Best Stovetop Griddle Reviews 2018

Making a great meal is every home chef’s dream, and it doesn’t matter if you are cooking for one or ten. But how do you choose the perfect griddle that can serve you whether at home or camping. Making this choice can be very frustrating since you have access to over one hundred thousand different products from thousands of brands. We know this, and that’s why we have taken it upon ourselves to research these brands and their various products and have selected five of the best stove top griddles. These brands have many griddles, but we have only focused on one each. So, you should take a look at the other products from each brand if the featured one isn’t the right one for you.
Overview
PROS
CONS
Our Top Choice
Nordic Ware Grill & Griddle
Nordic Ware’s high value products, exemplified by the Nordic Ware Double Backsplash Grill & Griddle, further establish its leadership role in the kitchen ware industry.
Compatible with gas, electric and glass-top. Even heating across the griddle surface. Easy to get a spatula under the food without it getting away.
Slides all over stovetop while maneuvering food. Doesn't have a true handle to steady it while flipping food. Not ideal for square burners.
Best Value
Utopia Kitchen Cast Iron Griddle
Utopia Kitchen delivers high quality lifestyle kitchenware. The Cast Iron Griddle Pizza Pan delivers both even and high heat while leaching some iron into the food being cooked.
The pan comes pre-seasoned. Clean-up is easy. Very good on the stove top. Good, even heat distribution throughout the surface.
Not best for glass top electric stoves.
Calphalon Ceramic Nonstick Griddle
Calphalon has consistently delivered great kitchenware backed by their traditional 10-year warranty. The Simply Calphalon Ceramic Square Griddle is well-made and comes PTFE free.
Well-made flat griddle. Perfect for grilled cheese sandwiches.  Distributes heat well even on electric stove top.
Warps.
Cuisinart Double Burner Griddle
Cuisinart’s excellence in kitchenware has been deployed in the 18" Non-Stick Double Burner Griddle, big enough for large family breakfast with top-class heat distribution.
Works on induction. Fits over the two burners.
Middle section does not heat up.
Lodge Double Play Reversible Griddle
All Lodge’s griddles are made of cast iron, making them virtually indestructible. Whether used in a kitchen or camp, this Cast Iron Reversible Griddle should last for generations.
Flat and well-made. Easy to get a spatula under foods. Easy to clean. Works on an induction cooktop.
Rusts. Sides of the griddle are too low. Length of the griddle is a bit short for commercial range burners.

(Updated )
Related Reviews
Best Sandwich Maker
Best Indoor Grill
Best Smoker
Best Barbecue

How Do I Choose the Best Stovetop Griddle?

A stove top griddle is an awesome way to carry out small scale grilling in your kitchen. It is bigger than a regular pre-seasoned skillet and is usually flat. It looks more like a grill pan, but the cooking surface isn’t always grooved. A stove top griddle can save you a lot of time especially if you want to make, say breakfast, for a bunch of people. You can fry the bulk of your pancakes at once due to its sheer size, instead of in limited batches as when using a skillet. There are also stove top griddles that are big enough to cover two burners on your stove.

The best stove top griddle spreads heat evenly across the cooking surface and holds heat for a long time. They have nonstick surfaces that won’t burn your food. They are sturdy and durable. Some stove top griddles are reversible, with one side smooth and the other grooved. For other stove top griddles, part of their surface is recessed for collected fats and grease that come out of your foods. They are also easy to clean and have comfortable handles.
Price
The size of the griddle, the surface type, and other extra features are the factors that affect the pricing of stove top griddles. The high-end reversible griddles cost a little less than $100 while the less expensive ones which still adequately serve their purposes will go for slightly less than $30. The cheap stove top griddles are nothing to write home about as they are made with inferior materials and will burn your food rather than cook them. As a result, we have not included them in this buying guide.
Features
Stove top griddles help bring grilling into the home. They allow you cook at moderate temperatures. You can heat flat bread, toast sandwiches, and make pancakes. If you get yourself one, we bet you will use it more often than you thought. Here are some of the features to look out for:
  • Material
  • Thickness
  • Surface type
  • Handle
  • Size
  • Care
  • Extra
These are the features that make a stove top griddle serve its purpose. The combination you decide on will impact the value you get from your chosen griddle.
Construction and Design
Stove top griddles are usually made with alloys of different metals. Stainless steel covered aluminum and anodized aluminum are sometimes used, but cast iron is the most commonly used. This is because it evenly distributes heat and often retains it for longer but it has its downsides too. They are heavy and have to be often maintained to prevent rust.

The thickness of a stove top griddle indicates quality and they are usually available in different thickness. The commonly available is between 1/16 inches and 1/8 inches which are adequate for a griddle to effectively serve its purpose.

