Best Turkey Roaster Reviews 2018

The holidays are around the corner! Or maybe you’re looking to smoke a large quantity of meat for your annual family reunion a few days away! Whatever the case may be, having a succulent roast on the table is one of the absolutes that will create memories for years to come. Hence, the best turkey roaster remains an invaluable investment, and one that you can use to cook up a storm for many years to come. But which turkey roaster is right for your cooking adventures? We’ve taken a look through some of the best turkey roaster brands, and have narrowed down a list of five great options to cook mouth-watering turkey, roast, ham or even a cold-smoked brisket.
Overview
PROS
CONS
SPECS
Type
Size
Capacity
Material
Convenience
Our Top Choice
Cuisinart Chef's Classic 16" Roaster Pan
Cuisinart, conceived in 1971, is one of the world’s leading manufacturers of kitchen appliances, including cookware, bakeware and cutlery.
Comes with two turkey lifters, one baster, fork and knife, and a meat thermometer. Great fit for most ovens. Removable U-rack that enhances heat circulation and drains fats and oils.
Rivets used to attach the handles to the pan aren’t of the best quality.
Pan
16 inches
Up to 22-pound turkey
Stainless steel
Dishwasher safe, accessories
Best Value
Nesco Professional Electric Roaster Oven
When it comes to buying cooking appliances, Nesco is a name that will probably crop up often, mostly owing to its wide range of high-quality products.
Three different sizes and six attractive colors available. Exclusive circle of heat construction for moist results. Porcelain cookwell.
Metal baking rack may have to be replaced after a few years of use.
Electric
5, 6 or 18 quarts
Up to 22-pound turkey
Stainless steel/porcelain cookwell
Dishwasher safe, steel rack
Calphalon Tri-Ply 14-Inch Roaster
Founded in 1963, Calphalon is a premier name when it comes to aluminum and non-stick cookware such as skillets and frying pans, non-stick bakeware and cutlery.
Satin finish interior. Three layers of stainless steel to ensure consistent, even cooking. 20-pound turkey capacity. Comes with a non-stick rack and two stainless steel lifters.
Does not come with a lid.
Pan
14 inches
Up to 25-pound turkey
Try-ply stainless steel
Dishwasher safe, non-stick rack
Oster 22-Quart Stainless Steel Roaster Oven
Part of Newell Brands, Oster is a manufacturer of small appliances formed in 1923, and offers a large product range that includes blenders and juicers and kitchen tools.
26-pound turkey. Self-basting lid. Stainless steel finish. Fitted with an enamel, non-stick roasting pan for easy cleanup. Variable temperature control.
Enamel pan may discolor after several years of good use.
Electric
22 quarts
Up to 26-pound turkey
Stainless steel/non-stick pan
Dishwasher safe, self basting lid
Granite Ware Covered Oval Roaster
Granite Ware products have been welcomed into American kitchens for over 150 years. The company continues to manufacture its classic, enamel-coated cookware in Indiana.
Made in the USA. Crafted of carbon steel with a naturally non-stick porcelain cooking surface. Great choice for a 10-pound roast or 8-pound turkey. Choice of three different sizes and two colors.
Lid may be a bit wonky, so avoid stuffing it to the fullest.
Pan
15, 18 or 19 inches
Up to 18lb poultry/22lb roast
Carbon steel/porcelain non-stick
Dishwasher safe, side handles

(Updated )
Related Reviews
Best Roasting Pan
Best Thanksgiving Dinnerware Set
Best Christmas Dinnerware Set
Best Carving Knife
Watch Our Turkey roaster Review

How Do I Choose the Best Turkey Roaster?

