, they’ll last up to two years—but we know you’ll need to make more lotion way before then!

What is the Best Shea Butter?

Although we can’t say which brand of Shea butter is the best on the market—the best depends on your needs and desires—we can say with confidence that you’ll find the ‘best’ product within our chosen brands. We think you should always be true to yourself, so only you can decide what Shea butter fits your wants and what will fit within your budget. As you read our reviews for each item, we know that you’ll get all the information you need to figure out the best butter for you!
Our Top Choice
The Molivera Organics Raw Organic Ivory Shea Butter is natural and unprocessed. Because it never went through an artificial method of extraction, the butter wasn’t subjected to intense heat that would bleach it and reduce its natural healing properties. If you prefer oil instead of butter for protecting your skin, we recommend the Molivera Organics Castor Oil.
Molivera Organics Organic Grade-A Raw African Ivory Shea Butter for Natural Skin

Molivera Organics Shea Butter Mol-3715


Features
Molivera Organics is a company that takes pride in bringing top-quality organic skin and hair care products to its customers. To achieve the highest success in customer satisfaction, they believe in using natural, unadulterated ingredients from Mother Nature.

The Molivera Organics Ivory Shea Butter is natural and unprocessed. You know from its pure ivory color that the butter is totally pure. Because it has never gone through an artificial extraction method, the butter is never heated to the point of bleaching. When butter is bleached, it loses some of its healing properties. Other butters that are yellow often have a dye added to them, which Molivera doesn’t utilize in order to keep their products 100% natural. This wonderful beauty care product has a lot of features that we really liked:
  • Non grainy; smooth to touch
  • High content of antioxidants
  • Contains essential fatty acids
  • Packaged in UV protective bottle to keep butter from degrading
  • Moisturizes and softens dry skin
  • Glossy and oily; easily absorbed into the skin
  • A little goes a long way
  • Healing properties help to clear skin of blemishes and impurities
Best Value
Better Shea Butter’s Unrefined Shea Butter has been rated at 5 stars for nearly three years in a row. This natural, unprocessed butter can be used as-is or for DIY purposes. The included eBook has tons of recipes! If you want to avoid that nutty smell, we highly recommend checking out raw cocoa butter instead! Better Shea Butter’s Unrefined Raw Cocoa Butter is an excellent choice.
Better Shea Butter African Raw & Pure Unrefined Shea Butter – Available in 2 Sizes & 2 Colors

Better Shea Butter Unrefined – 16 Ounces – Ivory


Features
Better Shea Butter’s first product was unprocessed, natural Shea butter from Ghana. From there, they went on to manufacturing other organic beauty products to help their customers create a well-rounded beauty regimen. Their use of raw, organic, Vegan-friendly ingredients means everyone can solve their skin issues without the use of harsh chemicals. They’re always researching new recipes and ways to improve their customers’ skin to bring them the highest product satisfaction.

Their Unrefined Shea Butter has attained thousands of 5-star ratings from their customers for three years in a row. The shea nuts in this butter are harvested by women in Ghana where they’re then opened, roasted, and made into a dough. The natural, unadulterated process through which these nuts go through is what makes this butter so creamy, so moisturiizing, and so nourishing for your skin! With their unrefined butter, you can apply it as-is or use it in your own DIY recieps (the included ebook with this product will give you all sorts of ideas!).

Other features we really loved are:
  • Does not clog pores
  • Has healing properties that ease, redness, swelling, itchiness and other skin conditions
  • Contains high level of vitamin A to help collagen production
  • Has vitamins E and F as well as essential fatty acids that deeply moisturize without greasiness
  • Product naturally protects skin from damaging UV rays
  • Helps reduce and prevent facial lines, scars, stretch marks, and uneven skin tone
  • Contains antioxidants
  • If stored properly, it can last up to 2 years
The Key West Health and Beauty Organic Shea Butter is thick and creamy, and packed with all the nutrients your body requires to stay youthful & vibrant. It’s sourced from Africa with women workers that are part of a co-op that endorses fair wages. Are you looking for a night cream with retinol? Then you’re in luck! Check out Key West Health and Beauty’s 2.5% Retinol Night Cream.
Key West Health and Beauty 16-Ounce Organic African Raw Unrefined Shea Butter

Key West Health and Beauty Shea Butter Organic Unrefined-16-Ounce


Features
Key West Health & Beauty produces beauty products with an emphasis on customer service and satisfaction. With over 35 years of experience in the spa and beauty industry between the founders, their items are derived from the most natural, organic ingredients. They don’t cut corners just to give their customers the lowest price. Instead, they seek to find a combination between great quality and affordable price tag.