Stove top griddles come in different shapes and sizes. There are the round, square, and rectangular griddles. The round ones, just like your regular frying pans, heat evenly than the square ones. But the square and especially the rectangular ones give you more cooking real estate. The long rectangular type that can cover two burners on your stove is great for treating a crowd.

Some other great extras come with some stove top griddles that brings out the extra usefulness in them. Some griddles are reversible and let you cook on both sides; these types often have a smooth surface on one side and ridges for grilling on the other. Some stove top griddles have a recessed portion on the surface that drains fat and grease away from your food.
Performance and Ease of Use
One crucial part of stove top griddles is the surface you will be cooking on. Nonstick surfaces are popular and even attractive as they are quite easy to clean and won’t burn your meals. There are downsides to them too. They will not give your food the type of color you would get from a metal surface, and nonstick surfaces are somewhat fragile. There are nonstick griddles now that are coated with Teflon which makes them more durable but will start to emit toxic fumes if heated beyond 350oC. Another type of nonstick griddle is anodized aluminum which is nontoxic and is even resistant to scratch. They sear and brown your food better, and you can use metal utensils with them, but they stick more that nonstick griddles.

The handle on a stove top griddle is also important because it is your point of contact. First off, the handles have to be sturdy whatever the material they are made of. The best handles are the ones that will not get too hot while in use. Handles that are forged from the griddle or are permanently bonded with the griddle are safe and durable. And so are those that are riveted, to some extent.

Like every other kitchenware, stove top griddles have to be thoroughly cleaned after every use. Most griddles are designed to be easy to clean. Grease breaking detergent, baking soda, club soda, etc. are some of the items you can use to clean stove top griddles. They can also be wiped off using a dishcloth, plastic scrubber, paper towels, etc. With this information, we hope you will be able to make up your mind which combination of features you want in your ideal stove top griddle which will help you in choosing the one to buy.

What is the Best Stovetop Griddle?

Making up your mind on the features you want in your stove top griddle is just one of the things you need to do with the information you now have on them. Now read our review of individual brands/products while keeping in mind all that information and your needs. This approach will make it easy for you to choose the best stove top griddle for you from the ones available from the trusted brands we featured.
Our Top Choice
The Nordic Ware Double Backsplash Grill & Griddle, made in the USA, meets Nordic Ware’s strict health and safety standards while meeting your cooking needs. Looking for a different type of griddle that cleans very easily after cooking without soaking? Then check out Nordic Ware 365 Indoor\/Outdoor Texas Searing Griddle.
Nordic Ware 19860 2 Burner Backsplash Grill and Griddle

Nordic Ware Stovetop Griddle 19860 -- Black


Features
Nordic Ware produces top quality, innovative and functional kitchenware products and distributes them worldwide, reaching millions of homes around the world.

The Nordic Ware Double Backsplash Grill & Griddle (selling for $36.55, the manufacturer’s suggested retail price) is a big two-burner, dual purpose pan that handles your cooking very well. With a flat griddle on the right side (which accommodates potatoes, pancakes or even eggs) and a ribbed grill surface on the left side (for searing meats and vegetables), you’ve got all your cooking needs met. Even if this is your first time using this type of cookware, rest assured that your learning curve will be quite short. Your spatula can easily reach under your egg without it getting away, and you won’t need to soak the grill and griddle overnight after cooking. Just one wipe, and the surface is as clean as new and you can cook again and again.

This Grill and Griddle comes with more exciting features:
  • Made of cast aluminum for excellent and even heating
  • Its raised edges and back panel contain spatters
  • Fats and juices from your cooking collect in a reservoir up front
This easily likeable grill and griddle works well for grills or stoves.
Best Value
Lifestyle is Utopia Kitchen’s focus in all its products, and the Cast Iron Griddle Pizza Pan 12 inch, big enough for cooking several items at once, delivers the kind of value that is customary of Utopia Kitchen. The Utopia Kitchen Reversible Cast Iron Grill Griddle, 17 x 10 inch provides even more space to serve more people.
Utopia Kitchen Cast Iron Griddle Pizza Pan - Pre Seasoned Grill (New Design)

Utopia Kitchen Stovetop Griddle UK0034 -- Black


Features
Utopia Kitchen, known for variety of lifestyle merchandises, also produces kitchenware that evokes empathy in the hearts of its customers, almost compelling them to always buy its products.