When it comes to cooking a savory turkey, you’ve truly got several options to choose from. You can use a turkey fryer for some tasty and quick results, or a roasting pan, or a turkey roaster in your electric oven. Although buying the best turkey roaster may seem like an easy task, it can get confusing wading through the array of features and options available. But the two main aspects to consider are the size of bird or amount of food you will be cooking in one go, and whether you need an electric standalone turkey roaster or a pan with a removable rack to be placed in your home oven or stovetop. Further, you should also consider the design of the respective turkey roaster to see if fits in well with your existing appliances or can go right from the oven to the dinner table.
Price
Just like any other kitchen item, your budget is the first thing to consider, because you can easily splurge on a turkey roaster with features you will never use. Turkey roasters are available in electric models or non-electric models, i.e. roasting pans that can be placed in your oven or on the cooktop, where the former in most cases will cost a few $$$ more. Next, the size of the roaster can very well add to the price, so if you’re going to cook a medium-sized turkey with few sides (think roasted asparagus and bacon), buying a pan that occupies valuable cooking real estate may not be the most practical and cost-effective decision.

Some turkey roasters come with several accessories, such as a baster which, although it may hike up the price, works out to be more cost-effective and convenient than having to buy them separately. But, to give you a rough idea, the price for a turkey roaster ranges from about $50 for a pan that will do the trick to $100+ for a roaster that comes with a ton of bells and whistles, such as adjustable temperature controls. Stay away from cheap turkey roasters, as they may be made of sub-par materials, which can distribute the head unevenly, resulting in a disappointing turkey dinner.
Features
Choosing among the many features available with turkey roasters can drive you crazy, simply because there are just so many to choose from – some that you will never use, and others that are important to your cooking agenda.

That said, here are a few features to consider when selecting the best turkey roaster.
  • Size –This is the capacity of the pan, and determines the size of bird and amount of food that can be cooked at one go.
  • Shape –Surprisingly, turkey roasters can be ordered in an assortment of different shapes, most notably oval, rectangular and dome shaped.
  • Exterior Material –Common choices include stainless steel and non-stick.
  • Type –Some roasters are powered via an electric outlet, whereas others come in the shape of large pans to be placed in the oven or on the stovetop.
  • Weight –Pans should be solid and durable, but shouldn’t be too heavy, because you also have the weight of the bird to deal with.
  • Handles –Most pans are fitted with riveted handles to easily and safely transport them from oven to table.
  • Racks –These allow you to keep the turkey a little raised off the bottom of the roaster so that it doesn’t stick to it and also promotes even air circulation.
  • Well Material –Most turkey roasters come with some sort of removable well that not only promotes even heat distribution, but makes it easy to clean up.
  • Lid –While the sole purpose of a lid is to retain heat within the appliance, some come with self-basting lids and others without.
  • Temperature Control –Only available in electric models, some roasters allow you to adjust the temperature as desired.
  • Accessories –Tools that can make cooking a whole easier, such as a baster and meat thermometer
  • Warranty –Some turkey roasters are backed by manufacturer warranty against any factory defects.
Construction and Design
Turkey roasters can be made of several different materials, from the stainless steel models that your grandma just couldn’t live without to non-stick and cast iron. Some even come with multi-ply cladding, meaning aluminum or copper sandwiched between layers of stainless steel for even heat distribution. Stainless steel turkey roasters, however, remain a premier and highly preferred choice owing to several reasons. Most notably, they can resist high temperatures and are extremely durable.

If you’re going to go non-stick, remember that they are easy to clean, and they need to be somewhat pampered in order to prevent scratches, chipping and peeling. The next important feature to give some thought to are the handles of the respective turkey roaster, because the chances are that you’re going to be lifting a fair amount of weight to and from a hot oven. Look for handles that are secure and large enough to grip comfortably, and ones that are secured with high-quality rivets to the turkey roaster.
Performance and Ease of Use
Racks included with some turkey roasters allow you to circulate air freely within the pan. Otherwise, you’re likely to have inadequate browning at the bottom of the roast. In addition, they also allow valuable drippings to drop to the bottom of the pan, so you can easily use a baster to suck up the juices and keep the turkey moist all during the cooking process – or make gravy!

Speaking of cooking surfaces, most electric turkey roasters feature enameled interiors for great heat retention and easy cleaning in the dishwasher. Plus, most high-quality electric cookers are fitted with automatic temperature control, which allows you to set the temperature and come back when your turkey is cooked until desired. And don’t forget that the turkey roaster you buy should not only be able to accommodate the bird with ease, but should also be a good fit for your oven.