Key West Health and Beauty’s Organic Shea Butter is thick and creamy, and packed with all that your body requires to stay youthful & vibrant. It’s raw, unadulterated, and rich in natural vitamins and nutrients. You won’t find any chemicals or preservatives in this raw butter! Sourced from Africa utilizing women in a co-op that supports fair wages, Key West Health and Beauty helps people perfect their skin while promoting women and equality abroad. Our favorite features are…
  • Packaged in FDA approved and BPA-free container
  • Certified by USDA as Organic
  • Good for all types of hair and skin treatments
  • A good lip balm that soothes dry and chapped lips
  • Helps reduce stretch marks
  • Luxurious whole-body moisturizer
The Perfect Body Harmony Shea Nut Butter is 100% organic and untreated. It’s made from Shea nuts from Karite trees in Ghana in West Africa, and it’s triple filtered for purity. Do you want a less expensive Shea butter option? Take a look at Perfect Body Harmony’s Unrefined Raw Shea Butter.
Perfect Body Harmony Organic Ivory Raw Shea Nut Butter – Available in 3 Sizes

Perfect Body Harmony Shea Butter Unrefined Virgin Ivory – 17.5 oz UV JAR - Tall


Features
Years of research and learning mixed with a desire to build their own business led Jana & Gerald Cobb to establish Perfect Body Harmony™. Having developed a great desire for, and having learned how to live a toxin-free life, this brand was designed to help educate others on how to live a healthy, natural lifestyle. Perfect Body Harmony sources their raw ingredients from West Africa, but packages everything in their FDA-approved facility. Their mission is to enable everyone to have their best skin offer—naturally!

Perfect Body Harmony’s Shea Nut Butter is 100% organic and untreated. It’s made from nuts that are harvested from Karite Trees in Ghana in West Africa, and then it’s triple filtered to ensure no impurities end up in your butter! Some features we thought should be highlighted for you are..
  • Glossy and natural whole-body moisturizer
  • Available in different sizes
  • Packaged in BPA-free jar
  • Won’t clog pores
  • Helps reduce the appearance of scars and stretch marks
  • Certified organic by Oregon Tilth; certification can be presented if customer desires
  • Contains vitamins A, D, E, and F—all essential for healthy, radiant skin
The Cleopatra’s Choice Organic Shea Butter is a luxurious, natural, unrefined Shea butter that absorbs quickly into the skin so you can be wonderfully smooth and moisturized without feeling super oily. Do you want a natural African black soap instead? Check out Cleopatra’s Choice’s African Black Soap - Face & Body Wash.
Cleopatra’s Choice Raw & Unrefined Premium Quality Organic Shea Butter – Available in 2 Sizes

Cleopatra’s Choice Shea Butter 100% Pure – 1 Pound


Features
Cleopatra’s Choice is a company that searches high and low for the most exceptional natural ingredients to create products that help their customers achieve the perfect beauty regimen. Their business is in gathering and importing organic ingredients which they then turn into luxurious beauty items. They’re so confident that you’ll love their products, they have an unconditional money back guarantee—if you don’t like it, just send it back with proof of purchase for a full refund. If you’re new to trying Shea butter, we recommend Cleopatra’s Choice because of their 100% guarantee.

Cleopatra’s Choice’s Organic Shea Butter is a luxuriously smooth, raw butter to mosturize and soften dry, cracked and damaged skin. Loaded with high levels of vitamins A, E and F, you know your skin is being actively protected, renewed and refreshed as enjoy your lavishly soft and smooth skin. This butter has so many amazing features, we’ve highlighted just a few for you:
  • Essential fatty acids that reduce fine lines and wrinkles
  • Helps skin fight other age-related conditions
  • Relieves dry skin and helps repair damage
  • Free of artificial substances
  • Cruelty Free
  • Jars is reusable and recyclable (perfect for DIY-ers!)
  • Does not clog pores
  • Protects skin while preventing future damage

Get the Best Shea Butter of 2019!

Now that you have taken the time to go through our review, we know you’ve got enough information to pick out the best Shea body butter. Purchase it now and get ready to moisturize your skin into silky-soft luxury!

Our Top Choice
Molivera Organics Ivory Shea Butter
Best Value
Better Shea Butter Unrefined Shea Butter
Key West Health and Beauty Shea Butter
Perfect Body Harmony Shea Nut Butter
Cleopatra’s Choice Organic Shea Butter