Griddles are essential when high heat is needed and the food being cooked is somewhat flat. The Cast Iron Griddle Pizza Pan 12 Inch meets and surpasses this basic need. With an outer diameter of 12 inches and a round cast-iron griddle, exceptional heat retention and distribution is delivered to the food, and its strong handles also help to steady the pan when flipping pancakes.
This cool kitchenware has the following features:
  • Strong handle which also allows for convenient hanging when not in use
  • Pre-seasoned and set for use with vegetable oil evenly baked into surface
  • Allows some iron to percolate into your food, which can be good for your health
  • Cooks more than one item at a time; several sandwiches, pancakes or bacon and eggs can be fixed to feed many people at once
On top of all this, you are covered by Utopia Kitchen’s full, no-questions-asked 30-day Money-Back Guarantee.
Calphalon’s over 50 years’ expertise in culinary kitchenware was unleashed in the Simply Calphalon Ceramic Nonstick 11-in. Square Griddle. This Griddle is oven-safe to 400 F. But if you are looking for a griddle that can withstand heat of up to 450 F, then the New Hard-Anodized Non-stick Double Griddle is what you need.
Calphalon 11-inch Contemporary Hard-Anodized Aluminum Nonstick Cookware, Square Griddle Pan

Calphalon Griddle 1876983 -- Black


Features
Since 1963, Calphalon has strived to be the open and friendly culinary expert in kitchenware, improving in every way possible the home chef's food planning, preparation and cooking experience.

The Simply Calphalon Ceramic Nonstick 11-in. Square Griddle features the eco-friendly PFOA-free ceramic nonstick with Calphalon's hard-anodized aluminum construction, making it durable and dishwasher safe. This square griddle has a large cooking area which means you can make food for several persons at the same time, and its shallow edge ensures that your spatula can easily slide under pancakes for easy flipping. Other features include:
  • Aluminum composition to ensure even heating
  • Interior comprising of three layers of nonstick coating (two layers for durability, and the third for easy release performance)
  • Stainless steel handles which remain cool on the stovetop
  • Nonstick surface which ensures healthier cooking by using less fat with effortless cleanup
This sturdy griddle further comes with Calphalon's full lifetime warranty.
Cuisinart’s many awards, including the 2012 Housewares Design Award in the Countertop Food Prep Appliances, shows its expertise in kitchenware. The 18" Non-Stick Double Burner Griddle is another great kitchenware with excellent Heat Surround Technology. For oven and stove cooking, see the Cuisinart DSA55-35 Washer Safe Double Burner Grill.
Cuisinart 10 x 18-Inch Stainless Steel Non-Stick Double Burner Griddle

Cuisinart Double Burner Griddle MCP45-25NS – Stainless Steel


Features
Cuisinart boasts of a wide selection of cookware and kitchenware with innovative designs, which greatly enhance the home chef’s preparation and cooking experience.

The 18" Non-Stick Double Burner Griddle comes with a handle made from 70% recycled stainless steel, which ensures that your hand won’t get burnt while cooking (especially when you are heating food up to 500 F, a temperature this griddle accommodates effortlessly). There’s more to this griddle…
  • The sheer size makes it perfect for big family breakfasts
  • PTFE/PFOA free, keeping possible autoimmune disorder risks at bay
  • Comes with a premium non-stick surface, making washing easy
  • Hard anodized pan construction provides excellent heat conductivity
  • Requires less energy to attain desired cooking temperatures
Lodge’s 100-plus years’ legacy of producing cast iron griddles makes cooking both fun and healthy. From crispy crusted pizza to moist chewy cookies, the Lodge LDP3 Reversible Grill/Griddle provides a healthy cooking environment with iron percolating into every food. Looking for bigger griddles? See Lodge LPGI3 Cast Iron Reversible Grill\/Griddle.
Lodge LDP3 Reversible Grill/Griddle, 9.5-inch x 16.75-inch

Lodge Reversible Griddle LDP3


Features
Lodge is a family brand and has carried on the cast iron cookware legacy of its founder since 1896, making it one of the oldest and most enduring cookware companies in the world.

The Lodge LDP3 Reversible Grill/Griddle, 9.5-inch x 16.75-inch is pre-seasoned and ready to use right away. This grill and griddle combo is reversible and covers 2 burners on a standard stovetop effortlessly. It also works perfectly for camping where you can simply throw it on the fire. The smooth side of this reversible griddle can be used for cooking eggs, pancakes and sandwiches while the ribbed side serves for grilling fish, chicken, etc.
Here are more features of this reversible griddle:
  • Handles for carrying or hanging when not in use
  • Seasoned cast iron for non-stick surface
  • Cast iron for even heating and heat retention
  • Cast iron leaches into the food, serving as a good source of nutritional iron
This griddle is safe for cooking on all cooking surfaces.

Get the Best Stovetop Griddle of 2018!

Now that you have taken the time to go through these reviews, we expect that you now have a better idea of the best stove top griddle for you. The ball is now in your court. Go, buy yourself a griddle and have a pleasantly memorable cooking experience!

Our Top Choice
Nordic Ware Grill & Griddle
Best Value
Utopia Kitchen Cast Iron Griddle
Calphalon Ceramic Nonstick Griddle
Cuisinart Double Burner Griddle
Lodge Double Play Reversible Griddle