What is the Best Turkey Roaster?

Whether you’ll be hosting family and friends over the holidays or for large dinners, you should buy a turkey roaster that will deliver the best results by distributing heat well. Furthermore, since a turkey roaster pan is not something you buy often, you want to ensure the one you select is sturdy and versatile enough to be used for years to come. Apart from the design and features of a turkey roaster, it is important that the pan is able to accommodate the size of bird you will be cooking, or else you will have to cook it in two parts. But now that you’ve read our turkey roaster buying guide, you should be able to spot the best pan for your needs so, without further ado, let’s get right to them!
Our Top Choice
The Cuisinart Chef's Classic 16" Stainless Steel Roaster Pan is a large-capacity roaster that fits easily in most standard ovens, and comes with several accessories. However, if you’d like the same size roaster, but without the tools, the Cuisinart 7117-16UR Chef's Classic Rectangular Roaster may be a better choice. It, too, is made of stainless steel and is dishwasher safe for easy cleanup after a hearty meal.
Cuisinart Chef's Classic 16-Inch Stainless Steel Roaster Pan – Other Matching Cookware Also Available

Cuisinart Turkey Roaster 7117-16PS – Roaster Pan, 16”


Features
Cuisinart, an all-American company founded in 1971, bills itself as the “World’s Most Trusted” name in the kitchen, and offers a massive range of superior and thoughtfully designed products, including bakeware, cutlery, toasters, waffle makers and rice cookers.

The Cuisinart Chef's Classic 16" Stainless Steel Roaster Pan boasts a large capacity, and is crafted entirely of high-quality stainless steel. It is an easy fit for most standard-sized ovens, and is fitted with riveted, wide-grip handles for easy lifting and a removable stainless steel U-rack for Heat Surround technology, which makes it easy to drain excess fats and oils and accelerates even heat distribution. When it comes to clean-up after you’ve indulged in your succulent meal, the Cuisinart Chef's Classic turkey roaster can be placed in the dishwasher for easy maintenance. Furthermore, it comes with a wide range of accessories, including two turkey lifters, fork and knife, meat thermometer and a baster, and is backed by a limited warranty.
Best Value
The Nesco 18 Qt Professional Stainless Steel Roaster Oven features a rectangular shape, a circle of heat element and automatic temperature control. However, if you’d like a smaller, circular roaster at six quarts but with similar features, the Nesco American Harvest 6 Quart Roaster Oven is worth a second look. It boasts an extra -wide dome, complete with a self-basting cover for moist results.
Nesco Professional Electric Roaster Oven – Available in Multiple Designs & Sizes

Nesco Turkey Roaster 4818-25PR – 18 Qt, Porcelain Cookwell, Stainless Steel


Features
Nesco is an esteemed name in the kitchen, and offers an expansive lineup of products that includes roaster ovens, dehydrators and small appliances such as food grinders, food slicers, toasters, pressure and slow cookers.

The Nesco turkey roaster is crafted from stainless steel with a dishwasher-safe porcelain cook well, and showcases a large, 16-quart capacity to accommodate up to a 22-pound turkey. It can be ordered in a choice of three different sizes and six colors, and is fitted with an adjustable temperature control to adjust the heat between 200 degrees and 450 degrees to help you achieve the results you desire. Plus, this turkey roaster features circle of heat construction that emits heat from the sides rather than from the bottom for moist results. It comes with a chrome steel rack, and is a joy to clean and store away.
The Calphalon Tri-Ply Stainless Steel 14-In. Roaster features an aluminum core and comes with a non-stick V-rack. But if you’d like to buy a completely non-stick turkey roaster, albeit one that’s slightly bigger at 16 inches, the Calphalon Contemporary Hard Anodized 16” Roasting Pan makes an excellent choice. It is dishwasher safe and comes with a five-piece set that includes two stainless steel lifters and an injection baster.
Calphalon Tri-Ply Stainless Steel 14-Inch Roaster with Nonstick Rack & Stainless Steel Lifters – Other Matching Cookware Also Available

Calphalon Turkey Roaster 1767986 – 14-Inch, Roaster


Features
Calphalon, a company founded in 1963, is a manufacturer and distributor of a wide array of products, including anodized and non-stick cookware, such as griddle and grill pans, soup pots and stockpots, bakeware sets and knife sets.

The Calphalon turkey roaster is made of 3-ply aluminum and rings in with an aluminum core for even heat cooking. Its non-porous cooking surface makes it safe to use with all utensils, and its brushed stainless steel exterior makes it a great choice for both the oven and dining table. Further, it is fitted with stainless steel, triple-riveted handles, making it sturdy enough to carry up to a 25-pound turkey. This turkey roaster comes with two stainless steel lifters, a non-stick V-rack and ultimate heat circulation, and is dishwasher safe for easy maintenance. To seal the deal, the Calphalon turkey roaster and its included accessories are backed by an impressive lifetime warranty, making it a reliable choice for many years to come.
The Oster 22-Quart Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid can accommodate up to a massive 26-pound turkey and comes in a silver finish. However, if you don’t see yourself cooking a bird that big, the Oster CKSTRS18-BSB 18-Quart Roaster Oven may be what you’re looking for. It too features a self-basting lid, but can cook up to a 22-pound turkey with its 18-quart capacity and showcases a black finish.
Oster 22-Quart Stainless Steel Roaster Oven - Available With & Without Self-Basting Lid

Oster Turkey Roaster CKSTRS23-SB – Self-Basting Lid


Features
Founded by John Oster in 1923, Oster took flight by manufacturing manually powered hair clippers, and was acquired in 1960 by mega kitchen brand Sunbeam. Today, Oster still continues to design and manufacture a diverse range of kitchen products, including blenders and juicers, ovens and toasters and parts and accessories.

The Oster turkey roaster boasts a massive 22-quart capacity that makes it good enough to roast up to a 26-pound bird. It features a stainless steel finish, and is fitted with an enamel steel roasting pan that is dishwasher safe for easy cleanup. Plus, it comes with a self-basting lid that constantly re-circulates the juices, eliminating the need to use that tedious hand baster to achieve moist results. Fitted with an adjustable temperature control knob (between 150 degree F and 450 degree F), the Oster 22-quart turkey roaster can cook anything your regular oven would, and makes an ideal choice for small and large gatherings, social functions and special events.
The Granite Ware 15-Inch Covered Oval Roaster features carbon steel construction complete with a porcelain non-stick surface. However, if you’d like the same qualities as the 15-inch oval roaster, such as dishwasher-safe convenience, only in a round design, the Granite Ware 0517 Covered Round Roaster Pan is probably what you’re looking for. It is safer to use than foil roasters, and offers even heat distribution for great results.
Granite Ware Covered Oval Roaster - Available in 3 Sizes and 2 Colors

Granite Ware Turkey Roaster 0508-2 – 15 Inches, Black


Features
Brought to you by Columbian Home Products, Granite Ware has served American kitchens for over 150 years. Their enamel-coated cookware continues to create headlines, and has helped transform everyday meals and holiday meals into cherished memories.

The Granite Ware turkey roaster features an oval shape, and can be had in three different sizes and two colors – black and brown. This 15-inch roaster makes a great choice for a 8-pound roast or 10-pound turkey, and is made of robust carbon steel that not only absorbs heat well, but also distributes it evenly and quickly. Moving to the interior, it features a porcelain cooking surface that is naturally non-stick, dishwasher safe and safe to use with metal utensils. Made in the USA, the Granite Ware turkey roaster is fitted with side handles to easily move it around, and topped with a dimpled lid to baste foods for moist results.

Get the Best Turkey Roaster of 2018!

You now know what to consider when shopping for the best turkey roaster, and since we’ve revealed the five best options available, buying one is just a few clicks away.

Our Top Choice
Cuisinart Chef's Classic 16" Roaster Pan
Best Value
Nesco Professional Electric Roaster Oven
Calphalon Tri-Ply 14-Inch Roaster
Oster 22-Quart Stainless Steel Roaster Oven
Granite Ware Covered Oval Roaster